Is Alberta Inviting Criticism From Trump?

Alberta’s production cuts are squeezing the margins of U.S. refiners like Valero Energy Corp. (NYSE:VLO) and Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX).

| More on:
question marks written reminders tickets

Image source: Getty Images

In a surprise move toward the end of 2018, the Province of Alberta elected to impose mandatory production cuts on oil producers in response to sharply weaker Canadian oil price benchmarks. That decision came after significant industry lobbying primarily from Cenovus Energy Inc. (TSX:CVE)(NYSE:CVE) and Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. Both oil sands giants were suffering financially because the Canadian benchmark bitumen price Western Canadian Select (WCS) plunged to record lows in November 2018 despite the North American benchmark West Texas Intermediate trading at over US$70 a barrel.

Oil production curtailments spark unintended fallout

A key reason for Edmonton deciding to introduce the cuts was the threat of losing up to $4 billion in oil royalties if the deep-discount applied to Canadian crude continued. The cuts initially aimed to reduce provincial oil output by around 9%, or 325,000 barrels daily, but Alberta’s government recently dialed them down by 75,000 barrels daily in response to unintended fallout. The announcement had an almost immediate effect, causing WCS and Edmonton Par prices to more than double.

While this has been a positive development for Alberta and those bitumen producers that lack significant refining capacity like Cenovus, it has triggered substantial fallout for an industry already labouring under a range of issues. This included lifting WCS prices to the point where it is essentially uneconomic to ship bitumen by rail. That has seen Imperial Oil Ltd., one of the harsher critics of Edmonton’s decision, to wind down rail shipments to almost zero during February 2019.

Aside from upsetting the economics of crude by rail, it could trigger significant political fallout because it has crimped the massive profits being made by U.S. refiners by narrowing the wide price differential between WCS feedstock and WTI.

The deep discount applied to WCS, which reached a record US$47 per barrel in late October 2018, gave refiners’ margins a substantial lift, thereby boosting fourth- quarter 2018 earnings, as they were able to access premium prices benchmarked to WTI while paying less than a quarter of that for bitumen feedstock.

The largest U.S. refiner by capacity Valero Energy Corp. (NYSE:VLO), where heavy crude makes up less than a fifth of its feedstock, reported that fourth-quarter operating profit surged by 50% year over year to almost US$1.5 billion. This was supported by the refiner’s throughput margin expanding by a healthy 26% to US$11 per barrel and its operating income soaring by 50% to US$5.36 per barrel.

Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX), which is considerably more reliant upon WCS feedstock, saw its refining margin for the fourth quarter almost double to US$16.53 per barrel seeing it report refining income before tax of US$2 billion, almost four times greater than a year earlier.

Lower WTI coupled with substantially higher WCS with the price differential at less than US$11 per barrel will squeeze margins for U.S. refiners, particularly with the North American benchmark trading at US$55 a barrel. The additional costs of higher feedstock could be passed onto consumers at the pump. It is here that Edmonton’s policy could trigger its most undesirable and least anticipated side effect: the wrath of President Trump. He has already established a history of being a vocal advocate of lower oil prices, criticizing Saudi Arabia and OPEC if prices move too high on reduced supply.

The dependence of U.S. refiners upon Canadian heavy crude, especially now that other sources such as Venezuela and Mexico are declining, means that higher WCS prices will compress margins and likely lead to costlier gasoline. It is difficult to predict whether Trump would intervene because it is a double-edged sword. The near collapse of Venezuela’s oil industry and recent U.S. sanctions makes those refineries configured to process heavy crude even more reliant upon Canadian oil imports. Amid an operating environment in which many U.S. refineries are only capable of cost-effectively processing heavy oil, any moves that could potentially choke off supplies are risky. 

What does it mean for the oil sands?

By meddling with the market mechanism, Edmonton has not only drawn harsh criticism from within the oil sands industry, but potentially damaged the province’s reputation as a destination for investment, which could have a noticeable political impact and delay the markets ability to find equilibrium.

Once the cuts wind down toward the end of this year, there is every likelihood that the wide price differentials between Canadian crude and WTI witnessed last year will return until the noticeable lack of pipeline capacity is resolved. That makes investing in those oil sands operators like Cenovus, which lack the capacity to refine a significant portion of the bitumen they produce unattractive investments.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Matt Smith has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Energy Stocks

Arrowings ascending on a chalkboard
Energy Stocks

Beat the TSX With This Cash-Gushing Dividend Stock

Canadian Natural Resources stock is well set up to beat the TSX as it continues to generate strong cash flows…

Read more »

energy industry
Energy Stocks

2 TSX Energy Stocks to Buy Hand Over Fist Now

These two rallying TSX energy stocks can continue delivering robust returns to investors in the long term.

Read more »

green energy
Energy Stocks

1 Magnificent TSX Dividend Stock Down 37% to Buy and Hold Forever

This dividend stock has fallen significantly from poor results, but zoom in and there are some major improvements happening.

Read more »

oil tank at night
Energy Stocks

3 Energy Stocks Already Worth Your While

Here's why blue-chip TSX energy stocks such as Enbridge should be part of your equity portfolio in 2024.

Read more »

Solar panels and windmills
Energy Stocks

1 Beaten-Down Stock That Could Be the Best Bet in the TSX

This renewable energy stock could be one of the best buys you make this year, as the company starts to…

Read more »

Dice engraved with the words buy and sell
Energy Stocks

Is Enbridge Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold?

Here's why Enbridge (TSX:ENB) remains a top dividend stock long-term investors may want to consider, despite current risks.

Read more »

Gas pipelines
Energy Stocks

If You Had Invested $5,000 in Enbridge Stock in 2018, This Is How Much You Would Have Today

Enbridge's high dividend yield hasn't made up for its dismal total returns.

Read more »

Bad apple with good apples
Energy Stocks

Avoid at All Costs: This Stock Is Portfolio Poison

A mid-cap stock commits to return more to shareholders, but some investors remember the suspension of dividends a few years…

Read more »