Is the Stock Market Fundamentally Overvalued?

The stock market was a bit overpriced even before the pandemic hit. But now the economy is in far worse shape, and the market is rapidly reverting to its pre-pandemic valuations.

| More on:

Unlike the tech and IT-heavy U.S. stock market, the bulk of TSX weightage is supported by the financial, material, and energy sectors. Out of these two, the materials have been performing exceptionally well, thanks mostly to investor interest in gold and prices rising continually. But the other two sectors have been suffering, especially since the pandemic hit. But the question of the stock market’s overvaluation is older than the epidemic.

The crash in March was one of the most significant blows that hit the stock market after the 2008 recession. Since then, there have been ups and downs but never a sharp fall as deep as the one in March. And after the last recession, we’ve seen a robust market for over a decade. Investor confidence in large-cap companies trading on TSX was one of the major reasons why the stock market became overvalued.

But is the market fundamentally overvalued right now?

Current valuation

Ever since the crash, the market is in a bit of disarray. Relatively fewer companies have reclaimed their pre-pandemic valuations. A large proportion of financial and energy, two out of the three major sectors on TSX, are still struggling. The disparity is pretty obvious if you see the respective indices, i.e., the energy index is still down 47% from its pre-pandemic high, while the financial index is 16.43% down.

Compared to that, the material and tech indices are up 26.5% and almost 30%, respectively, from their pre-pandemic highs. The S&P/TSX Composite Index is trading just below 7% of its pre-pandemic high. The fact that two heavyweight sectors are substantially down in the midst of a near-complete market recovery does seem to indicate an overvalued stock market.

And while it may not impact your choice too much when you are picking up individual stocks (since you would be looking into the valuation of the company itself), it does indicate that we might be heading into another market crash.

An oversold stock from an oversold market

One way to capitalize on a market crash is to buy companies that are typically too expensive for you, from a value investment standpoint. One such stock is Canadian National Railway (TSX:CNR)(NYSE:CNI). It’s not too overpriced, especially for a powerful aristocrat with stellar dividend history and decent capital growth potential, but it’s getting there. The stock also showed a decent recovery pace after the pandemic.

Currently, CNR is offering a modest 1.7% yield. But if the stock craters again in the upcoming crash, the yield, along with the valuation, might become a bit more enticing. Its five-year returns (dividend-adjusted) are 108.57%, resulting in a juicy five-year compound annual growth rate (CAGAR) of 15.8%. It has a dominant position in the transportation sector and a strong balance sheet.

Foolish takeaway

Just because the stock market might be overpriced doesn’t mean all the stocks are, however. But if you want to buy now and don’t wish to wait for a crash that may or may not come, browse through financial, real estate, and energy stocks.

You may find many heavily discounted stocks that are fundamentally strong and will shine again when the economy (not the market) finally recovers.

Fool contributor Adam Othman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. David Gardner owns shares of Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool recommends Canadian National Railway.

More on Dividend Stocks

boy in bowtie and glasses gives positive thumbs up
Dividend Stocks

Here Are My Top 3 TSX Stocks to Buy Right Now

My top three TSX stocks form a fortress-like portfolio capable of weathering the geopolitical storm in 2026.

Read more »

Income and growth financial chart
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks to Double Up on Right Now

Generate outsized passive income in your self-directed investment portfolio by adding these two high-quality dividend stocks to your holdings.

Read more »

Yellow caution tape attached to traffic cone
Dividend Stocks

7.4% Dividend Yield? Here’s a Dividend Trap to Avoid in March

Yellow Pages (TSX:Y) is a top Canadian dividend stock that many investors focus on for its yield, but that could…

Read more »

people ride a downhill dip on a roller coaster
Dividend Stocks

2 Monster Stocks to Hold for the Next 5 Years

These two monster Canadian stocks look like screaming buys for investors looking for not only recent momentum, but long-term total…

Read more »

Yellow caution tape attached to traffic cone
Dividend Stocks

4.66% Yield? Here’s a Dividend Trap to Avoid in March

I'm surprised this bank is still around, much less paying a 4.66% dividend yield.

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Top TSX Stocks

Top Canadian Stocks to Buy Right Now With $3,000

A $3,000 capital investment can buy the top Canadian stocks and create a mini-portfolio in 2026.

Read more »

people ride a downhill dip on a roller coaster
Dividend Stocks

A Canadian Dividend Stock I’d Hold Through Anything

Long-term dividend investors can take advantage of a rare combination of essential assets, a global footprint, and a steadily growing…

Read more »

customer adds cash to tip jar at business
Dividend Stocks

2 Canadian Stocks That Pay You While You Wait

Reliable dividend payers, like this regulated utility and this diversified financial, can keep cash coming in while the market sorts…

Read more »