CN Keeps Chugging Along

CN Rail maintains its position atop the North American rail heap by turning in a solid Q4 and 2012.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

I wonder how many times some derivation of this title has been used as an intro for this railroad king?  Another year is in the books for CN Rail (TSX:CNR,NYSE:CNI) and the company has produced yet another round of outstanding results.

Q4 and 2012 broke records for CNR in terms of carloads, revenues, and revenue ton-miles.  The company generated $1 billion in free cash flow in 2012 and is rewarding shareholders with a 15% bump to the quarterly dividend.  Adjusted earnings per share for the full year were $5.61, and CN management expects to grow this figure in the high single digits in 2013. The company expects the transport of energy-related products to be a primary driver of earnings growth, as North American pipeline capacity remains constrained.

That’s all positive news as far as I can tell.  Of course, the stock was down 1% or so on the day!

Cream of the crop

Pure and simple, this is one of Canada’s finest companies and based on its operating ratio, CN is the best run railroad in North America.  If his friend Bill Gates didn’t already own 10% of CN, would this have been the railroad that Warren Buffet chose to invest in, instead of Burlington Northern?

For the full year 2012, CN’s operating ratio, which compares operating expenses to revenues (lower is better), checked in at 62.9%, an improvement of 0.6% from the year before.  According to figures derived from Capital IQ, U.S. peers Union Pacific came in at 68.1%, CSX managed 70.4%, and Norfolk Southern posted 71.3%.  The gap is even larger when compared to CN’s chief Canadian rival, CP Rail (TSX:CP,NYSE:CP) and its 78.1% ratio.

Over the past year, however, this operating gap over its rival has not translated to better stock performance.  CN’s stock price has generated a 19% return for investors since January 2012, while CP has increased by 53%.  CP was all over the financial headlines throughout 2012, as famed investor Bill Ackman renovated the company’s executive suite and parachuted in retired CN CEO Hunter Harrison to help close the operating gap between the two companies.  The market smiled upon this move, and CP’s stock reacted accordingly.

What’s done is done

As investors, we must be aware of these past events, but always looking to the future.  Yes, CP was the better stock in 2012. But what about 2013, and more importantly, beyond?  The table below outlines a range of possible one-year expected prices for CN’s stock.  I am taking the company’s management at its word and assuming high single-digit EPS growth for next year.  In addition, the range of possible multiples are based on historical levels.

P/E Multiple Range

EPS Growth EPS





7.0% $6.00 $90.04 $96.04 $102.05 $108.05
8.0% $6.06 $90.88 $96.94 $103.00 $109.06
9.0% $6.11 $91.72 $97.84 $103.95 $110.07

We arrive at a high of $110 and low of $90, or upside of 19% and downside of 2%, when the 1.8% yield is factored in.  Let’s assign a 50-50 probability to both outcomes, and therefore target a 2013 total return for CN of 8.5%.

Now, that doesn’t look like much, but CN is not necessarily built to perform over one-year periods.  With a tremendous track record of blowing the doors off the competition, this is a company you buy and hold, and hold, and hold – just like Buffet will do with Burlington Northern.  In some years, CN’s stock will provide a return of 19%, and in some years it will go down 2%. But if it is able to generate a CAGR of 8.5%, investors could double their money every nine years by owning this stock.

Priced in

As for CP, the outlook is far less certain.  I have the utmost respect for the two principal players – Harrison and Ackman.  I’ve had the pleasure of meeting Harrison, and a more passionate and capable executive you will not find.  His track record in bringing CN to where it is today speaks for itself.  I admire Ackman so much that I went out and bought (and am underwater on) a small slice of JC Penney – his U.S. department-store turnaround idea.

However, after its tremendous run over the past 12 months, CP now trades with an earnings multiple of 27 – compared to CN’s at just a little more than 16.  Given that CP’s operating ratio hasn’t even begun to approach the peer group’s, let alone CN’s, one has to believe that the stock’s value already reflects Harrison’s and Ackman’s capabilities.

Bet on the turtle

This time next year, and for years to come, I expect a very similar report from CN’s management, and a very favourable, risk-adjusted return for CN’s investors.  I don’t have the same degree of confidence that CP offers the same scenario.

At this point in the race, I feel far more comfortable predicting an 8.5% CAGR over the next five to 10 years for CN than I do for CP.

Follow us on Twitter for the latest in Foolish investing.

Fool contributor Iain Butler owns shares and is short put options in JC Penney.  David Gardner owns shares of Canadian National Railway.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

More on Investing

stock analysis

Buy the Dip: 2 Stocks to Buy Today and Hold for the Next 5 Years

These Canadian stocks are trading at discounted valuations, providing an opportunity for buying the dip.

Read more »

bulb idea thinking

Safety in Size? 2 of the Bluest Blue-Chip Stocks I’d Buy Now

TC Energy (TSX:TRP) and another cash cow have huge dividend yields for safe investors.

Read more »

A cannabis plant grows.
Cannabis Stocks

Can Aurora Cannabis Stock Recover in 2024?

Aurora Cannabis stock is down 99% from all-time highs but remains a high-risk bet, despite its cheap valuation.

Read more »

Question marks in a pile
Dividend Stocks

Where Will Brookfield Infrastructure Partners Stock Be in 5 Years?

Brookfield Infrastructure Partners (TSX:BIP.UN) kicked off 2024 with a bang. Where will it be in five years?

Read more »

TFSA and coins

TFSA Investors: 3 Incredible Stocks for 2024

Are you looking for stocks to buy and hold for years for your TFSA? These three stocks could deliver exceptional…

Read more »

A person looks at data on a screen
Stocks for Beginners

3 Warren Buffett Stocks to Hold Forever

Warren Buffett sold some shares in Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL), and the market had questions.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

Golden Years Gain: Your CPP Benefits at Age 70

CPP users delaying pension payments until 70 will receive substantial monthly income streams in the golden years.

Read more »

data analytics, chart and graph icons with female hands typing on laptop in background
Dividend Stocks

3 Dividend Stocks You Can Safely Hold for Decades

Top TSX dividend stocks are on sale.

Read more »