Why Is Bank of Montreal Canada’s Worst-Performing Bank?

The bank provides another example of short-term thinking.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

Often the best investment opportunities arise when companies are willing to endure short-term pain for long-term gain. These painful decisions can result in depressed earnings and a discounted stock price. If an investor is willing to wait out the short-term noise, the odds will eventually be in his favour. But what happens when a company repeatedly does the exact opposite? Unfortunately, one of Canada’s banks is a repeat offender.

Recently a man came forward with his experience with Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO)(NYSE:BMO). One of the company’s investment advisors was duped by a fraudster, and the poor customer lost his entire $87,500 balance. That alone would not be so bad; everyone makes mistakes.

But Bank of Montreal failed to take responsibility for the error. Instead, the customer had to fight with the bank’s lawyers and managers. Making matters worse, the customer is also fighting cancer, and had to work full-time (even while on radiation) to pay for cancer drugs, instead of using the money that should have been in his account. Only when the customer threatened to go public did the bank agree to reimburse him (if he agreed to two pages of legally binding conditions).

This case is just the latest example of Bank of Montreal making a poor long-term decision to provide a short-term boost.

For example, one of the bank’s most popular mutual funds is its Monthly Income Fund, a favourite among retirees. But for years, the monthly income fund paid out a higher distribution than it could afford to. Fearing redemptions, Bank of Montreal refused to cut the distribution, even during the financial crisis. Eventually the problem snowballed out of control, and it cut the distribution by nearly 60% a year ago. The fund’s unit-holders were mostly blindsided.

Another example involves the bank’s repeated 2.99% mortgage promotions. While these promotions are popular with homebuyers, they are not good for shareholders, and have even drawn the ire of finance minister Jim Flaherty. Not coincidentally, Bank of Montreal’s Canadian banking operations have the highest expense ratio among its peers (it’s difficult to get high margins when a company keeps offering large discounts).

Foolish bottom line

The past 10 years have not been a great time to be a Bank of Montreal shareholder. Over this time, total shareholder return has been 6.15% per year, the worst of Canada’s big five banks. By comparison, the average of the other four is 9.3%. The top performer has been Royal Bank of Canada (TSX:RY)(NYSE:RY) at 11.1%. Even CIBC (TSX:CM)(NYSE:CM), which got hammered the most by the financial crisis, has outperformed Bank of Montreal.

In my opinion, this company needs a drastic culture change before it becomes a compelling investment opportunity. And judging by today’s story, that looks to be a long way off.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Benjamin Sinclair holds no positions in any of the stocks mentioned in this article.

More on Investing

Investing

$1,000 Ready to Deploy? 3 Quality TSX Stocks for Canadian Investors

Amid improving investors sentiments, the following three Canadian stocks offer excellent buying opportunities.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing the Registered Retirement Savings Plan
Dividend Stocks

RRSP Investors: 3 Canadian Dividend Stocks to Buy on Dips

These stocks have strong track records of dividend growth and now trade at discounted prices.

Read more »

concept of real estate evaluation
Dividend Stocks

Beyond Real Estate: These TSX Income Generators Could Deliver Superior Passive Income for Canadians

These two TSX dividend stocks could offer Canadian investors a reliable income stream and strong long-term upside, without relying on…

Read more »

Confused person shrugging
Dividend Stocks

Better TSX Dividend Stock to Own: Manulife or Sun Life?

While Sun Life stock has outpaced Manulife in the last two decades, which dividend-paying insurance giant is a good buy…

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Energy Stocks

Got $25,000? Turn it Into $200,000 in a TFSA as Canadian Dollar Gains

This energy stock may not have a high dividend, but it certainly has a high rate of growth to look…

Read more »

coins jump into piggy bank
Dividend Stocks

How to Use Your TFSA to Earn $1,057/Year in Tax-Free Income

Investing $5,000 in each of these high-yield dividend stocks can help you earn over $1,057 per year in tax-free income.

Read more »

data analyze research
Tech Stocks

Is BlackBerry (TSX:BB) a Buy in May 2025?

While its recent downturn might not look pretty, it might be the best opportunity to buy BlackBerry (TSX:BB) stock and…

Read more »

Piggy bank with word TFSA for tax-free savings accounts.
Investing

Where I’d Invest the New $7,000 TFSA Contribution Limit in 2025

If you have $7,000 for the new TFSA contribution increase, here are three stocks I would contemplate adding to the…

Read more »