Which Materials Stock Has More Upside: Methanex (TSX:MX) or Norbord (TSX:OSB)?

Methanex Corporation (TSX:MX)(NYSE:MEOH) and Norbord Inc. (TSX:OSB)(NYSE:OSB) are two great defensive stocks to get your through any rough patches on the market.

| More on:

If you’re looking for a stable investment, with dividends to boot, you don’t have to look any further than materials stocks. With a recession potentially on the horizon, these stocks are perfect to add to your portfolio to protect you from any economic downturn.

Methanex

Methanex (TSX:MX)(NYSE:MEOH) is the world’s largest supplier of methanol, serving North America, the Asia Pacific, Europe, and South America. The stock has been on a slow and steady increase, with a few jumps in the last few years. Most notably, it reached the $90 range last summer before the slump in the fall but has since rebounded to nearly $80 per share.

But the next 12 months could be a bit nerve-wracking for investors. Analysts are predicting shares to slump to as low as $40 per share. This comes from the negative five-year average past earnings-growth rate for this stock, and its level of debt increasing compared to its net worth.

But the company is well protected through its operating cash flow, making analysts believe over the next three years there will be a shift, pushing the ROE to 28.2%. In the meantime, this stock is still performing well, with $1.29 billion in earnings during the last quarter. And there’s also a solid dividend of 2.32% to keep you happy while you wait for the rebound.

Norbord

Norbord (TSX:OSB)(NYSE:OSB) is in a very different position than Methanex. Norbord produces oriented strand board, which is used for structural panels in building applications. It had its high days years back in 2004 when shares reached $152.70 compared to now when they trade at around $32 at the time of writing.

But since 2009, the stock has been on an upward trend, with a nice boost coming in 2015 when the company acquired Ainsworth, adding 2.5 billion square feet of capacity to its artillery. And after a number of years of slowed construction, this company is due for another boost. After a strong 2018, the company should continue to have lower EBITDA margins of $724 million than previous years, and building should boom beyond 2019, putting this company back to work.

There’s also a potential for further international expansion, as the company only has a toe in the European market accounting for only 20% of its earnings. This combined with peak demand for construction could bring this stock back to levels not seen in a decade.

That would be great news for shareholders, especially those who recently were hit by the dividend decrease. The stock now offers a 4.35% dividend at the time of writing, but should things change, that should jump right back up again.

The upside

Between these two stocks, if you’re a long-term investor, either will continue on an upward trend over the years. But for the immediate future, I would buy Methanex. This stock’s historical performance proves it can slowly and steadily increase, even among some fairly daunting situations such as the last great recession. There isn’t that worry that it will plummet to a third of its share price, as there is with Norbord.

Finally, the need for methanol will continue to increase over the next few years, setting this company up for a number of jumps. So, I would wait for the next dip and buy this stock on a low.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Investing

Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.
Stocks for Beginners

Canada’s Infrastructure Boom May Be Closer Than You Think – Here’s How to Position Now

Canada’s infrastructure boom may reward the behind-the-scenes TSX suppliers, not just the headline megaproject names.

Read more »

woman looks at iPhone
Dividend Stocks

All It Takes is $3,000 in Telus to Generate Hundreds in Passive Income

Investors looking to generate nearly $300 in passive income only need to start with a $3,000 investment right now.

Read more »

child looks at variety of flavors at ice cream store
Stocks for Beginners

The Key Things to Understand Before Holding U.S. Stocks in a TFSA

Canadians love U.S. stocks in their TFSAs, but dividends, currency, and account choice can quietly change the math.

Read more »

monthly calendar with clock
Dividend Stocks

Looking for Monthly Income? This 5.8% Dividend Stock Is Worth a Look

This Canadian monthly dividend stock offers a consistent payout backed by stable oil production and long-life assets.

Read more »

Runner on the start line
Stocks for Beginners

2 Growth Stocks That Could Be Positioned for a Strong Run in 2026

Despite their recent rally, these two TSX growth stocks could still have plenty of upside left in 2026.

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Dividend Stocks

This TSX Dividend Stock Has Fallen 20% – and I’d Still Consider It Worth Owning

This TSX dividend stock has dropped 20%, but its stable income and disciplined strategy still look impressive.

Read more »

Young Boy with Jet Pack Dreams of Flying
Investing

The Canadian Stocks I’d Focus on for Growth Potential in 2026

These five Canadian stocks offer different forms of growth potential in 2026, making them some of the best Canadian stock…

Read more »

Metals
Stocks for Beginners

Why These 2 Canadian Stocks Look Like Bargains Right Now

These two TSX stocks look cheap, but still have the cash flow and balance sheets to keep rewarding shareholders.

Read more »