Should Investors Buy Scotiabank (TSX:BNS) or TD Bank (TSX:TD) Stock?

Bank of Nova Scotia (TSX:BNS)(NYSE:BNS) and Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD)(NYSE:TD) are two of Canada’s largest banks. But should you buy them?

There are several good reasons to buy Canadian bank stocks right now. Firstly, in the event of a recession, the government will have to shore up the Big Five banks as essential pillars of the economy. Despite being cyclical, bank stocks are therefore more defensive than they appear. To a certain degree, the biggest of the Big Five are technically untouchable and add backbone to a resilient stock portfolio.

The second reason: the Big Five banks offer reliable dividend growth. Aside from defensive qualities, a TSX investor with recessionary worries should be looking for stocks that offer passive income, along with the assurance of growing, well-covered payments. Again, the Big Five banks hold up in this regard, and count among Canada’s go-to stocks for dependable buy-and-hold dividends.

A potential third reason to buy bank stocks would be in the event of an interest rate cut. In fact, a few signs point to just such an event this year. If you’re bullish on a Canadian rate cut in 2020, then now might be the time to buy bank stocks. With the possibility of a bank stock rally, investors may want to lock in those bigger yields now before those value fundamentals start to go up.

Battle of the banks

Coming in at third place in the Big Five, Bank of Nova Scotia — better known as Scotiabank — underperformed both most of its peers as well as the TSX last year. With the general assumption that credit will decrease in quality this year, Scotiabank may find 2020 at least as tough as 2019. However, the housing market may rebound, giving Scotiabank a boost.

More seriously, perhaps, could be Scotiabank’s exposure to the Pacific Alliance. With economic headwinds facing Latin America, a region responsible for a significant amount of Scotiabank’s growth in income, the Big Five banker could face a deteriorating share price this year. The thesis for value opportunities is strong: long-range investors should back up the truck on a dip in 2020.

From the third-largest bank in Canada to the sixth-largest bank in North America. Toronto-Dominion Bank is a trillion-dollar behemoth that packs serious U.S. exposure. Paying investors a 4% dividend, this is the one to go for if growth among bankers fits your investment strategy.

TD Bank’s client base puts it far in the lead with an international customer pool of 26 million. The bank is a strong buy for shareholders interested not only in growth in the U.S. but also online banking — an arena in which TD Bank leads the way. The Charles SchwabTD Ameritrade deal further bolsters TD Bank’s standing, creating a $5 trillion brokerage.

The bottom line

If investors are buying one Canadian bank stock right now for a combination of safety, growth, and income, it should be TD Bank. With its U.S. exposure and strength in the American economy, it’s arguably a safer play than Scotiabank. Continuing to expand stateside, where it already commands an impressive presence, TD Bank is a solid buy.

Fool contributor Victoria Hetherington has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA.

More on Dividend Stocks

Yellow caution tape attached to traffic cone
Dividend Stocks

The CRA Is Watching This January: Don’t Make These TFSA Mistakes

January TFSA mistakes usually aren’t about stocks; they’re about rushing contributions and accidentally triggering CRA penalties.

Read more »

Canadian Dollars bills
Dividend Stocks

The TFSA Paycheque Plan: How $10,000 Can Start Paying You in 2026

A TFSA “paycheque” plan can work best when one strong dividend stock is treated as a piece of a diversified…

Read more »

A Canada Pension Plan Statement of Contributions with a 100 dollar banknote and dollar coins.
Dividend Stocks

Retirees, Take Note: A January 2026 Portfolio Built to Top Up CPP and OAS

A January TFSA top-up can make CPP and OAS feel less tight by adding a flexible, tax-free income stream you…

Read more »

senior couple looks at investing statements
Dividend Stocks

The TFSA’s Hidden Fine Print When It Comes to U.S. Investments

There's a 15% foreign withholding tax levied on U.S.-based dividends.

Read more »

young people stare at smartphones
Dividend Stocks

Is BCE Stock Finally a Buy in 2026?

BCE has stabilized, but I think a broad infrastructure focused ETF is a better bet.

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Dividend Stocks

Start 2026 Strong: 3 Canadian Dividend Stocks Built for Steady Cash Flow

Dividend stocks can make a beginner’s 2026 plan feel real by mixing income today with businesses that can grow over…

Read more »

senior relaxes in hammock with e-book
Dividend Stocks

2 High-Yield Dividend Stocks for Stress-Free Passive Income

These high-yield Canadian companies are well-positioned to maintain consistent dividend payments across varying economic conditions.

Read more »

Senior uses a laptop computer
Dividend Stocks

Below Average? How a 70-Year-Old Can Change Their RRSP Income Plan in January

January is the perfect time to sanity-check your RRSP at 70, because the “typical” balance is closer to the median…

Read more »