MENU

Enbridge Inc. vs. TransCanada Corp.: Better Buy on the Dip?

If you’re a contrarian value investor who’s interested in locking in an above-average dividend yield relative to their principal, it’s hard to ignore the Canadian mid-stream energy stocks. They appear to be severely undervalued after experiencing bouts of weakness over the last few years.

Enbridge Inc. (TSX:ENB)(NYSE:ENB) and TransCanada Corp. (TSX:TRP)(NYSE:TRP) are two former market darlings that are down from all-time highs by ~37% and ~15%, respectively. Both stocks offer above-average dividend yields of 6.5% and 5%, respectively, at the time of writing, and each dividend is expected to continue to grow over the foreseeable future in spite of their recent troubles.

Both stocks remain dividend-growth kings that look poised to continue their respective annual dividend growth streaks, but which, if any, is the better buy into weakness?

Enbridge

A high yield, a double-digit dividend growth rate and above-average capital gains. That’s what Enbridge was known for prior to its 2015 tumble that saw the stock became a falling knife before bouncing back and falling to even lower lows, trapping many bulls in process.

Although Enbridge stock no longer offers investors the best of both worlds in the form of high capital gains to go with its juicy dividend yield, two of the three traits that made Enbridge a must-have holding are still intact. In fact, the dividend yield is over double of what it was prior to the initial collapse in shares. And this, combined with vastly cheaper shares should have many investors hungry to add to their positions gradually on the way down.

As a falling knife with a considerable amount of negative momentum, the stock remains technically unsound; however, investors shouldn’t be afraid to nibble away at shares with the expectation that the stock will continue to fall.

With Spectra Energy Partners, LP‘s promising natural gas assets in the mix and a plan to further sell non-core assets in order to cut down on its debt load, I think it’s just a matter of time before Enbridge shares finally bottom out. However, with no real near-term catalyst on the horizon, investors will need to exhibit patience with the name. The massive 6.5% dividend provides a huge incentive to those who are willing to hang in there in spite of the continued doom and gloom sentiment regarding many aspects of the business.

TransCanada

Unlike Enbridge, TransCanada isn’t as technically horrifying, but for that, you’re getting 1.5% less yield.

Management is committed to a capital expenditure plan by which $23 billion will go toward short-term projects, with $24 billion being invested into longer-term initiatives. These projects will fuel a considerable amount of top-line growth over the next five years and will support further annual dividend increases in the 8-10% range over the foreseeable future.

The stock trades at a 2.2 P/B, a 3.6 P/S, and a 9.1 P/CF, all of which are lower than the company’s five-year historical average multiples of 2.4, 3.8, and 9.4, respectively.

With an intriguing growth pipeline, a discounted valuation, and a yield that’s over 1% more than it normally is, I think TransCanada is a smart buy on the dip for income-oriented contrarians.

Better bet?

You can’t go wrong with either stock at these levels, as both are undervalued and offer a solid dividend that will likely continue to grow by as much as 10% over the medium-term.

Enbridge’s deeper discount and higher yield may be more compelling to deep-value investors who can stomach short-term losses, but TransCanada appears better suited to an investor who’s looking for a quicker bounce back.

If I had to choose one, I’d go with TransCanada because there appear to be more promising nearer-term growth catalysts that can bring the stock out of its funk over the near-term. If possible, I’d recommend buying both today, however, especially if you intend to own shares for many years as you rake in the huge dividend payments.

Stay hungry. Stay Foolish.

Our expert just announced his #1 TSX energy play right now

Since 2013, The Motley Fool Canada's Iain Butler has more than doubled the return of the S&P/TSX index. It's a track record that should make you sit up and pay attention...

Especially when Iain announces a brand-new stock pick, like his #1 energy play right now. Hint: It's not another flash-in-the-pan E&P. It's actually a tech stock with deep ties to the energy industry - and Iain sees as much as 70% upside from today's price.

Now here's the really good news. You can snap up a copy of Iain's brand-new report for FREE. You'll get the name, ticker and the full investment case 100% gratis. In fact, the only catch is that you need to hurry! This report is hot off the presses today, but blink and you could miss it.

Click here to claim Iain's new report, absolutely FREE!

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of Enbridge. Enbridge is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

I consent to receiving information from The Motley Fool via email, direct mail, and occasional special offer phone calls. I understand I can unsubscribe from these updates at any time. Please read the Privacy Statement and Terms of Service for more information.