Dividends vs. Growth: Which Is the Better Option for Investors?

Canada Goose Holdings Inc (TSX:GOOS)(NYSE:GOOS) has been one of the best growth stocks on the TSX in recent years, but it’s far from a risk-free investment.

One of the biggest considerations an investor will make is whether to invest in a stock that generates a good dividend or one that’s focused on growth. With the exception of a very small dividend being offered, growth stocks normally won’t offer any sort of yield, as they’ll require the cash to help fund future growth and expansion.

That makes the decision of deciding on whether to invest in growth stocks or dividend stocks an important one.

Potential returns make growth stocks much more valuable

A good example of a strong growth stock is Canada Goose Holdings (TSX: GOOS)(NYSE: GOOS), which has achieved significant sales growth since listing on the TSX. Its quality products are made locally and have won over both investors and consumers alike. And with the company selling online as well, it has made it easier to sell its winter clothing year-round.

Last year, the stock climbed 50%. This year, however, things have been a lot more volatile, and the stock has fallen in value, down around 10% heading into trading on Wednesday. While there’s no doubt that double-digit returns will eclipse the dividends that can be earned from a bank stock like Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX: CM)(NYSE: CM), there’s also more risk of a sell-off happening.

At a price-to-earnings ratio of more than 40, Canada Goose is an expensive stock to own, and that makes it easy to justify selling it when economic conditions are not ideal. Growth stocks are all about increasing their sales and profits as much as possible, and unfortunately, the first hint of a struggle could trigger a lot of selling, which is what happened earlier this year when Canada Goose’s quarterly results were not as strong as investors were hoping for.

If you plan to invest your money for many years, then growth stocks could be appealing since you have the flexibility to wait out any corrections that may take place. However, if you’re primarily focused on stability or recurring income, then that’s where dividend stocks may be more suitable for your needs.

When dividend stocks reign supreme

CIBC’s stock is yielding more than 5.2% per year, and that means that even with a modest return, it could help grow your portfolio by more than 10%. The benefit of a stock like CIBC is that it isn’t trading at obscene multiples, and that means there’s less room for a possible correction.

The problem for CIBC this year is that with a negative outlook for the economy, it and other bank stocks have struggled to rally and make up for disappointing performances in 2018. But with a beta of around 1.2, CIBC will closely follow the direction of the markets.

The good news is that with the dividend income, investors of CIBC are making out a bit better than the stock’s returns would indicate. And unlike with growth stocks, there’s more of a likelihood that a stock like CIBC will recover from a fall in price simply because it’s more fairly priced and trading at reasonable multiples.

Bottom line

Which path you choose, growth or dividends, ultimately comes down to your investing profile and how much risk you’re willing to tolerate. Although there’s no simple answer to which strategy is best, in good economic times, growth stocks can produce stronger returns, while under more adverse conditions, dividend stocks can be very helpful in improving your portfolio’s overall performance.

Fool contributor David Jagielski has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

Agricultural harvesting at the last light of day, aerial view.
Dividend Stocks

Ottawa Just Put $1 Billion Into Food Security: This Fertilizer Giant Feeds Off It

Ottawa’s food-security fund could support agriculture, but Nutrien’s investment case depends on farm economics and company cash flow.

Read more »

dividends grow over time
Dividend Stocks

How to Avoid a Big Tax Bill on Your RRSP in Retirement

A proven drawdown strategy can help avoid a big tax hit on your RRSP in retirement.

Read more »

customer uses bank ATM
Dividend Stocks

I Found a 5.6% Dividend Stock That Pays Monthly, Like an ATM for Your Retirement

With a 5.6% annualized yield, growing rental income, and monthly payouts, this Canadian REIT could help turn your retirement portfolio…

Read more »

concept of growth
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Passive Income: Should You Buy This Dividend-Growth Stock for the 6% Yield?

This stock has delivered annual dividend increases for more than 30 years.

Read more »

people sit in two wooden beach chairs facing the Caribbean ocean holding drinks and making a toast
Dividend Stocks

Can You Really Live Off Dividends? A Realistic Look at the Numbers

Can you live off dividends? See how much you would need to invest, what BNS, CU, and ZWC could pay,…

Read more »

ETFs can contain investments such as stocks
Dividend Stocks

This Monthly Income ETF Yields 6% and I Think Retirees Should Give it a Closer Look

The Purpose Global Bond Fund offers Canadian retirees a steady 6% yield and monthly payouts. Discover how the ETF can…

Read more »

dividends can compound over time
Dividend Stocks

I’d Rather Own SmartCentres at 98.1% Occupancy Than Chase a Bigger Yield

Before you chase a bigger yield, consider SmartCentres’ 98.1% occupancy, 6.9% yield, and the cash flow supporting its monthly distribution.

Read more »

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Dividend Stocks

Enbridge vs. Canadian Natural Resources: Where I’d Put My Next $10,000

Let’s compare Enbridge and CNQ to see which offers the better mix of dividend income and growth potential.

Read more »