Warning: The CRA Doesn’t Mess Around With TFSA Tax Mistakes!

TFSA can be your ally when you want to create a safe and secure financial future through saving and investing, but only if you concede with the terms of this friendship.

| More on:

Even though it has been over a decade since the Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) was introduced, many people still don’t fully understand the TFSA and tend to make mistakes. Some of these mistakes are relatively harmless and are more oriented towards people not using the full potential of the TFSA (such as only using it for cash savings), but some mistakes draw the ire of the CRA.

Over-contribution

This is one of the most common mistakes with one of the most clearly defined CRA penalties. You get taxed 1% on the amount that you over-contribute to your TFSA (over the yearly limit or the TFSA limit available to you, carried over from previous years). The penalty tax is deducted every month that the exceeding amount stays in your TFSA.

Over-trading

This one is a little bit tricky. The TFSA was created to motivate and help Canadians save and invest. But the stipulation (and assumption) is that you will invest and not trade. That means holding assets long-term in your TFSA. If you use your TFSA to trade (which is taxed as business income and not as investment income) stocks, your account will lose the tax-free status, and your TFSA income will be taxed as business income.

The CRA doesn’t exactly define what constitutes day-trading, but if you buy and sell funds too quickly (and usually intra-day), your TFSA might become a tax nightmare for you.

Mixing contributions and withdrawals

Let’s say you have already contributed the yearly allowed amount ($6,000) to your TFSA. You need some funds, so you raid your TFSA and make a $2,000 withdrawal. But you realize later that you don’t need the funds, so you put the amount back in — but wait — you can’t!

The TFSA yearly contribution is a one-way road. You are only allowed to contribute a set amount for a year. And if you’ve withdrawn a sum from your TFSA, you can’t put it back to your TFSA until next year, with your withdrawal is added to your yearly contribution limit.

Proper use of your TFSA

Adding the right long-term holdings to your TFSA is the proper way to use your TFSA. It allows you to grow your TFSA funds without over-contributing, and since you will be holding them for a long-time, you won’t become susceptible to trading in your TFSA.

One stock you may want to consider for your TFSA is Capital Power (TSX:CPX). It’s an Alberta-based independent power company that claims to produce “responsible energy for tomorrow.” The company has 28 power generation facilities across the country and the U.S. that include wind, solar, coal, natural gas, and solid fuel. The total power generation capacity is 6,491 MW.

A clean energy business model is good news for investors since it probably means that the company will have a bright future and its long-term prospects look good. The two other reasons to love this stock is its juicy 5.5% yield and a 22.6% five-year compound annual growth rate (CAGR).

Foolish takeaway

The TFSA can be a powerful tool if you use it properly. It allows you to save and invest your money for short-term goals and emergencies, and it’s also great for saving for retirement. Using your TFSA improperly won’t just get you penalized, but can also put significant dents in your TFSA nest eggs.

Fool contributor Adam Othman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

chatting concept
Dividend Stocks

BCE vs. Telus: Which TSX Dividend Stock Is a Better Buy in 2026?

Down almost 50% from all-time highs, Telus and BCE are two TSX telecom stocks that offer you a tasty dividend…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Dividend Stocks

Your 2026 TFSA Game Plan: How to Turn the New Contribution Room Into Monthly Cash

With the 2026 TFSA limit at $7,000, a simple “set-and-reinvest” plan using cash-generating dividend staples like ENB, FTS, and PPL…

Read more »

Business success of growth metaverse finance and investment profit graph concept or development analysis progress chart on financial market achievement strategy background with increase hand diagram
Dividend Stocks

Want $252 in Super-Safe Monthly Dividends? Invest $41,500 in These 2 Ultra-High-Yield Stocks

Discover how to achieve a high yield with trusted stocks providing regular payments. Invest smartly for a steady income today.

Read more »

Piggy bank and Canadian coins
Dividend Stocks

Canadians: Here’s How Much You Need in Your TFSA to Retire

If you hold Fortis Inc (TSX:FTS) stock in a TFSA, you might earn enough dividends to cover part of your…

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

1 Ideal TFSA Stock Paying 7% Income Every Month

A TFSA can feel like payday with a monthly payer like SmartCentres, but the real “winner” test is cash flow…

Read more »

up arrow on wooden blocks
Dividend Stocks

3 Blue-Chip Dividend Stocks for 2026

These blue-chip dividend stocks have consistently grown their dividends, and will likely maintain the dividend growth streak.

Read more »

Nurse talks with a teenager about medication
Dividend Stocks

A Perfect January TFSA Stock With a 6.8% Monthly Payout

A high-yield monthly payer can make a January TFSA reset feel automatic, but only if the cash flow truly supports…

Read more »

alcohol
Dividend Stocks

2 Stocks to Boost Your Income Investing Payouts in 2026

These two Canadian stocks with consistent dividend growth are ideal for income-seeking investors.

Read more »