Which Pipeline Should You Choose?

Pipelines are an important but underappreciated part of the energy sector. Of the three major players in Canada, which one offers the best value?

The Motley Fool

When hunting for investment opportunities in Canada’s oil patch, many investors look past staid pipeline and infrastructure companies in the midstream and focus instead on the more glamorous oil explorers and producers. But with Canada’s pipeline companies forming a crucial part of the energy infrastructure required to support the patch, they are a virtual gold mine for investors in this era of surging global energy demand.

Not only are they able to clip the ticket on each barrel of crude they transport, but growing energy demand from emerging economies and pipeline capacity constraints bode well for their future ability to generate revenue. With three major midstream companies operating in Canada, as well as a number of small players, the big question for investors is which one belongs in your portfolio.

This company delivers over half of Canada’s crude to the U.S.

Despite U.S. demand for Canadian crude expected to fall, midstream giant Enbridge (TSX: ENB)(NYSE: ENB) is well-positioned to continue growing.

Not only is the company responsible for shipping around 52% of the total Canadian crude exported to the U.S., but it’s also the first to receive a license from U.S. regulators allowing it to re-export Canadian crude from there. This will give Enbridge access to European markets, which are desperately trying to reduce dependency on Russian energy imports in light of the crisis in Ukraine.

Enbridge is also pushing hard for approval of its Northern Gateway pipeline that will connect the patch to Canada’s west coast, enabling access to crucial Pacific Rim energy markets. This will reduce dependence on the U.S., currently Canada’s key export market, and provide access to what is expected to become the world’s greatest consumer of energy: China. Already in 2013, China overtook the U.S. to become the world’s largest net importer of crude, and demand is expected to soar as economic growth accelerates in the world’s second-largest economy.

This bodes well for Enbridge’s future revenue, cash flow, and bottom line.

Enbridge pays a tasty dividend yield of 2.7%; over the last 10 years, its dividend has grown by 13% per year, rewarding income-hungry investors for their loyalty. With a dividend payout ratio of 60%, it’s certainly sustainable and will continue to grow as Enbridge capitalizes on accessing new markets and on its dominant position in Canada’s crude transportation industry.

This quiet achiever in the patch goes from strength to strength

Unlike its competitors Enbridge and TransCanada (TSX: TRP)(NYSE: TRP), Pembina Pipeline (TSX: PBA)(NYSE: PBA) has a lower profile. It maintains a quiet but strong presence in local communities, which has seen it deftly avoid much of the negative publicity associated with other midstream companies operating in the patch.

More importantly, it continues to perform strongly; Q1 2014 EBITDA, a measure of core profitability, jumped a solid 34% compared to the previous quarter and a massive 50% compared to the equivalent quarter in 2013. Cash flow also continues to grow, having shot up a healthy 32% quarter over quarter and 5% year over year for the first quarter of 2014.

This has seen Pembina continue to reward investors through the payment of a consistently growing monthly dividend, with the dividend being increased twice over the last year alone. This gives Pembina a very attractive dividend yield of 3.8%, but a payout ratio of 136% indicates the dividend may not be sustainable.

However, in light of the company’s history of solid cash flow growth, this dividend does appear sustainable when this ratio is calculated using operational cash flow in place of net income, where it falls to 78%.

Ongoing controversy is clouding this midstream company’s future

TransCanada continues to attract media attention for all of the wrong reasons, particularly in regards to the ongoing battle to receive approval for the northern leg of its Keystone pipeline.

But despite the controversy and TransCanada’s inability to generate income from the capital invested thus far, the company still continues to perform strongly. First quarter 2014 EBITDA shot up 5% quarter over quarter and a staggering 20% year over year.

TransCanada also pays a healthy dividend yield of 3.8% and has a payout ratio of 78%, highlighting the sustainability of the dividend.

Which one is best for your portfolio?

All three companies have strengths and weaknesses. Enbridge pays the lowest yielding dividend, Pembina has a dividend payout ratio over 100% when calculated using net income, and TransCanada’s Keystone pipeline remains mired in controversy.

When evaluating a number of key valuation ratios, it is TransCanada that appears the cheapest, with an EV of 14 times EBITDA compared to Enbridge’s 23 times and Pembina’s 17 times. However, it is Pembina that has the strongest balance sheet, with a conservative debt-to-equity ratio of 0.38, while TransCanada’s is 1.28 and Enbridge’s is a massive 1.53 times equity.

While all three offer an attractive opportunity for investors to bet on solid ongoing growth in the patch, it is Pembina which stands out as the obvious choice for risk-averse investors. Not only does it pay a monthly dividend with a solid yield of almost 3.8%, but it also has the strongest balance sheet coupled with solid EBITDA growth.

However, for risk-tolerant investors who are willing to gamble on the eventual approval of the Keystone pipeline, TransCanada may offer better value given it is the most attractively priced.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Matt Smith does not own shares of any companies mentioned.

More on Investing


Got $5,000? Buy and Hold These 3 Value Stocks for Years

Given their solid underlying businesses, healthy growth prospects, and attractive valuation, I am bullish on these three value stocks.

Read more »

money cash dividends
Stocks for Beginners

Got $1,000 to Invest in Stocks? Put It in This Index Fund

This low-cost beginner-friendly ETF is a great way to invest $1,000.

Read more »

Overhead shot of young adults using technology at a table
Tech Stocks

3 Cheap Tech Stocks to Buy Right Now

Given their long-term growth prospects and discounted stock prices, I am bullish on these tech stocks.

Read more »

money cash dividends
Dividend Stocks

Have $500? 2 Absurdly Cheap Stocks Long-Term Investors Should Buy Right Now

Want some absurdly cheap stocks for your portfolio? Here are two options trading at a huge discount right now.

Read more »

Gas pipelines
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Passive Income: Is Enbridge Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold?

Enbridge now offers a yield near 8%. Is the dividend safe?

Read more »

A worker uses the cloud for paperless work. tech
Tech Stocks

Wanna Beat the Market? Try These 2 Tech Stocks That Look Undervalued Today

Here's why undervalued TSX stocks such as Vitalhub can help you generate outsized gains in the next 12 months.

Read more »

Redwood trees stretch up to the sunlight.
Tech Stocks

These 3 Magnificent Stocks Keep Driving Higher

Constellation Software, Dollarama and another TSX stock have consistently generated positive investment returns. Here’s why they belong in your retirement…

Read more »

sale discount best price
Dividend Stocks

3 Stocks to Buy While They Are on Sale

Top TSX dividend stocks are trading at discounted prices.

Read more »