Why Chasing High Yields Is the Fastest Way to Lose Money

Here’s why high-yield dividend stocks come with so much risk, and how to ensure the stocks you’re buying are safe and reliable.

| More on:
Key Points
  • Dividend investing can compound wealth long‑term, but chasing ultra‑high yields is risky—yield spikes often reflect falling share prices and unsustainable payouts (e.g., BCE’s pre‑cut yield topped double digits before its reduction).
  • Two high‑quality picks: BCE (TSX:BCE) — an essential telecom with ~5% yield now better positioned after heavy capex and a steadier dividend outlook; Freehold Royalties (TSX:FRU) — a low‑risk energy royalty offering ~6.2% yield with payout ratios typically managed at ~60–80% to support sustainability.
  • 5 stocks our experts like better than Freehold Royalties

For many Canadians, dividend investing is one of the best ways to build real wealth over the long haul. When you own high-quality companies that pay reliable dividends, you continue to receive consistent cash flow, which you can immediately reinvest back in the market and let compounding work.

Over the decades that continuously compounding stream of income can help turn even modest investments into significant sums. However, the key for investors is to ensure the companies you buy for the long haul are reliable, well-established businesses with reliable or defensive operations.

And while that might make sense on the surface, when it comes to actually picking individual stocks, many investors fall into the trap of trying to chase the highest yields they can find.

A stock offering investors a 10% yield looks far more compelling on the surface compared to a 4% yield. That’s exactly the trap, though. High yields are almost always a red flag for the market.

Dividend yields rise when share prices fall. So often, a high-yield stock that continues to trade cheaply and struggles to recover has a dividend that the market thinks is unsustainable.

This happens all the time when a company’s dividend becomes unsustainable. For example, last year, before BCE (TSX: BCE) ultimately cut its dividend by 56% in May, the stock’s yield had risen to more than 13%.

That’s why the most important thing when it comes to dividend investing isn’t the yield it offers today. It’s the sustainability of that dividend in the near and long term. You have to assess whether the company keep paying and ideally growing that dividend for years.

So, if you’re looking for a high-quality dividend stock to buy today, here are two high-quality picks.

Yellow caution tape attached to traffic cone

Source: Getty Images

Two of the best dividend stocks on the TSX today

Although BCE had to trim its dividend last year, the stock remains one of the best companies that dividend investors can buy and hold for the long haul. As a telecom stock, it consistently generates billions in cash flow each year by providing essential communication services to Canadians.

However, the telecom sector saw a period of significant investment over the last three years as companies rushed to build out their 5G and fibre infrastructure in order to stay competitive. This was a necessary move, but it also caused BCE’s free cash flow to turn negative for a few years, making a dividend cut necessary to improve the company’s sustainability going forward.

Now, however, with nearly all that heavy capital investment behind it, and with a much more sustainable dividend going forward, BCE is once again one of the best dividend stocks to buy now.

Plus, not only does it offer an attractive yield of 5% today, but with the stock in a much stronger position now than it was a year ago, it has the potential to begin increasing its dividend annually once again.

In addition to BCE, Freehold Royalties (TSX: FRU) is another high-quality dividend stock that investors can buy with confidence today.

The energy stock has a simple and low-risk business model that makes it ideal for dividend investors. It simply collects a royalty from other energy companies that use its land to produce oil and gas.

Therefore, it’s constantly generating cash flow without needing to spend any money on capital expenditures itself. Furthermore, the stock consistently aims to keep its payout ratio between 60% and 80% of its funds from operations, to ensure it remains sustainable. And right now, Freehold is offering investors a yield of more than 6.2%.

So, if you’re looking to boost your passive income with reliable, high-yield dividend stocks, there’s no question that Freehold is one of the best.

Fool contributor Daniel Da Costa has positions in Bce and Freehold Royalties. The Motley Fool recommends Freehold Royalties. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Agricultural harvesting at the last light of day, aerial view.
Dividend Stocks

Potash Power Play: Why This Overlooked Commodity Could Be Canada’s Trump Card

Canada’s potash dominance gives Nutrien a strategic edge as trade tensions rise, making this overlooked commodity worth watching closely.

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Dividend Stocks

Trade War 2.0: The TSX Stocks That Could Actually Benefit From U.S. Tariffs

These two TSX stocks could give investors great ways to benefit from Trade War 2.0.

Read more »

A red umbrella stands higher than a crowd of black umbrellas.
Dividend Stocks

A 6% Yield Won’t Save a Weak Dividend: I’d Buy This Growing Payout Instead

A lower 3.3% yield can beat a 6% yield over time if the dividend keeps growing, and Manulife is showing…

Read more »

infrastructure like highways enables economic growth
Dividend Stocks

A $7,000 TFSA Contribution Could Become $70,000: Here’s the Math

A single $7,000 TFSA contribution can grow into $70,000 over decades if you pair time with a durable grower like…

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Dividend Stocks

Buy the Dip: 2 TSX Dividend Stocks to Own for Passive Income

These stocks now offer yields well above 5%.

Read more »

TFSA (Tax-Free Savings Account) on wooden blocks and Canadian one hundred dollar bills.
Dividend Stocks

The First $100,000 Is the Hardest: Here’s How a TFSA Can Do the Rest

Hit $100,000 in a TFSA and compounding can start doing more work than your annual contributions.

Read more »

Income and growth financial chart
Dividend Stocks

Got $10,000 Sitting in Your TFSA? I’d Make This Move Before the Next Rally

Letting $10,000 sit in a TFSA feels safe, but it can quietly lose buying power if it stays uninvested.

Read more »

the word REIT is an acronym for real estate investment trust
Dividend Stocks

This Industrial REIT Could Be a Quiet Growth Engine

Learn how Granite REIT utilizes a strategic approach to enhance portfolio growth through its diverse industrial properties.

Read more »