Canada Revenue Agency: 33% of Canadians Are Making This TFSA Mistake

TFSA is a powerful tool that Canadians can use to grow their wealth tax-free. It can help you build a nest egg for retirement or save for short-term goals, but be sure to use it the right way.

| More on:

One of the things that many people have trouble understanding is that you don’t just need money to make money as an investor. While it’s true that having a decent amount of cash to invest surely helps, and the more you have, the more you are likely to grow your wealth, there are other things you need to focus on as well.

The right investments, asset allocation, investment vehicles, investment strategies, the time you have to grow your wealth, and choosing the right securities are all important considerations.

One of the best tools available for investors in Canada is the Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA). This is a flexible account that can help people with their short-term and long-term financial and investment goals.

But the problem is that even though the account is now over a decade old, people are still making mistakes with it. About 33% of the Canadians are making a huge TFSA mistake: overcontribution.

Contribution limit and penalties

Understanding the basic contribution limit is simple. If you haven’t contributed to your TFSA yet, you will likely have the full contribution limit available to you, which is $69,500. If you regularly contribute to your TFSA, you have to keep in mind the yearly limit.

For example, if you had a TFSA full to the brim in 2019, the new amount that you can contribute to your TFSA is just $6,000 – this year’s contribution room.

Let’s say you overcontributed and placed $10,000 in your TFSA this year. That’s $4,000 in over-contribution. The penalty is 1% of the excess amount from the contribution month until the excess is removed or absorbed in the next year’s contribution room.

So if you placed $4,000 excess in your TFSA in May, you would have incurred $320 ($40 x 8 months) in penalties by the end of 2020.

At year-end, it will get absorbed in the new limit. If it’s $6,000 again, that means you can only contribute $2,000 for the next year ($4,000 excess carried forward to next year). So the best way is to remove the excess.

One typical reason for over-contribution is that people think that having two different TFSAs gives them two separate contribution limits, but that’s wrong. No matter how many TFSAs you have, your limit for the year won’t change.

Maximize your returns

The good news is that $69,500 is a sizeable enough sum that you can grow to a decent nest egg with the right investments, so it’s better not to overcontribute. If you invest in a decent growth stock like Parkland Fuel, currently trading at a 21% discount, you will have ample chances to grow your wealth to sizeable proportions in due time. Currently, it’s trading at $37.9 per share at writing, with a yield of 3.23%.

And you don’t have to invest the whole sum in one stock. In fact, it’s better if you don’t. For retail investors, diversification can be a hedge against massive portfolio losses. But even if you invest just $20,000 and it keeps growing at a rate of 10.5% per annum (its five-year CAGR), you might be sitting on over $650,000 in 35 years. And that’s apart from the monthly dividends that the company has been steadily growing.

Foolish takeaway

The TFSA is an amazing investment tool, especially if you are leveraging on growth. You can grow your TFSA wealth without fear that the CRA will take a big bite out of your pie.

But it’s imperative that you follow the rules and don’t make costly mistakes with your TFSA, like over contributing or using it to day trade.

Fool contributor Adam Othman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

frustrated shopper at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

5 TSX Stocks to Buy for a Calm, Boring, Winning Portfolio

These five “boring” TSX stocks focus on essentials and recurring demand, which can make them useful holds in 2026.

Read more »

Canadian Red maple leaves seamless wallpaper pattern
Dividend Stocks

The Canadian Stocks I’d Be Most Comfortable Buying and Holding in a TFSA Forever

I'd be most comfortable buying and holding blue-chip Canadian dividend stocks in a TFSA forever.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

This Is the Average TFSA Balance for Canadians at Age 60

Turning 60 puts your TFSA in the spotlight, and this senior-housing dividend payer aims to deliver tax-free income plus long-term…

Read more »

Middle aged man drinks coffee
Dividend Stocks

1 Magnificent TSX Dividend Stock Down 12% to Buy and Hold for Decades

This TSX dividend stock is down 12%, giving long‑term investors a chance to lock in reliable income and steady growth…

Read more »

woman considering the future
Retirement

How Much Canadians Typically Have in a TFSA by Age 50

Here is the average TFSA balance if you are 50-years old. Use tax-free compounding to build substantive wealth for retirement.

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Dividend Stocks

The Best TSX Stocks Right Now for Income and Growth Combined

Buy Enbridge (TSX:ENB) and another stock for income and appreciation this year.

Read more »

heavy construction machines needed for infrastructure buildout
Dividend Stocks

These Stocks Will Power Canada’s Nation-Building Push in 2026

Canada's $1T nation-building boom targets infrastructure, housing, AI power, and resilience. These 2 surging TSX stocks are set to cash…

Read more »

crisis concept, falling stairs
Dividend Stocks

1 Practically Perfect Canadian Stock Down 19% to Buy and Hold Forever

Brookfield is down about 23% from its high, but its global real-asset machine still looks built to grow for decades.

Read more »