Better Dividend Buy: Royal Bank Stock or Bank of Nova Scotia Stock?

Although BNS stock is riskier, it offers about 53% more income and could provide higher total returns than RBC stock over the next five years.

The big Canadian bank stocks are excellent passive-income investments. It doesn’t take long for investors to look up the dividend yields of Royal Bank of Canada (TSX: RY) and Bank of Nova Scotia (TSX: BNS) and find that the latter bank stock’s dividend yield is much higher. How much is the difference? RBC’s dividend yield is 4.08% at writing, while BNS stock’s dividend yield is 6.25%. So, BNS stock pays approximately 53% higher dividend income than RBC stock.

Is Bank of Nova Scotia stock a better dividend buy?

If current income is your top priority, then BNS stock is absolutely a better dividend buy. Let’s take a look at their dividend-growth history to compare their future dividend income potential. RBC stock’s 10-year dividend-growth rate is 8.1%, while BNS stock’s is 6.4%.

Let’s assume they’re able to grow their dividends by 8% and 6% per year, respectively, going forward. In 10 years, RBC’s yield on cost would be about 8.2%, while BNS’s would be close to 10.6%. It’ll take 24 years(!) before the same investment in RBC stock today will catch up to BNS stock’s yield on cost of close to 24%.

What if you care more about total returns?

If your focus is more on total returns, then Royal Bank of Canada stock has been a much better buy-and-hold dividend stock. For example, in the last 10 years, RBC stock returned about 10.5% per year — slightly more than double BNS stock’s return of roughly 5.4% annually in the period.

This has partly to do with how well Royal Bank stock has held up during this banking sector downturn versus Scotiabank. The graph below illustrates the banks’ stock price action over the last 12 months. It’s obvious that RBC stock has been much more resilient thanks to its leadership position, well-managed business, and diversified operations across personal and commercial banking, wealth management, capital markets, insurance, and investor and treasury services. RBC is also geographically focused on Canada and the United States, generating roughly 84% of its revenues in these countries.

RY Chart

RY and BNS data by YCharts

Valuation matters

One thing that could make Bank of Nova Scotia stock a better buy today is its valuation. While RBC stock trades at a premium valuation of 11.3 times earnings, BNS stock trades at a low price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) of about 8.2. To provide a clearer picture, RBC stock has a long-term normal P/E of about 12.1, while BNS’s is about 11.5 times.

So, BNS stock has a much bigger upside potential from valuation expansion. What’s weighing on the stock? Its international strategy has been more of a drag on its business results over the last few years. Particularly, the bank saw a meaningful decline of 21% in its diluted earnings per share (EPS) during the 2020 pandemic year versus RBC’s diluted EPS decline of 11%. This suggests that although BNS’s international strategy could theoretically lead to higher long-term growth, the underlying operations are also riskier in nature.

In recent years, Scotiabank has expanded its wealth management business with acquisitions, making it the third-largest active manager in Canada. Simultaneously, it has also exited some international operations while being more focused in other areas, such as targeting Chile and Colombia. Moreover, it’s a wait-and-see story, as investors hope the new chief executive officer Scott Thomson will right the ship over the next few years. If things work out, investors would get greater returns in higher-risk BNS stock over RBC stock over the next five years.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has positions in Bank Of Nova Scotia. The Motley Fool recommends Bank Of Nova Scotia. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Bank Stocks

Piggy bank with word TFSA for tax-free savings accounts.
Stocks for Beginners

CIBC vs. TD: Which Bank Offers the Better Case for a Long-Term TFSA?

The two banks offered almost identical yields at recent prices. I’d use my next TFSA purchase on the business I…

Read more »

Child measures his height on wall. He is growing taller.
Stocks for Beginners

National Bank Stock: How Much Growth Am I Willing to Pay for?

National Bank’s growth is worth paying for up to a point. I’d work backwards from the share price before adding…

Read more »

hot air balloon in a blue sky
Bank Stocks

Hot Take: This Is the Top Canadian Dividend Stock for Safety and Growth

Here's a safe Canadian dividend stock for investors seeking reliable income, financial stability, and long-term growth.

Read more »

data analyze research
Stocks for Beginners

TD’s Dividend Is Only Half the Investment Case: Here’s the Recovery Math

TD’s dividend pays you while you wait. The bigger payoff depends on how much more the bank can earn from…

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Bank Stocks

Canadian Bank Stocks in Late 2026: Which to Buy and Which to Skip

Canada’s banking sector is a bedrock of stability but a Big Bank stock stands out if you’re investing before 2026…

Read more »

traders work at stock exchange
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Bank Stocks: Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Explore the Big Six, their latest earnings and dividend yields, with income and defensive picks.

Read more »

The RRSP (Canadian Registered Retirement Savings Plan) is a smart way to save and invest for the future
Bank Stocks

Maxing Out Your TFSA Is Just the Beginning: Here’s What to Do Next

Maxing out your TFSA is not only a financial achievement but also the beginning of the next phase of your…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Stocks for Beginners

How I’d Turn Quarterly Bank Dividends Into a Monthly Paycheque

Quarterly bank dividends can fund regular monthly transfers without choosing stocks for payment dates.

Read more »