Landlords won’t be too happy in May, as the month could be the start of rent strikes. In the ongoing crisis, many tenants with closed businesses will have no income or means to make rental payments. The government might have to step in with rental subsidies for affected tenants.
Carnage is looming for real estate investment trusts (REITs) such as RioCan (TSX:REI.UN) and Choice Properties (TSX:CHP.UN). These two top landlords have begun offering 60-day rent deferrals and automatic deferrals to other tenants. The sacrifice could be more if the lockdown persists for a few more months.
Rental payments during the pandemic are now flashpoint expenses to business owners. The restaurant and retail industries are practically non-operational, as the country curbs the spread of COVID-19. A rent strike will hurt RioCan and Choice Properties should the gathering storm materialize.
Landlords have been receiving letters and notices from tenants advising of non-payment of rent. Rent payments are inescapable, but how can tenants afford to pay when there is no income?
RioCan is one of the largest REITs in Canada with a market capitalization of $5.28 billion as of April 17, 2020. This REIT leases about 220 properties in prime, high-density, transit-oriented areas across the country. The portfolio consists of mixed-use properties, but several tenants are retail-focused.
Having high exposure to the retail space will impact on rental revenue. RioCan is expecting to lose 25% of revenue in the next 60 days because of business closures. Cinema operator Cineplex counts as among the major tenants, along with Loblaw. The latter’s business is safer since it’s a necessity-based retailer.
The weak spot is now showing for RioCan, which was once regarded as a haven for income investors. As of this writing, this REIT is down 36.8% year to date on the stock market. Management is hoping the pandemic will end soon, so customers can return to restaurants, cinemas, and gyms. For now, RioCan’s lustre is gone.
Strong but not safe
Choice Properties is also not exempt from the brewing rental woes. The stock performance of this $4.15 billion REIT, however, is better than RioCan’s. Choice Properties’s year-to-date loss is only 2.4%.
There are 726 properties in the portfolio and 576, or 79%, are retail. Loblaw is the anchor tenant. Its partnership with Canada’s largest food retailer is an advantage. Unlike discretionary retail businesses like restaurants and cinemas, Loblaw’s grocery and drug stores are open for business.
Industrial properties comprise 15.6% (113) of the total portfolio. The businesses in this sector should do well in the long term. Tenants catering to e-commerce and logistics are benefiting from the stay-at-home directives.
The coronavirus outbreak is a major headwind, and a rent strike is something unheard of. Choice Properties must be bracing for the negative impact if there is no virus containment in the coming months. Investors are nervous that Choice Properties will also lose its appeal as an investment option.
REITs or major landlords like RioCan and Choice Properties are in tight spots. Everyone thought both were safe investments, but nobody could predict a crisis like COVID-19.
This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.
Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.