Which of These 2 Energy Stocks Is Right for You?

The market is rich for oil and gas marketing and refining companies right now. But do you buy Cenovus Energy Inc (TSX:CVE)(NYSE:CVE), up 23% so far in 2019, or its 5.52%-yielding rival?

| More on:

Shares of oil and gas marketing and refining companies appear to offer investors pretty solid value right across the board these days. And there’s good reason for that.

Thanks to major advancements in hydraulic fracturing over the past decade, the U.S. (the world’s largest consumer of energy, including oil and gas products) has gone from being a net importer to a net exporter today.

While environmentalists may be quick to point to the dangers of hydraulic fracturing and the risks that it presents for our natural environment, the one thing we do know is that the widespread acceptance and adoption of  “fracking” technology among oil and gas exploration companies in recent years has played a major role in reducing the financial burden of energy for consumers and businesses alike. Well, maybe for some out there more than others.

Because while the price of a barrel of crude oil has fallen from north of US$100 a few years ago to frequently below US$50 in recent years, prices for refined crude products like gasoline and diesel haven’t fallen by nearly the same amount.

Sure, the cost to fill up your fuel tank at the local gas station might be a little cheaper than at its peak, but in most major Canadian markets, drivers today are paying roughly what they did back at the start of the decade when the price of oil was still above the US$80 mark.

That isn’t great news for the average Canadian commuter, but it is pretty good news for the oil and gas refining and marketing companies that buy crude stock from producers at cheap prices and pass it along to consumers along with a hefty mark-up.

Down to brass tacks

There are two companies on the Canadian side of things in this space that I really like right now.

One of them is Cenovus Energy (TSX:CVE)(NYSE:CVE) and the other is Husky Energy (TSX:HSE).

Both stocks have been punished in recent years (in my opinion, not quite fairly).

CVE lost the faith of markets after it took on mountains of debt to pay for the ConocoPhillips assets that it did not already own in a massive, multi-billion-dollar deal.

Husky, meanwhile, is a more highly levered operation, and as gas prices have come off their highs over the past 12 months or so, HSE stock has suffered an outsized punch to the throat (so to speak).

Still, the HSE shares pay a 5.52% dividend, trades at less than 0.5 time its reported book value, and has a price-to-earnings ratio of just 6.5 times.

The fact that its shares are now in a deeply oversold condition and trading at their lowest point in the past 52 weeks only serves to make this a more appetizing value play for contrarian-minded investors.

CVE is generating hoards of cash at the moment, and while it still has a way to go before it gets its books completely back in order and sufficiently raises its dividend payout to the point where it can truly be on par with a company like Husky, investing is very much a forward-looking endeavour. In this respect, I have to believe that with CVE, it’s more a matter of being patient with the market’s disposition to this company than anything else.

Foolish bottom line

Long term, I’m a Cenovus bull for the reasons outlined above, but if you were to ask me which stock I thought would outperform over the next few weeks or so, I would probably have to put my money on the side of HSE stock.

Fool contributor Jason Phillips owns shares in Cenovus Energy Inc.

More on Dividend Stocks

telehealth stocks
Dividend Stocks

This TSX Stock Pays a 4.3% Dividend Every Single Month

This TSX stock pays you cash every single month – and it’s backed by a growing, essential business.

Read more »

3 colorful arrows racing straight up on a black background.
Dividend Stocks

2 Great Warren Buffett Stocks to Buy Before They Raise Their Dividends Again

If you want to invest like Warren Buffett, these two top Canadian dividend stocks are some of the best picks…

Read more »

Map of Canada with city lights illuminated
Dividend Stocks

A Dirt-Cheap Canadian Dividend Growth Stock Built for the Long Haul

A dirt‑cheap Canadian dividend growth stock offering stability, steady income, and reliable annual payout increases for long‑term investors.

Read more »

middle-aged couple work together on laptop
Dividend Stocks

Turn Dividends Into Paydays: 2 Top TSX Stocks for Reliable Monthly Income

Exchange Income Corp. (TSX:EIF) and another monthly payer worth buying up on strength.

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Investors: 1 Perfect Monthly Dividend Stock With a 7.7% Yield

This grocery-anchored REIT aims to deliver reliable monthly TFSA income, but its payout coverage is the key metric to watch.

Read more »

runner checks her biodata on smartwatch
Dividend Stocks

A Perfect March TFSA With a 3.1% Monthly Payout

This Canadian stock combines monthly income with long-term growth in the booming energy sector.

Read more »

Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem
Dividend Stocks

Interest Rates Aren’t Falling: Here’s What I’d Do With My TFSA

Here's how higher interest rates impact Canadian stocks and how to position your TFSA in the current environment.

Read more »

chatting concept
Dividend Stocks

3 Blue-Chip Dividend Stocks for Canadian Investors

Looking for growing income and steady growth? These Canadian blue-chip stocks are best in class and long-term value creators.

Read more »