How to Earn Big TFSA Income That the Canada Revenue Agency Can’t Tax

You could make over $9k per year tax-free with securities like American Hotel Income Properties (TSX:HOT.UN) in your TFSA.

Unless you’re one of the lucky ones to land major multi-baggers that swelled your TFSA past the million-dollar mark, I think it’s safe to say that any TFSA income stream you make for yourself today will be free from taxation.

The TFSA is a gift to Canadians courtesy of the federal government.

Unfortunately, many Canadians aren’t using the gift to build their wealth and are just using it as a store for cash and bonds. Hoarding such “risk-free” instruments in your TFSA comes with unfathomable and astronomical opportunity costs.

Gone are the days where you can score an over 7% yield on your fixed-income securities without having to risk your shirt. So, if you’re young and letting your cash collect dust in your TFSA, it’s time to make some changes so you can put your TFSA proceeds to work for you.

How high are the opportunity costs of leaving your cash in TFSA “high” interest savings accounts?

Consider an extreme example with a high-yield security such as American Hotel Income Properties REIT (TSX: HOT.UN), a relatively small hotel REIT with a $510 million market cap that currently sports a massive 13.2% yield.

Shares of AHIP have been in a world of pain over the last few years, and the distribution payout is now undoubtedly stretched. If you’ve got what it takes to be a contrarian and think that AHIP can turn its ship around, you could lock-in the 13.2% yield, which would be yours to keep (based on your invested principal), even if shares were to recover in a turnaround scenario.

Come 2020, Canadians should have $69,500 (not including interest) in their TFSAs if they just made regular contributions and sat it in a savings account. If invested entirely in AHIP, one would stand to collect $9,174 per year, not a penny of which is subject to taxation.

Who couldn’t use such a boost to their annual income?

This HOT property could burn a hole in your wallet

Unfortunately, a super-high-yielder like AHIP comes with its fair share of baggage — and isn’t without its risks. The company has been treading water for awhile, and investors must understand the situation so they’re not left holding the bag in the event that AHIP slashes its distribution.

The REIT’s strategic pivot away from economy hotels toward premium branded hotels is encouraging for longer-term AFFO growth, but in its current state, there is apparent financial pressure.

The AFFO payout ratio is over 100%, and AFFOs growth has been in the red of late (AFFOs fell around 4% in the last quarter), both of which don’t bode well for the health of the distribution.

Fortunately, the REIT can easily avoid a distribution reduction as it continues to make changes for the better. AHIP’s property improvement plan (PIP) is going quite well, with many projects coming under budget (good news given AHIP’s “tight” financial position).

Whether AHIP will be a rebound candidate in the new year remains to be seen, but if you’re willing to take on a bit of risk, the potential rewards could be massive.

Continued successful execution of the PIP could bolster AFFOs and relieve a bit of financial pressure caused by the now colossal distribution.

Foolish takeaway

AHIP is a high-risk/high-reward bet, but it’s just one extreme example of what you could do with the funds sitting in your TFSA. If all goes well with a super-high-yielder like AHIP, you could enjoy more than $9,000 per year in tax-free income alongside potential capital gains.

Given the progress with AHIP’s PIP, I’d say the distribution is safer than most would think in spite of its ominous triple-digit payout ratio.

Stay hungry. Stay Foolish.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

concept of growth
Dividend Stocks

The Dividend Stock I’d Never Sell, Even in a Downturn

Fortis is a dividend stock I'd hold through a downturn. Its regulated utilities and dividend growth support a patient approach…

Read more »

frustrated shopper at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks Retirees Can Count on for Decades

These two Canadian dividend stocks offer a great mix of essential businesses, regular dividends, and long-term growth investments that could…

Read more »

customer comparison shops in liquor store
Dividend Stocks

How Much TFSA Income Triggers an OAS Clawback?

The OAS clawback is based on net world income, with a 2025 minimum recovery threshold of $93,454, not on a…

Read more »

ETF is short for exchange traded fund, a popular investment choice for Canadians
Dividend Stocks

Create a Set-And-Forget Portfolio With Just 3 ETFs

Build a set-and-forget portfolio with VCN, XUU, and XEF, three ETFs offering broad exposure to Canadian, U.S., and international stocks.

Read more »

voice-recognition-talking-to-a-smartphone
Dividend Stocks

1 Canadian Dividend Stock Down 22% I’d Buy Right Now

The Canadian dividend stock has witnessed a notable pullback, creating a buying opportunity for investors looking for steady income.

Read more »

Colored pins on calendar showing a month
Dividend Stocks

How to Build a Canadian Portfolio That Pays You Monthly

If you like monthly income, this mix of five real estate, industrials, and energy stocks can pay you attractive monthly…

Read more »

Concept of rent, search, purchase real estate, REIT
Dividend Stocks

The Best Monthly-Paying Dividend Stock on the TSX Right Now

This monthly dividend stock offers an attractive mix of nearly 5% yield, monthly distributions, and a deeply discounted unit price…

Read more »

Warning sign with the text "Trade war" in front of container ship
Dividend Stocks

The Trade War Is Raising Prices Again: This Canadian Grocer Can Protect Its Margins

Trade tensions can raise specific retail costs even when overall grocery inflation is slowing, putting purchasing scale at a premium.

Read more »