CN Rail (TSX:CNR) or CP Rail (TSX:CP): Better TFSA Buy?

CN Rail Co. Ltd. (TSX:CNR)(NYSE:CNI) and CP Rail Ltd. (TSX:CP)(NYSE:CP) just pulled back modestly, but are the dips buyable?

What a glorious run it’s been for shares of CN Rail (TSX: CNR)(NYSE: CNI) and CP Rail (TSX: CP)(NYSE: CP) over the past several months. Both major railways will play a major role in lifting the Canadian economy out of its funk over the next several quarters.

With volumes likely to pick up traction into 2021, I think the recent dip in both rail stocks are buyable for TFSA investors looking for excess risk-adjusted returns as the world looks to recover from the coronavirus crisis. But which, if any, is the better buy for your TFSA portfolio at this juncture? Let’s have a closer look at each name:

CN Rail

At the time of writing, CN Rail stock is down just shy of 9% from its high due to what I believe is a massive overreaction to the firm’s sub-par quarterly results, which doesn’t appear to change the 2021 recovery trajectory.

While CN Rail stock’s valuation may have gotten ahead of itself going into the quarter, the name is worthy of a premium multiple as the stage looks set for a big revenue bump alongside what could be a huge improvement to its operating ratio, which, as you’d expect, has dragged for most of the year thanks to the disruptive crisis.

CN Rail is known as North America’s most efficient railway for a reason. Why the firm’s operating ratio (OR) deterioration may be concerning to some, I think the firm will have little trouble getting its OR back down to the mid-single-digits coming the coming year.

Even after the recent correction, CNR stock still looks pricy at 21.3 times next year’s expected earnings and 7.0 times sales. Given the upside to be had in a 2021 economic recovery, though, I’d say the slightly less frothy premium price tag is well worth paying, especially given the relative degree of downside protection you’ll get from the name if next year’s recovery ends up being far rockier than most are expecting.

CP Rail

CP Rail stock has retreated alongside its peer, with shares now down 5.6% from its high. The number two Canadian railway has done a magnificent job of staying operationally efficient (58.2% operating ratio as of the last quarter) despite the profound pressures brought forth by the coronavirus crisis.

The railway’s free cash flow (FCF) took a step back but is poised to bounce back abruptly next year alongside the Canadian economy. Management recently raised its 2020 guidance modestly and is now calling for at least mid-single-digit EPS growth.

At the time of writing, CP stock trades at 20.1 times forward earnings, and like CN, 7.0 times sales. CP has a lofty premium multiple that bakes in a strong economic recovery in 2021. Kay Ng, my colleague here at the Motley Fool, thinks that CP Rail is a better buy than CN Rail because of higher nearer-term EPS growth expectations.

Is CN Rail or CP Rail the better rail stock to buy for your TFSA right now?

Kay and I have agreed with one another on numerous occasions in the past. But this time, I’m afraid I have to disagree when she says CP Rail is the better rail stock to buy here.

CN Rail, I believe, is the far better bet following its 9% dip, as I see greater potential for margin improvement over the year ahead (CN’s OR swelled to 60%, but looks poised to revert to the mid-50s). Moreover, CN’s earnings bar looks to be that much lower following its brutal recent post-earnings flop.

As such, I think CN Rail stock is a far better bet and think shares have greater upside potential versus the likes of its smaller brother over the next 18 months.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette owns shares of Canadian National Railway. David Gardner owns shares of Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool recommends Canadian National Railway.

More on Stocks for Beginners

how to save money
Energy Stocks

Want $12,000 a Year in Dividends? Here’s the Capital the Goal Requires

A $12,000 dividend target can look more manageable once you see the required balance and how much monthly deposits can…

Read more »

Offshore wind turbine farm at sunset
Energy Stocks

Northland Power Stock: Would I Buy the Dividend or Wait for Better Cash Flow?

Northland pays monthly after cutting its dividend. I’d wait for more cash after project spending before giving it a job…

Read more »

dividend stocks are a good way to earn passive income
Dividend Stocks

Enbridge vs. Telus: Which Stock Offers More Reliable Income Through 2030?

Enbridge and Telus are two of the best Canadian dividend stocks on the TSX, but which is the better hold…

Read more »

cloud computing
Dividend Stocks

Intact vs. Fairfax: Which Insurance Stock Fits a More Conservative Portfolio?

Both companies can earn money from insurance and investments. I’d pick Intact if I want a simpler way to follow…

Read more »

AI image of a face with chips
Tech Stocks

OpenText’s AI Pitch Needs to Show Up in Earnings: Here’s What I’d Watch

At OpenText World, I heard how customers can move from searching their files to building AI agents. The earnings test…

Read more »

A glass jar resting on its side with Canadian banknotes and change inside.
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Income for Canadians Starting With a Small Budget

Wondering how to start investing for dividend income? This simple portfolio can get you started with $136 of income every…

Read more »

open bank vault
Stocks for Beginners

Bank Stocks or a Dividend ETF? Where I’d Put $25,000 for Retirement Income

Two bank stocks can pay a decent retirement cheque. I’d give the next $25,000 to a dividend ETF if I…

Read more »

Trans Alaska Pipeline with Autumn Colors
Energy Stocks

How Much Would You Need in Pembina to Average $300 a Month?

Pembina pays quarterly. Averaging $300 a month at its latest rate would take about $85,000 at writing.

Read more »