Why I’d Choose This Dividend Stock Over Telus or BCE Any Day

Telecoms are expected to face headwinds from falling immigration, while oil & gas stocks may benefit from the ongoing conflict.

Key Points
  • Slowing immigration growth may create headwinds for telecom companies like TELUS and BCE that benefited heavily from post-COVID subscriber growth.
  • PrairieSky Royalty uses an asset-light royalty model that generates high margins without directly drilling or operating wells.
  • While the dividend yield is lower at roughly 3.15%, PrairieSky maintains a conservative payout ratio and a very strong balance sheet.

Beyond just looking at company fundamentals, I think investors also need to pay attention to the broader macroeconomic backdrop when deciding which stocks to buy. Right now, I think the environment is becoming more of a headwind than a tailwind for Canadian telecom giants like TELUS (TSX: T) and BCE (TSX: BCE).

During the years immediately following COVID, both companies benefited heavily from surging immigration levels. International students, temporary foreign workers, and new permanent residents all needed cellphone plans, internet subscriptions, and bundled telecom services. Population growth became a major driver of subscriber growth.

That backdrop is now changing. Under Mark Carney’s new Liberal government, Canada has steadily reduced targets for temporary foreign workers and international students. Immigration growth is slowing, and I think that creates a meaningful challenge for telecom companies that had become increasingly reliant on population growth to drive top-line expansion.

Meanwhile, the setup for Canadian energy has improved considerably. With the U.S.-Israel versus Iran conflict now entering its third month and ongoing disruptions surrounding the Strait of Hormuz, global energy security is back in focus. Canadian producers are once again being viewed as a relatively stable and secure source of supply during a period of geopolitical turbulence.

So if I were investing in dividend stocks today, I would personally skip the telecoms and look toward PrairieSky Royalty (TSX: PSK) instead. The yield is lower at 3.2%, but I think there are several reasons why this may ultimately prove to be the more durable investment.

oil pumps at sunset

Source: Getty Images

What is PrairieSky Royalty?

PrairieSky is not your typical oil and gas company. The business is not drilling wells, exploring for oil, or operating pipelines. Instead, PrairieSky owns mineral rights and royalty interests tied to energy-producing land across Canada.

Specifically, the company owns roughly 9.9 million acres of fee simple mineral title lands, along with another 8.7 million acres tied to gross overriding royalty interests. Gross overriding royalties essentially allow PrairieSky to collect a percentage of production revenue generated by other companies operating on its land.

That distinction is important because it removes many of the risks traditionally associated with energy investing. PrairieSky does not need to spend heavily drilling new wells or maintaining production infrastructure. It simply collects royalties when third-party operators successfully produce oil and gas from its lands.

Today, the company has more than 335 producing leases spanning over 30 geological horizons. That diversification gives PrairieSky exposure across multiple formations, operators, and commodity streams instead of relying on a single producing asset. This model creates a very different financial profile compared to the average TSX energy stock.

For example, PrairieSky currently generates a profit margin of roughly 45.3%, which is exceptionally high for the energy sector. Traditional producers cannot match this, because they have to deal with volatile operating costs, capital expenditures, transportation expenses, and debt servicing requirements that can heavily compress margins during weaker commodity cycles.

The dividend is conservative on purpose

One thing I actually like about PrairieSky is that management does not appear overly aggressive with the dividend. Oil and gas remains a cyclical business. During boom periods, many companies become tempted to dramatically raise payouts, only to slash them later once commodity prices weaken.

PrairieSky takes a more measured approach. The company currently pays an annualized dividend of $1.06 per share on a quarterly basis, which works out to a yield of roughly 3.15% at current prices. That yield is lower than what investors can get from some telecom or high-yield energy stocks today. But the tradeoff is that the payout appears substantially more sustainable.

As of Q1 2026, PrairieSky maintained a dividend payout ratio of roughly 65%. Management also highlights several structural advantages supporting the business, including no maintenance capital expenditures, no operating costs tied to production, and no abandonment or environmental liabilities.

The balance sheet also remains very strong, with debt sitting at just 0.6 times EBITDA over the trailing 12 months. For income investors, that combination of asset-light royalties, conservative payouts, and low leverage is hard to ignore.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends TELUS. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Energy Stocks

investor schemes to buy stocks before market notices them
Energy Stocks

I’m Betting My Future on This Canadian Dividend Giant

TC Energy combines a 4%-plus yield with contracted growth as LNG, electricity, and data centres increase natural gas demand.

Read more »

RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan) on wooden blocks and Canadian one hundred dollar bills.
Energy Stocks

3 Canadian Stocks I’d Load Into My RRSP Without Hesitation

Here's why Tourmaline, Brookfield Renewable, and Allied Gold could anchor a long-term RRSP.

Read more »

man in bowtie poses with abacus
Energy Stocks

Enbridge: My Honest ‘Buy, Sell or Hold’ Take on the Stock

Enbridge stock's recent 17% drop pushes its yield to 5.8%. Is ENB a Buy, Sell, or Hold? Here is an…

Read more »

The sun sets behind a power source
Energy Stocks

Buy This Stock, Forget It, Thank Yourself in 10 Years

A 3.6% yield and 54 years of dividend growth make Canadian Utilities the kind of stock you tuck away and…

Read more »

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

Fortis Stock Is Down 10%: Buy, Sell, or Hold Right Now?

After Fortis stock pulled back nearly 10% from its midsummer high, is this the buying opportunity investors have been waiting…

Read more »

golden sunset in crude oil refinery with pipeline system
Energy Stocks

TC Energy Stock Is Down 14%—Should You Buy the Dip?

Down 14%, TC Energy stock still offers a 4.2% yield following 25 years of dividend raises. With AI and LNG…

Read more »

Trans Alaska Pipeline with Autumn Colors
Energy Stocks

The High-Yield Stock That Isn’t a Trap

Although this stock yields nearly 6%, its payout ratio is just 63%, showing why it's one of the best high-yield…

Read more »

The TFSA is a powerful savings vehicle for Canadians who are saving for retirement.
Energy Stocks

Is Too Much Cash Holding Back Your TFSA?

Cash feels safe, but keeping too much of it in a long-term TFSA can quietly erode your future buying power.

Read more »