Better Bank Stock: Royal Bank vs TD Bank?

Royal Bank and TD Bank have delivered very different results for investors in the past few years.

Royal Bank (TSX: RY) and TD Bank (TSX: TD) are the largest players in the Canadian financial sector. The stocks have delivered very different performances for investors in recent years, with RY being the big winner.

Investors are wondering if TD Bank is now undervalued and good to buy or if Royal Bank remains a better pick for a self-directed Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) or Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) portfolio focused on dividends and total returns.

open vault at bank

Source: Getty Images

Royal Bank Stock

Royal Bank trades near $176 per share at the time of writing. This is close to the record high of around $180 it reached in early December. The stock is up 33% in the past year and gained 68% over the past five years.

Royal Bank is benefitting from its $13.5 billion purchase last year of HSBC Canada. The deal added 780,000 customers and 4,500 new employees. Management’s focus on a Canadian acquisition sets Royal Bank apart from its peers in the past few years, where deals in the United States have been more common.

Royal Bank delivered a 10% gain in adjusted net income in 2024 to $17.4 billion. Adjusted diluted earnings per share rose 8% compared to fiscal 2023, and adjusted return on equity (ROE) came in unchanged at a solid 15.5%.

Royal Bank finished fiscal 2024 with a common equity tier-one (CET1) ratio of 13.2%. This means the bank still has ample capital on hand to ride out market turbulence or make additional acquisitions.

The bank delivered a strong performance in a year where high interest rates put pressure on businesses and households with too much debt. Royal Bank’s fiscal fourth-quarter (Q4) 2024 provision for credit losses (PCL) rose $120 million, or 17% compared to fiscal Q4 2023.

Rate cuts by the central bank will ease the pressure on variable-rate borrowers, but bond yields remain high, making fixed-rate mortgage renewals more expensive in the current market compared to when homeowners took out the initial mortgages five years ago.

At the current share price, investors can get a dividend yield of 3.3% on RY stock.

TD Bank

TD trades near $82.50 at the time of writing compared to $108 about three years ago. In the past 12 months, the stock price has been relatively unchanged, and investors are up about 13% from where the stock sat five years ago.

The stock’s underperformance is due to issues in the American operations. Regulators fined TD more than $3 billion in 2024 and placed an asset cap on the U.S. business as penalties for not having adequate systems in place to identify and prevent money laundering.

TD spent billions of dollars over the past 20 years buying American regional banks from Maine right down the East Coast to Florida. The bank ranks among the top 10 in the U.S. market and expansion south of the border was a core part of the growth strategy. In fact, TD had to abandon its planned US$13.4 billion takeover of First Horizon due to regulatory challenges.

TD is now in a transition phase. A new chief executive officer will take control next month to work out a new strategy to deliver growth for shareholders. At the current share price, investors can get a dividend yield of 5% from TD stock.

Is one a better pick?

Royal Bank isn’t cheap right now, and the dividend yield is a bit low, but the stock still deserves to be on your radar for a buy-and-hold portfolio focused on total returns.

TD is arguably a contrarian pick right now. Investors will need to be patient, but the shares might be undervalued at this point and you get paid a decent dividend yield to wait for a recovery.

Income investors might want to go with TD as the first choice today. Otherwise, it might be worthwhile to split a new investment between the two stocks.

The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Fool contributor Andrew Walker has no position in any stock mentioned.

More on Bank Stocks

data analyze research
Stocks for Beginners

TD’s Dividend Is Only Half the Investment Case: Here’s the Recovery Math

TD’s dividend pays you while you wait. The bigger payoff depends on how much more the bank can earn from…

Read more »

traders work at stock exchange
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Bank Stocks: Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Explore the Big Six, their latest earnings and dividend yields, with income and defensive picks.

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Bank Stocks

Canadian Bank Stocks in Late 2026: Which to Buy and Which to Skip

Canada’s banking sector is a bedrock of stability but a Big Bank stock stands out if you’re investing before 2026…

Read more »

The RRSP (Canadian Registered Retirement Savings Plan) is a smart way to save and invest for the future
Bank Stocks

Maxing Out Your TFSA Is Just the Beginning: Here’s What to Do Next

Maxing out your TFSA is not only a financial achievement but also the beginning of the next phase of your…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Stocks for Beginners

How I’d Turn Quarterly Bank Dividends Into a Monthly Paycheque

Quarterly bank dividends can fund regular monthly transfers without choosing stocks for payment dates.

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Bank Stocks

How Much to Invest in TD Bank Stock for $5,000 a Year in Dividends

TD Bank (TSX:TD) stock has been so resilient lately and it's a massive shareholder-friendly dividend giant worth buying up.

Read more »

Group of people in a line at an ATM waiting to make a cash withdrawal
Stocks for Beginners

Scotiabank vs. BMO: Which Bank Would I Choose for Retirement Income?

Scotiabank gets my retirement-income preference, while BMO offers a lower adjusted payout ratio and U.S. recovery potential.

Read more »

Happy golf player walks the course
Stocks for Beginners

The TFSA Investment Strategy I’d Use to Build a Retirement Paycheque

This TFSA investment strategy combines global growth, bonds, and dividend income to help build a reliable retirement paycheque.

Read more »