Should You Sell Overpriced Stocks for Gains?

The Coca-Cola Co (NYSE:KO) and another U.S. dividend-growth stock are overpriced. Should you sell quality companies for gains and move on?

The Motley Fool

We invest to earn more money. Theoretically, we want to buy when a business is priced at a discount and potentially sell it when it reaches your fair-value range or becomes overvalued. The reason some investors might sell at fair value is because there’s little margin of safety left for the stock, and any news or macro factors might bring the shares lower.

Should we sell overpriced stocks for gains?

If you’re a true investor, you’re building a portfolio of stocks. Your portfolio might consist of companies from the sectors of consumer discretionary, healthcare, technology, telecommunications services, industrials, energy, materials, financials, and consumer staples.

The Coca-Cola Co (NYSE: KO), of the consumer discretionary sector, is at US$45 and overvalued by about 13% based on its normal 10-year multiple. Does this mean shareholders should sell it for gains?

Investors should decide what to do with overvalued shares by considering their situations. Did they buy Coca-Cola for gains or for its dividend? If they bought it for its dividend, then they should hold it. And if they don’t have much exposure to consumer staples in their portfolios, they might wish to hold on to the shares.

If they sell, it could be a long time before Coca-Cola is priced attractively enough to buy again, and they’ll need to decide where to invest the money instead to get the same yield of the same quality (if not better quality).

Procter & Gamble Co (NYSE: PG) is another consumer staples company that’s overvalued. At about US$81, Procter & Gamble is overvalued by (coincidentally) 13% based on its normal 10-year multiple.

It is undergoing a transformation by cutting out its non-core brands. So, its earnings could actually continue to fall this year. Last year, its earnings per share fell by 5%.

If shareholders sell it, they should know what to replace it with that’s of the same quality and has a yield of at least 3.3%.

In summary

Investors should consider the alternative investments to the proceeds of the sales before selling. If the alternatives are of the same quality but priced at a cheaper valuation, it might make sense to sell. Other considerations include the sector and company allocations of your portfolio. For example, if you only have 5% of your portfolio in consumer staples, you might wish to hold on to your Coca-Cola and Procter & Gamble shares.

Investors should revisit their goals of investing in each stock before deciding whether to sell or not. Selling may be warranted if their original goal was to sell Coca-Cola at, say, US$45.

Instead of selling quality companies such as Coca-Cola and Procter & Gamble, I think it makes more sense to hold them and look for other companies to add. This way, a solid diversified portfolio can be built.

Fool contributor Kay Ng owns shares of Coca-Cola and Procter & Gamble.

More on Dividend Stocks

holding coins in hand for the future
Dividend Stocks

How Dweeby-Sounding “DRIPs” Can Supercharge Your Portfolio Growth

A dividend reinvestment plan can turn small cash payments into more shares. The trick is knowing when your dividend is…

Read more »

a man relaxes with his feet on a pile of books
Dividend Stocks

5 of the Best Canadian Dividend Stocks to Buy This Month

These best Canadian dividend stocks have reliable distribution payment and growth histories, and sustainable payouts.

Read more »

warehouse worker takes inventory in storage room
Dividend Stocks

This 5.6% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Every Single Month

This TSX-listed monthly dividend stock’s attractive 5.6% dividend yield, growing rental income, and expanding property portfolio could make it a…

Read more »

Aircraft Mechanic checking jet engine of the airplane
Dividend Stocks

Exchange Income vs. Cargojet: Which Aviation Stock Fits a Long-Term Portfolio?

Both businesses depend on keeping aircraft busy. Exchange Income’s mix of essential routes and manufacturing gives it the edge for…

Read more »

Agricultural irrigation sprinkler gun spraying water
Dividend Stocks

1 Magnificent Canadian Dividend Stock Down 28% to Buy and Hold for Decades

Nutrien (TSX:NTR) stock still stands out as a magnificent play that could help boost dividend investors portfolios over time.

Read more »

man touches brain to show a good idea
Dividend Stocks

1 No Brainer Canadian Stock to Buy and Hold Forever

CN stock is up 35% in 2026, yet Q3 earnings jumped 18% on only 4% more volume. See why this…

Read more »

man calculates finances
Dividend Stocks

What $50,000 Across 3 Dividend Stocks Could Add to Your Retirement Budget

A utility, a pipeline and a railway show how $50,000 could start paying part of the retirement budget.

Read more »

woman stares at chocolate layer cake
Dividend Stocks

Power Corporation vs. Great-West Lifeco: Which Dividend Stock Would I Own?

Power Corporation gives you exposure to Great-West and more. I’d take Great-West directly when I want to know what’s funding…

Read more »