Get Energy Exposure: Funds vs. Individual Stocks

To capitalize on the upside of energy, should you invest in a stock such as Vermilion Energy Inc. (TSX:VET)(NYSE:VET) or a fund?

oil, petroleum, refinery

If oil prices rise, the junior oil companies tend to perform better than bigger oil companies. However, it’s anyone’s guess who the winners will be.

Interested investors can gain exposure to the junior group via the BMO Junior Oil Index ETF (TSX:ZJO). The fund seeks to replicate the performance of the Dow Jones North America Select Junior Oil Index. The ETF holds micro- to medium-cap companies in the oil and gas producers or oil equipment, services and distribution sectors.

After a meaningful 20% pullback from late 2016, the BMO Junior Oil Index ETF has experienced an uptick recently. The fund can head higher if it breaks above a major resistance at roughly $15.61.

Lower your risk with the fund

The benefit of investing in the fund is that you get to significantly lower your risk by spreading it across many junior oil companies while gaining access to capture any upside to higher oil prices.

The fund has about 67% in U.S. equities, 22% in Canadian equities, and 11% in international equities. Its top 10 holdings make up 43% of the fund. Among them are Vermilion Energy Inc. (TSX: VET)(NYSE: VET) and Whitecap Resources Inc. (TSX: WCP), which take the fourth and 10th spots, respectively, of the fund.

oil pump 16-9

Get more income from individual companies

Although you can lower your risk by investing in the fund, you can get a higher yield by being selective in the energy stocks you buy.

The BMO Junior Oil Index ETF currently offers a tiny yield of less than 0.80%. Additionally, it has a 0.55% management fee.

So, essentially, the income component of the returns is negligible, and investors can expect to get the majority of the returns from potential price appreciation of the fund.

Both Vermilion Energy and Whitecap offer higher yields than the fund. They yield 5.1% and 2.7%, respectively, from their recent quotations.

Dividends can lower the risk too

By buying energy companies with sustainable dividends, you can lower your risk. With each dividend you receive, you can view it as getting a part of your investment back. If price appreciation doesn’t happen, you can still get a return from dividends.

Between Vermilion Energy and Whitecap, I’d put my bets on the former, which maintained its dividend through the energy downturn. Since 2003, Vermilion hasn’t slashed its dividend and even raised it three times.

Moreover, Vermilion Energy maintains a globally diversified portfolio with operations in Canada, the United States, France, Ireland, the Netherlands, Germany, and Australia. Its production mix includes 52% natural gas, 44% oil, and 4% natural gas liquids. It enjoys higher European gas prices, which contributes 31% of its cash flows.

Investor takeaway

If you are bullish on energy, you can capture any potential upside via the BMO Junior Oil Index ETF. If you prefer to get a nice income, you can consider strong dividend payers, such as Vermilion Energy.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Dividend Stocks

This Dividend Stock Is Down 13% in the Past Year, but the Payout Looks Safe

A 13% share-price decline has lifted this dividend stock’s yield to 6.8%, while strong liquidity and recurring revenue continue to…

Read more »

Agricultural irrigation sprinkler gun spraying water
Dividend Stocks

How to Diversify Your Portfolio Beyond Canadian Banks

These top TSX stocks could help you move beyond bank-heavy portfolios without giving up established businesses and dividends.

Read more »

man calculates finances
Dividend Stocks

With Interest Rates Rising, Are Canadian Dividend Stocks Still Worth Buying?

Three questions to ask before investing in a dividend stock, especially as bond yields grow more attractive.

Read more »

woman looks at iPhone
Dividend Stocks

Telus’s Dividend Explained: Is It Safe to Buy for Income Today?

Here’s why Telus’s 6.2% dividend looks more sustainable today and how paying out less could make it a better long-term…

Read more »

hiker with backpack in the mountains
Dividend Stocks

How a $20,000 TFSA Could Fund Your Retirement

These two dividend-paying TSX stocks could help turn a $20,000 TFSA into a stronger source of retirement income.

Read more »

concept of growth
Dividend Stocks

3 TSX Dividend Stocks for Reliable Passive Income

These TSX dividend stocks are backed by established operations, consistent earnings growth, and a sustainable payout ratio.

Read more »

man gives stopping gesture
Dividend Stocks

A No-Spend Month Could Jump-Start Your Emergency Savings

Join the No-Spend Month challenge to take control of your finances and discover the benefits of minimal spending habits.

Read more »

Young adult concentrates on laptop screen
Dividend Stocks

Opening Your First Investing Account in Canada: What to Know Before You Click “Apply”

Don’t chase returns without first understanding risks.

Read more »