This Unexpected Stock Is My TFSA’s Dirty Little Secret

A high-yield energy stock paying monthly dividends is a reliable income engine for a TFSA portfolio.

Key Points
  • Peyto (TSX:PEY) is a mid‑cap natural‑gas producer paying a predictable monthly dividend with a yield of about 5.8%, pitched as a TFSA income pick.
  • Its low‑cost Alberta Deep Basin operations, control of gathering/processing, strong 2026 performance (YTD earnings +37%, Q2 FCF US$140.6M) and a 10‑year Centrica sales agreement (2029–2039) support dividend sustainability.
  • A $14,000 TFSA today would generate roughly $67.67/month (~$812/yr) and, with dividend reinvestment and Peyto’s hedging policy, could more than double in ~12.5 years — though outcomes remain exposed to commodity cycles.

Canadians can build real wealth through the Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA). However, a truly rewarding strategy isn’t just chasing high yields, but also prioritizing frequent cash distributions for faster, tax-free compounding or immediate passive income. Right now, a mid-cap stock in the energy sector deserves serious consideration.

Peyto Exploration & Development (TSX: PEY) is my TFSA’s dirty little secret. Beyond its attractive 5.8% yield, PEY delivers a predictable monthly dividend. The $5 billion energy company boasts some of the lowest-cost, highly efficient natural gas operations in North America. At $24.39 per share, you’d be investing in an infrastructure-backed income engine.

dividend stocks are a good way to earn passive income

Source: Getty Images

Profitable enterprise

The 2026 Middle East conflict has disrupted world oil supplies and continues to drive prices higher. Peyto Exploration & Development didn’t exactly benefit from the war, as it was consistently and strongly profitable long before it started. According to management, operating results over the last 27 years reflect the successful implementation of Peyto’s strategies.

In full-year 2025, total net earnings from natural gas and natural gas liquid sales rose 49.2% to $418.6 million compared to full-year 2024. Natural gas prices were lower during the year, but disciplined hedging and a diversification program protected revenues. Over the last few years, Peyto has invested capital in the profitable development of long-life, low-cost, and low-risk natural gas resource plays.

On a year-to-date basis (six months ending June 30, 2026), earnings increased 37% year-over-year to $277.3 million, while free funds flow in Q2 2026 reached $140.6 million. At the quarter’s end, net debt declined 18.3% to $1 billion from a year ago. The plan is to manage production and limit exposure to weaker-priced markets during summer.

Business control

Peyto has direct control over all of its gathering systems, processing, and pipelines. This structural advantage keeps production costs low. Its operations are concentrated in the Alberta Deep Basin. Ever-growing demand for natural gas and gas-fired power, along with the prospect of the liquefied natural gas (LNG) buildout in Canada and the U.S. to supply global markets, are strong tailwinds.

On June 2, 2026, Peyto signed a 10-year natural gas purchase agreement with Centrica Energy, a British global energy trading company. According to its President and CEO, Jean-Paul Lachance, diversifying natural gas sales to premium demand markets has been Peyto’s core strategy. In this first exposure to the European market, Peyto will deliver 50,000 million British thermal units (MMBtu) of natural gas daily, starting in 2029 through 2039.

Superior total return

The Peyto model is engineered for superior total return, encompassing growth in value, assets, production, and income. Its forward hedging policy protects future revenues from volatility in oil and natural gas prices.  Predictable revenue streams fund Peyto’s capital programs and help sustain monthly dividend payouts across all stages of the commodity cycle.

PEY has consistently paid monthly dividends since January 2012. A $14,000 TFSA investment today will generate $67.67 in tax-free monthly income ($812 annually). Assuming you reinvest dividends, your money will more than double to $28,855.80 in 12.5 years. This reliable income engine can fuel your long-term wealth strategy.

Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Energy Stocks

diversification is an important part of building a stable portfolio
Dividend Stocks

Diversification 101: How Beginners Can Protect Against Market Shocks

Stocks like TD Bank and Fortis provide an anchor to a well-diversified portfolio for resilient long-term performance.

Read more »

chart reflected in eyeglass lenses
Energy Stocks

Is Emera Stock a Buy Before Its Proposed Merger With Canadian Utilities?

A reliable dividend and the prospect of a much larger utility business make Emera stock worth watching before the merger.

Read more »

Board Game, Chess, Chess Board, Chess Piece, Hand
Energy Stocks

Cenovus Energy Plans to Buy Athabasca Oil for $5.7 Billion: Is the Stock a Steal Before the Deal?

Cenovus is paying $5.7 billion for Athabasca Oil. Here is what the deal means for ATH stock and whether it…

Read more »

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

Better Stock to Buy Now: Fortis vs. Hydro One

Let’s compare Fortis and Hydro One to determine which utility stock offers the more compelling investment opportunity amid ongoing macroeconomic…

Read more »

Colored pins on calendar showing a month
Energy Stocks

Alberta Will Detail New Oil Royalty Incentives in November: This Monthly-Paying Oil Stock is Ready

Whitecap’s dividend has a reported cash cushion, while Alberta’s planned royalty changes still need project-level scrutiny.

Read more »

data center server racks glow with light
Energy Stocks

I’m Betting on Hammond Power After a 45% Sales Jump

Hammond Power will continue to benefit from rising investment in AI data centres, electrification, and power infrastructure.

Read more »

worry concern
Energy Stocks

Cenovus Just Paid $5.7 Billion for Oil Sands Growth: Should Your TFSA Follow?

Cenovus’s proposed oil sands purchase creates a specific debt hurdle for investors considering the stock in a TFSA.

Read more »

Energy Stocks

Why Canadians Love Dividend Stocks (and What Beginners Should Know)

Canadian stocks like Enbridge are prime examples of the many benefits of dividend stocks, such as reliability and income.

Read more »