Why a Dividend-Growth Stock Is Safer Than a Dividend Stock

I compare TransAlta Corporation (TSX:TA)(NYSE:TAC) and Fortis Inc. (TSX:FTS) and illustrate how a dividend-growth stock is a better investment than a dividend stock that just maintains its dividend.

| More on:

Dividend-growth stocks are stocks that have a history of increasing dividends. Dividends are powerful because they can be used to pay bills, buy food, or they can be reinvested for more shares and income.

Dividends are a way for businesses to return profits to shareholders, and typically only mature companies do this. These companies earn consistent earnings and cash flows to be able to continue paying dividends.

I emphasize dividend-growth stocks here because no matter which perspective you use to look at it, dividend-growth stocks are more powerful than dividend stocks. Why? Well, your income is not simply maintained. It grows! Plus, the safest dividend is the one that was just increased.

Why is a dividend-growth stock safer?

I would call TransAlta Corporation (TSX:TA)(NYSE:TAC) a dividend stock. It used to pay a quarterly dividend of 29 cents from 2009 to 2013. Now it only pays a quarterly dividend of 18 cents. So, shareholders have experienced a 38% cut in their income from their investment.

On the other hand, Fortis Inc. (TSX:FTS) has increased dividends for more than 40 years! In fact, it just increased its quarterly dividend by 10.3%–three times the rate of inflation.

Now you can see why TransAlta has a yield of 13.2%, while Fortis only has a yield of 4%. Obviously, the former is much riskier. The market requires it to have a higher yield to assume the higher risk.

Why did TransAlta perform so badly compared with Fortis?

From 2009 to 2014, TransAlta’s earnings per share (EPS) went from 90 cents to 25 cents, a drop of 72%. At the start of January 2009 its shares traded around $25. Today, it’s at $5.45, a drop of 78%.

In the same period, Fortis’s EPS grew from $1.51 to $1.81, a rise of close to 20%. At the start of January 2009 Fortis’s shares traded around $25. Today, it’s at $38, a rise of 52%.

So, while an investment in TransAlta fell 38%, an equal investment in Fortis would have seen income rise by 44%. From 2009 to the present, Fortis’s quarterly dividend increased from 26 cents to 37.5 cents per share.

Conclusion

Utilities are supposed to be very stable businesses because they provide needed products and services. However, Foolish investors should know that not all businesses are the same, even in the same sector or industry.

Going forward, Fortis will see an average 6% increase in the dividend per year through 2020. If I had to choose between TransAlta and Fortis today, I would not hesitate to choose Fortis.

Now, I’m not saying TransAlta is a bad investment, as it could very well be a potential turnaround investment, but I don’t know that for certain.

Fool contributor Kay Ng owns shares of FORTIS INC.

More on Dividend Stocks

Child measures his height on wall. He is growing taller.
Dividend Stocks

The $109,000 TFSA Milestone: How Do You Stack Up?

Most investors hit the $109,000 TFSA milestone with consistent contributions, not one big deposit.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Stocks to Buy for a “Pay Me First” Portfolio

A “pay me first” portfolio focuses on dividends that are supported by real cash flow, not headline yields.

Read more »

Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem
Dividend Stocks

The Bank of Canada Speaks Up Again: Here’s What to Buy for a TFSA Now

With rates steady, a balanced TFSA can blend dependable income, a discounted yield opportunity, and long-run growth.

Read more »

three friends eat pizza
Dividend Stocks

A 5.9% Dividend Stock Paying Out Monthly Cash

Boston Pizza’s royalty fund turns restaurant sales into monthly cash, offering a simpler income model than owning a full restaurant…

Read more »

woman stares at chocolate layer cake
Dividend Stocks

$50K TFSA: How to Structure for Constant Income

A $50,000 TFSA can produce “always-on” income by layering a high-yield booster between two steadier stocks.

Read more »

middle-aged couple work together on laptop
Dividend Stocks

Canadians: Here’s the TFSA Amount You Need to Retire, Plus 3 Stocks to Get There

You'll want to use a sustainable withdrawal rate to figure out your goal.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Investors: Here’s the Only Time Using a Taxable Account Is a Better Choice

Surprisingly, it can make sense to hold Fortis (TSX:FTS) stock in a taxable account.

Read more »

moving into apartment
Dividend Stocks

The Perfect TFSA Stock: A 6.7% Yield With Monthly Paycheques

Northview Residential REIT offers monthly TFSA income with an improving operating story, while still trading below book value.

Read more »