Is the Current Stock Market Rally Sustainable?

The stock market recovered after the March sell-off, even though the GDP contracted. This stock market rally came after the government stimulus package.

| More on:
man sitting in front of 3 screens programming

Image source: Getty Images

The stock market crashed in March, as the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic created panic among investors. The TSX Composite Index hit bottom on March 23, falling 34% from the start of the year. At that time, there were around 1,300 COVID-19 cases and fewer than 20 deaths in Canada. However, the index recovered over the next three months, even though the number of new cases continued to increase and crossed 100,000, with over 8,400 deaths.

The stock market rallied, even when Canada’s GDP contracted 11%, and the unemployment rate rose to 13% in April. The TSX Composite Index rose 37% from its March 23 low but is still down 10% year to date. The stock market is not reflecting the state of the economy. Moreover, its rally is incomplete, as investors are fearful of a second market crash.

This state of uncertainty and optimism leaves a question of whether the current stock market rally is sustainable. But before this, it is crucial to understand the reason behind the stock market crash and recovery.

Why did the stock market crash in March?

A stock market crash comes when speculation goes out of control, and stock valuation is inflated beyond the fundamentals. Uncertainty fuels speculation, as investors are unable to make informed decisions. They react instead of responding. In March, when Canada announced the pandemic-driven lockdown, there was a lot of uncertainty around public health and safety. Everyone, from investors to consumers to businesses, panicked. The stock market has been in its longest bull run from 2009 to 2020, which had stretched the valuation of stocks. The out-of-control speculation around the pandemic and stretched stock valuations in the last 11 years sent the stock market down 30%.

The way market dynamic works, the stock valuation is corrected periodically. The stock market falls 10% every one to two years, and 20% every five to seven years. But it is rare for the stock market to fall 30% and above. The market witnessed such a decline in the 2008 financial crisis. It took the market six years to return to the pre-crisis level.

At the start of the year, stocks like that of Air Canada (TSX:AC) and CGI Group were trading at their all-time highs, which stretched their valuations beyond their fundamentals. Both companies have high leverage and lower profit. The market sell-off sent the stocks down 60% and 20%, respectively.

Why did the stock market rally in the April-June period?

However, the TSX Composite Index rallied from April onward, even though the economy contracted, as the government injected money into the economy. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) started providing $2,000 monthly payment to citizens who lost their jobs due to the pandemic. The government also launched Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy to protect jobs. The central bank lowered interest rates, REITs deferred rent payments, and banks deferred mortgage and loan payments. These stimulus payments revived optimism and stabilized the economy.

Is the current rally sustainable?

The government is funding the stimulus payment with taxpayers’ money, and it will last until the economy reopens in June. However, the government extended the stimulus package until August, as the unemployment rate increased and companies struggled to return to business. But these exemptions and stimulus packages are not sustainable.

The current stock market rally has priced in expectation that a cure or vaccine for coronavirus will be found in the next 12 months and life will start returning to normal this fall or early next year. Many companies have taken loans and cut jobs to have sufficient cash to stay afloat until the end of the year.

Another stock market crash is inevitable if the recovery takes longer than expected. Individuals and companies would default on their rent and loan, thereby putting banks under pressure. Many companies will go bankrupt, and new companies will replace them. This entire economic revival will take at least three to five years.

Air Canada stock rose 50% from its March 23rd fall, as the company increased its liquidity by $3 billion. The investors have priced in expectation that the air travel will begin this fall. The stock will see another sell-off if international travel demand takes longer to recover, and the company defaults on payments.

Another stock market crash is inevitable. Don’t rush to buy stocks just because they are cheap. Invest in stocks that are fundamentally strong and can withstand a recession.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Puja Tayal has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends CGI GROUP INC CL A SV.

More on Coronavirus

little girl in pilot costume playing and dreaming of flying over the sky

Air Canada Stock: How High Could it go?

AC stock is up 29% in the last six months alone, so should we expect more great things? Or is…

Read more »

eat food

Goodfood Stock Doubles Within Days: Time to Buy?

Goodfood (TSX:FOOD) stock has surged 125% in the last few weeks, so what happened, and should investors hop back on…

Read more »

stock data
Tech Stocks

If I Could Only Buy 1 Stock Before 2023, This Would Be It

This stock is the one company that really doesn't deserve its ultra-low share price, so I'll definitely pick it up…

Read more »

Aircraft Mechanic checking jet engine of the airplane

Air Canada Stock Fell 5% in November: Is it a Buy Today?

Air Canada (TSX:AC) stock saw remarkable improvements during its last quarter but still dropped 5% with more recession hints. So,…

Read more »

Airport and plane

Is Air Canada Stock a Buy Today?

Airlines are on the rebound. Does Air Canada stock deserve to be on your buy list?

Read more »

A patient takes medicine out of a daily pill box.

Retirees: 2 Healthcare Stocks That Could Help Set You up for Life

Healthcare stocks offer an incredible opportunity for growth for those investors who look to the right stocks, such as these…

Read more »

sad concerned deep in thought

Here’s Why I Just Bought WELL Health Stock

WELL Health stock (TSX:WELL) may be a healthcare stock and a tech stock, but don't let that keep you from…

Read more »

healthcare pharma

WELL Stock: The Safe Stock Investors Can’t Afford to Ignore

WELL stock (TSX:WELL) fell 68% from peak to trough, and yet there's no good reason as to why. So now…

Read more »