5 Reasons Canada’s Housing Market Won’t Crash as the Market in the U.S. Did 10 Years Ago

The Canadian housing market may be on the verge of a correction, but here are five good reasons why the market and lender Home Capital Group Inc. (TSX:HCG) won’t suffer the same fate as the U.S. markets did 10 years ago.

Much has been made over the past decade of Canada’s rising household debt, which is now at levels similar to those in the United States prior to the 2008-09 Financial Crisis.

With housing prices in Toronto up more than 30% over the past 12 months, and Vancouver prices having been inflated for several years, many are wondering: now that the Bank of Canada has raised interest rates twice in the last three months, will it be enough to topple the Canadian housing market?

There are five very important reasons why investors should not expect a housing correction in the Canadian market to be of nearly the same magnitude as the one experienced in the United States 10 years ago.

Reason #1: The United States incentivizes home ownership

In the U.S., federal policy actively encourages home ownership, whereas in Canada, policies are designed to encourage access to housing, but they do not explicitly favour home ownership over renting or leasing a property.

It seems then only natural to suggest that creating incentives for home ownership (like, for example, allowing mortgage interest to be tax deductible in the U.S.) would be more likely to create an environment ripe for a housing bubble.

Reason #2: Canada’s housing market is directly backed by the Federal government

In the U.S., Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are responsible for providing guarantees on mortgage-backed securities and providing overall stability to the housing system.

At the time of the Financial Crisis, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were privately owned, with the “implicit” backing of the Federal government. Yet, when push came to shove, investors learned the hard way the difference between an implicit guarantee and direct backing.

By comparison, the Canadian equivalent responsible for providing insurance and stability, is the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) — a Crown corporation directly owned by the Canadian Federal government.

Reason #3: Canada does not allow non-recourse mortgages

In Canada, mortgages are typically “full-recourse” loans, meaning the borrower continues to be responsible for repaying the loan in the event of a foreclosure, which effectively incentivizes the borrower to do everything in their power to avoid foreclosing and losing the property.

Meanwhile, many U.S. states employ “non-recourse” mortgages, which, in the event of a foreclosure, allow the borrower to walk away from their homes, leaving the lender with no-recourse besides taking over ownership of the property.

It’s easy to see how non-recourse mortgages can exacerbate the problem of homeowners defaulting on their payments.

Reason #4: Canada has tighter restrictions on mortgage insurance

Canadian legislation prohibits lenders from issuing mortgages without loan insurance if the loan is greater than 80% of the value of the property.

Insurance which is purchased from the CMHC covers the entire amount of the loan for the entire life of the mortgage.

In the U.S., it is a little different; while many lenders will require insurance, they are not legally obligated to do so.

Moreover, in the U.S., loan insurance is “partial,” often covering 20-30% of the loan amount and is cancelled as soon as the value of the loan falls below 78% of the purchase price.

Reason #5: The relative absence of a subprime market in Canada

Sub-prime mortgages are made to riskier borrowers, such as those with a weaker credit history or less stable income.

In the U.S., before the housing crisis, the sub-prime mortgage market peaked at 23.5% of all mortgage originations.

By contrast, in Canada today, the sub-prime mortgage market, which includes Home Capital Group Inc. (TSX: HCG), accounts for less than 5% of originations, making the market significantly less risky.

Conclusion

Regardless of how you look at it, rising interest rates are not a good omen for the future of Canada’s housing market. And while delinquencies today are well below historical averages, that may actually be confirming evidence that a bubble is present.

Current and prospective homeowners should approach the market with caution. Those warning that the “sky is falling” and that the environment is similar to the situation in the U.S. 10 years ago, ought to think a bit more Foolishly.

Fool contributor Jason Phillips owns shares in Home Capital Group Inc.

More on Dividend Stocks

Investor wonders if it's safe to buy stocks now
Dividend Stocks

Enbridge Stock: Is It Still a Top Passive Income Pick for Retirees?

Enbridge's attractive 5.7% dividend yield, improving cash flows, and massive growth backlog make it a compelling passive income stock for…

Read more »

earn passive income by investing in dividend paying stocks
Dividend Stocks

$10,000 in Your TFSA: 2 Stocks to Buy for Passive Income

Given their well-established businesses, reliable cash flows, consistent dividend payouts, and high yields, these two Canadian stocks are ideal for…

Read more »

Colored pins on calendar showing a month
Dividend Stocks

What $40,000 in a Dividend Portfolio Could Pay Without Selling Shares

A $40,000 portfolio can help with recurring bills even if you leave every share in the account. Here’s what three…

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Passive Income: Is Enbridge Stock Still a Buy for Its Dividend Yield?

Enbridge’s resilient cash flow profile, solid payout history, and a growing earnings base strengthen its appeal as a high yield…

Read more »

diversification and asset allocation are crucial investing concepts
Dividend Stocks

How Many Enbridge Shares You Need for $1,000 in Dividends

Enbridge pays $3.88 a share. At $68.59, you need 258 shares, about $17,696, to earn $1,000 a year in annual…

Read more »

boy in bowtie and glasses gives positive thumbs up
Dividend Stocks

3 Blue-Chip Dividend Stocks Every Canadian Should Own

These Canadian blue-chip dividend stocks are known for consistently paying and increasing their dividends year after year.

Read more »

up arrow on wooden blocks
Dividend Stocks

Standout Canadian Blue-Chip Stocks to Own in 2027

Explore Canadian blue-chip stocks for 2027, with Canadian National, Fortis and Manulife offering distinct paths to earnings growth and dividend…

Read more »

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Dividend Stocks

4.2% Yield: 1 Perfect TFSA Dividend Stock Paying Every Month

Whitecap Resources pays monthly, yields roughly 4.2%, and just boosted its dividend and cut debt by $1.3 billion. See why…

Read more »