Dividend Aristocrat vs. Dividend ETF: Which Offers Better Income Safety?

Dividend ETFs tend to offer a slightly different mix of sustainability and yield than Dividend Aristocrats and a different way to diversify your portfolio.

When it comes to buy-and-forget investments, exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, tend to stand out from the crowd. Most retail investors that wish to keep their investment expenses to a minimum prefer ETFs over mutual funds. These funds come with minimal fees and offer much better capital-preservation potential than individual stocks might.

But what if your aim is to start a passive income, and you are just as concerned about the safety and sustainability of your dividend-based income as you are about the return potential/yield? The most obvious first choice might be Dividend Aristocrats, but dividend ETFs are a powerful option to consider as well.

A “former” Dividend Aristocrat

Dividend Aristocrats are companies that have grown their payouts for at least five consecutive years, and while the past doesn’t always predict the future, it is the best data set we have, nevertheless. And most Dividend Aristocrats tend to maintain their dividend streaks, because breaking that streak might result in the potential loss of investor trust.

One example would be Suncor (TSX: SU)(NYSE: SU), the oil sands giant of North America, which had to slash its payout in 2020 when it became too financially unsustainable. It was a shock to investors when the beloved Dividend Aristocrat broke its 18-year dividend-growth streak. But the company started making amends as soon as the energy sector as a whole started recovering.

The company has restored its payouts quite close to the former number, and the result is an impressive 4.7% yield. And if the company restarts its dividend-growth practice, the payouts will only increase over time.

A dividend ETF

BMO Covered Call Utilities ETF (TSX: ZWU) is a low- to medium-risk ETF that offers monthly payouts, has a market capitalization of about $1.4 billion, and offers monthly dividends with an annualized distribution yield of 7.7%. And while capital appreciation is simply the cherry on top with this dividend-oriented ETF, if you had invested $10,000 in the fund about 10 years ago, your capital would have grown to over $16,000 by now.

Since 2012, the ETF’s monthly payouts have hovered between $0.073 per share and $0.09 per share, but they have mostly remained around $0.078 and $0.08 per share. So, even though the payout is not exactly rock solid, the variation is minimal enough that you can rely upon the dividends for a reasonably secure income.

About one-third of the assets within the ETF are Canadian, while the remaining are from the United States. Its top holdings include industry giants like BCE, Fortis, and Enbridge, and this comprehensive diversification within the ETF makes the income even more secure.

Foolish takeaway

The ETF is currently offering a much better return potential, even if you take the 0.71% management expense ratio into account. It’s better diversified and significantly safer than most individual Aristocrats. However, its diversification prevents fluctuations, which means that your chances of locking in excellent yields are much lower than what they are with Aristocrats.

Fool contributor Adam Othman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Enbridge and FORTIS INC.

More on Dividend Stocks

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

A TFSA Loss Doesn’t Create New Room: Here’s the Rebuilding Plan I’d Use

A falling investment won’t create TFSA contribution room. I’d rebuild using the room I actually have and a portfolio that…

Read more »

Forklift in a warehouse
Dividend Stocks

A 7.9% Dividend Stock for Monthly Retirement Income

This Canadian REIT trades at a 38.8% discount to a key valuation measure, and offers a 7.9% yield, paid monthly,…

Read more »

hand stacks coins
Dividend Stocks

Building a $1,000-a-Month Dividend Income Stream: What It Actually Takes

Wondering what it takes to earn $1,000/month in dividends? Here's some different scenarios and stocks that can help get you…

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Colliers Stock: The Engineering Business Behind the Real Estate Name

Colliers still earns from real estate, but engineering now gives investors a second business to follow.

Read more »

shopper checks her receipt
Dividend Stocks

2 Safe Canadian Stocks to Buy With $7,000

Loblaw (TSX:L) and another safety play that could be a great fit for Canadian investors seeking lower betas and greater…

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Telus vs. Fortis: Which Stock Would I Choose for a More Dependable Payout?

Telus pays more today after its reset. I’d choose Fortis for the payout I’d rather count on over several years.

Read more »

a person looks out a window into a cityscape
Dividend Stocks

This 3% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Out Every Month

Boardwalk REIT pays $0.15 a unit every month, a yield near 3%. See Q3 results, the buyback story and the…

Read more »

shoppers in an indoor mall
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX Dividend Stocks With High Yields Worth Considering Now

These TSX stocks offer high yields of over 5.5%, have sustainbale payouts, and are well-positioned to keep paying their dividends.

Read more »