Methanex (TSX:MX) vs. Nutrien (TSX:NTR): 1 Materials Stock Wins After a Mad Summer

Methanex Corp. (TSX:MX)(NASDAQ:MEOH) and its closest competitor have drifted apart after a tumultuous summer in the markets.

| More on:

Today, I’m going to compare two close competitors in the materials and chemicals industry and see which one looks like the strongest buy. Not that long ago, the two stocks below weren’t that dissimilar, but after a tough summer for the markets the pair has grown further apart in terms of valuation and outlook.


Methanex seems to have its industry cornered. This is a great defensive stock, with a market cap of $8 billion making it sizable enough to reassure all but the queasiest of investors. A one-year past earnings growth of 65.8% compares a little unfavourably with an industry average for the same 12 months of 104.7%, but smashes its own five-year average past earnings growth of just 2%.

At $97.81, Methanex is overvalued by $20 a share compared to its future cash flow value. This overvaluation wouldn’t be apparent were to go by a P/E ratio of 16.5 times earnings alone. With a negative PEG denoting a lack of expected growth, a P/B of 4.1 times book rounds out a handful of multiples that do indeed suggest that this is an overpriced stock at present. Competitors include Air Products and Chemicals and Valero Energy, though value investors may be hard pressed to find comparable value, overheated as those variables might be.

Is it worth a punt, though growth investors looking at a 4.1% expected contraction in earnings over the next couple of years might say no. The rest of its data is similarly mixed: a decent return on equity of 26% last year and dividend yield of 1.76% (which could be higher, to be honest), contend with a high debt level of 85.8% of net worth. Inside selling has been quite high in the last 12 months, though the last few months have seen some inside buying.


It’s hardly a surprise to follow the methanol superstar with the wunderkind of agri chemicals; what is a surprise though is how much this stock has changed since earlier this year. While a high market cap is nothing new (Nutrien’s is $43 billion), a one-year past earnings growth of 143.7% easily beats Methanex as well as the rest of the sector and totally sets fire to its own five-year average past earnings contraction of 40.3%.

However, this is not a cheap stock at the moment: overvalued by almost double its future cash flow value, Nutrien now has a very high P/E of 62.8 times earnings, making it look a bit like a FAANG stock. A PEG of four times growth is pretty high for the TSX, though a P/B of 1.4 times book suggests that you’re not wasting too much money in terms of assets.

A 15.6% expected annual growth in earnings over the next one to three years may mark this stock out as a contender for your growth portfolio, while a dividend yield of 2.96% should satisfy some passive-income investors. Close competitors include the aforementioned Methanex and the U.S. industrial gases company Praxair, which would-be investors should check out for a comparison.

The return on equity was only 3% last year last year, suggesting that better use could have been made of the funds pumped into this stock, though there has been more inside buying than selling in the last 12-month period. A debt level of 50.9% of net worth could definitely be lower, though it is by no means the highest on the TSX.

The bottom line

This is a fine duo to slip straight into your portfolio. Though it may not look diversified, since both stocks are concerned with Canadian chemicals, the fact is that agricultural potash and industrial methanol are vastly different beasts. If you have to pick just one, I would suggest buying Nutrien, purely since food security is arguably a more immediate necessity in the emerging markets than non-agricultural industrial chemicals; a higher dividend yield and lower debt are sound financial arguments for this choice as well.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Victoria Hetherington has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Nutrien is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Dividend Stocks

worry concern
Dividend Stocks

Worried About a Recession? 2 Canadian Blue-Chip Stocks to Buy and Hold for Dear Life

A recession is worrisome. Buying two blue-chip TSX stocks and holding them for the long term will deliver stable, less…

Read more »

money cash dividends
Dividend Stocks

TFSA: 3 of the Best Canadian Dividend Stocks to Buy This Year

Are you looking for some of the best Canadian Dividend stocks to buy this year? Here are three great options…

Read more »

Man data analyze
Dividend Stocks

2 Recession-Tough Stocks to Buy in February 2023

TSX stocks, such as Jamieson Wellness, are trading at compelling valuations and might deliver stellar gains to investors.

Read more »

A worker overlooks an oil refinery plant.
Dividend Stocks

Defensive Investors: 3 Stocks to Shore Up Your Portfolio

Fortis is a defensive stock with an impressive track record.

Read more »

edit Woman calculating figures next to a laptop
Dividend Stocks

Passive Income: 2 Cheap Stocks to Buy and Never Sell

Buying dividend stocks cheap and discounted is a strategy many value investors pursue to maximize the return potential.

Read more »

Female friends enjoying their dessert together at a mall
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Stocks: Will Debt Load Put a Damper on This Top Stock in 2023?

This dividend stock has a very solid track record of revenue and cash flow growth, ,as well as dividend growth,…

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Dividend Stocks

How to Invest in One of the Most Important Commodities in the World (It’s Not Gold)

Many things we take for granted may offer economic value and a powerful investment opportunity beyond commodities like gold or…

Read more »

growing plant shoots on stacked coins
Dividend Stocks

Need Passive Income? Turn $15,000 Into $1,016 Annually With These 2 Dividend Stocks

Canadian investors with limited capital can create passive-income streams from two high-yield dividend stocks.

Read more »