More Upside: Alimentation Couche-Tard or Canadian Bank Stocks?

Alimentation Couche-Tard (TSX:ATD) and another market darling that may prove smart buys in October for upside-seeking investors.

It’s a great time to be a contrarian investor now that some of the market’s hottest stocks are taking a bit of a breather. At the same time, some of the year’s laggards — think the Canadian bank stocks — are also letting negative market-wide sentiment weigh on them. Indeed, the big banks are cheap dividend payers that have gotten just a bit cheaper after passing through a turbulent September.

At this juncture, I think you cannot go wrong by initiating a long-term position in any one of the Big Six Canadian bank stocks right here. They look untimely, given the sluggish economy, and though their dividend yields are at a high point, they still pale in comparison to the current risk-free rate.

Indeed, any stock can be a risky ride going into a recession, whereas Guaranteed Investment Certificates (GICs) can be safe havens. Unless you have to exit the markets within the next year or two, though, value stocks stand out as having a far better risk/reward scenario right here, provided you get in at a decent price.

think thought consider

Image source: Getty Images

TD Bank stock

At this juncture, analysts believe shares of TD Bank (TSX: TD) could return as much as 15% from today’s prices. Add the dividend yield of 4.72% into the equation, and TD stock looks a heck of a lot more bountiful than the likes of any risk-free asset in the market right now. Of course, it doesn’t seem like TD is a better bet than GICs right now, especially after a hectic year of wild swings.

Year to date, TD stock is off more than 6%, while the TSX Index has been flat. The once-beloved big bank is heavily out of favour these days. Still, I think it’s never a good idea to bet against the big bank stocks, just because of their ugly rear-view trajectories. It’s hard to be optimistic when we hear all this negative chatter on television after a bad day in markets. While it’s never easy to buy as others sell, it is key to achieving long-term success.

Right now, TD Bank stock still seems to be stuck in limbo after walking away from its First Horizons deal earlier this year. American regional banks were in a crisis to start the year. Though things have calmed lately, it seems doubtful that TD will want to resume its shopping spree south of the border. Not when there are so many risks on the table.

With plenty of liquidity, expect TD to weather economic chaos to come, perhaps with a potential deal in hand at some point in 2024. Either way, TD stock looks like dead money through the eyes of Wall Street. But that’s exactly why I like it. Today, shares trade at 10.6 times trailing price to earnings (P/E), which implies low expectations.

Couche-Tard stock

Alimentation Couche-Tard (TSX: ATD) should be a core holding in any young Tax-Free Savings Account investor’s portfolio. The stock is up over 119% in five years and 18.6% year to date. For such a low-tech retailer, the stock’s performance is nothing short of incredible. Further, Couche-Tard’s strategy is likely to keep the good days going, even as Canada sinks into an economic rut.

Like TD Bank, Couche-Tard has billions in acquisition power. If stocks roll over, the company can snag a bargain. In a high-rate environment, such financial wiggle room is worth that much more. Combined with management’s knack for producing synergies from most deals it makes, it’s clear Couche-Tard is a stock to hang onto, even as it revisits new all-time highs of around $74.

Notable Couche-Tard bull and RBC analyst Irene Nattel thinks Couche stock could be headed to $87 per share — that’s a huge 22% gain from here. That’s a realistic target to watch moving forward.

Better buy: TD or ATD stock?

It’s hard to choose between the two right now. But if I had to pick one, it’d be Couche, which is a winner I’d bet will keep on winning through 2024. TD, while deep in value, is less timely and more prone to fluctuations come the next downturn.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has positions in Alimentation Couche-Tard and Toronto-Dominion Bank. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Alimentation Couche-Tard. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

infrastructure like highways enables economic growth
Dividend Stocks

The 1 Stock I’d Hold in a TFSA for the Long Term

This utility stock is an excellent TFSA long-term holding, especially if purchased on meaningful market corrections.

Read more »

data center server racks glow with light
Energy Stocks

Hammond Power Stock: A Different Way to Invest in the Electricity Buildout

New power demand can mean more work for transformer makers. Hammond’s order book shows the opportunity, and its share price…

Read more »

Woman in private jet airplane
Investing

Air Canada Stock Slides on Fuel Costs: Is the Dip a Buying Opportunity?

Air Canada (TSX:AC) stock might be a promising dip-buy as jet fuel headwinds weigh things down.

Read more »

AI concept person in profile
Tech Stocks

Shopify vs. CGI: Which Canadian Tech Stock Would I Add to a Retirement Portfolio?

Shopify’s growth is hard to ignore. I’d add CGI to a retirement portfolio first because I can put a more…

Read more »

stocks climbing green bull market
Dividend Stocks

In a Few Years, You’ll Probably Regret Not Owning TMX Stock

TMX Group is a quality business, demonstrating growth potential from multiple sources. It's a top candidate for long-term holding.

Read more »

A family watches tv using Roku at home.
Dividend Stocks

Forget Telus Stock: A Dividend Giant I’d Buy Immediately Instead

Telus cut its dividend, and its cash flow is falling. Rogers just posted record free cash flow and held its…

Read more »

happy woman throws cash
Dividend Stocks

1 Way to Use a TFSA to Earn $250 in Monthly Income

Uncover the potential of a TFSA for generating income. Reinvest and withdraw your funds effortlessly without tax concerns.

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Dividend Stocks

How Much to Invest in Enbridge for $1,000 a Year in Dividends

Given its resilient business model, predictable cash flows, consistent dividend growth, high yield, and healthy growth prospects, Enbridge would be…

Read more »