TFSA Investors: Don’t Chase Yield — Do This Instead

Total return, fees, and diversification matter far more than headline yield.

Key Points
  • Dividends and distributions aren’t free money, total return matters more than a high yield.
  • Long-term TFSA investors benefit more from low fees and broad diversification than from chasing income.
  • XAW offers exposure to over global 8,000 stocks at a low cost, making it a strong core holding for a diversified portfolio.

I don’t know who needs to hear this, but income isn’t free money. Whether it’s a dividend from a stock or a distribution from an exchange-traded fund (ETF), the math is the same.

On the ex-dividend or distribution date, the price of that stock or the net asset value of that ETF drops by the exact amount paid out, all else being equal. It doesn’t matter if it recovers later in the day. It’s just an accounting mechanic.

That’s important to understand because there’s a lot of interest in using a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) for passive income. And that’s fine. It’s certainly better than leaving cash sitting idle and losing purchasing power to inflation.

But if you’re still years, or even decades, away from needing that income, chasing yield may not be the best move. If you’re willing to delay gratification, your TFSA can be much more powerful as a compounding machine.

Loading up on double-digit yield stocks or funds often means taking on more risk or sacrificing long-term growth. Instead, the focus should be on two things: low fees and broad diversification.

ETF is short for exchange traded fund, a popular investment choice for Canadians

Source: Getty Images

Why low fees and global diversification matter

When you invest, there are forces working for you and against you. Markets, over time, tend to grow. That’s the tailwind. But fees, poor diversification, and bad timing decisions can all drag your returns down.

Many investors end up underperforming not because markets fail, but because they get in their own way. The simplest solution is to aim for the market’s average return while removing as many obstacles as possible.

Diversification is a big part of that. The global stock market includes thousands of companies, yet only a small percentage of those stocks drive most of the long-term gains. If you’re holding just a handful of names, the odds of consistently picking those winners are low.

That’s why John Bogle, the founder of Vanguard, popularized the idea of “buying the haystack.” Instead of trying to find the needle, you own every stock from different sectors, sizes, and countries.

The second piece is cost. Fees come directly out of your returns, and they compound over time just like gains do, except in the wrong direction. Paying high fees for a concentrated portfolio makes little sense when you can own a broadly diversified one at a fraction.

The ETF that puts this into practice

One ETF that captures this approach is the iShares Core MSCI All Country World ex Canada Index ETF (TSX: XAW).

It holds more than 8,200 stocks from around the world, giving you exposure to the United States, developed international markets like Japan, the United Kingdom, and Germany, as well as emerging markets such as China, India, and Brazil.

Importantly, it excludes Canada. That’s actually a feature. Many Canadian investors already have a home bias through individual stocks or other holdings. Using this ETF as the foundation of your portfolio helps you diversify globally without doubling up on Canadian exposure. Even if your Canadian picks underperform, the rest of your portfolio is still tied to the broader global market.

It’s also cost-efficient. With a 0.22% management expense ratio, you’re getting access to thousands of stocks across multiple regions at a relatively low cost. The ETF handles rebalancing and underlying exposure for you, making it a hands-off solution.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

person with spyglass looks at ocean horizon
Dividend Stocks

This 5.9% Dividend Stock Is One I’ll Never Sell — Here’s Why

This Canadian dividend stock has a great combination of a 5.8% dividend yield, resilient cash flow, and billions of dollars…

Read more »

nugget gold
Stocks for Beginners

Gold Just Had a Rough Week: Is This Canadian Miner Still Worth Buying?

Agnico Eagle shares had a rough week, but record cash flow and a net-cash balance sheet keep the thesis interesting.

Read more »

concept of growth
Dividend Stocks

The Dividend Stock I’d Never Sell, Even in a Downturn

Fortis is a dividend stock I'd hold through a downturn. Its regulated utilities and dividend growth support a patient approach…

Read more »

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Energy Stocks

This Undervalued Dividend Stock Yields 4.3% and Keeps Growing

TC Energy (TSX:TRP) is an undervalued dividend titan to buy as shares come in further.

Read more »

patient tests her eyes with a vision test at a doctor
Stocks for Beginners

Don’t Make This TFSA Contribution Room Mistake

Before adding money to your TFSA, make sure you know your actual contribution room.

Read more »

frustrated shopper at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks Retirees Can Count on for Decades

These two Canadian dividend stocks offer a great mix of essential businesses, regular dividends, and long-term growth investments that could…

Read more »

AI concept person in profile
Investing

2 Stocks I’d Buy Now and Hold for the Next 5 Years

These Canadian companies are positioned to benefit from long-term trends that could support their growth for years to come.

Read more »

customer comparison shops in liquor store
Dividend Stocks

How Much TFSA Income Triggers an OAS Clawback?

The OAS clawback is based on net world income, with a 2025 minimum recovery threshold of $93,454, not on a…

Read more »