TSX Investors Keep Making This Costly Mistake

Find out why you should ditch mega-cap stocks like Royal Bank of Canada (TSX:RY)(NYSE:RY) and choose tiny, high-growth stocks like Boyd Group Income Fund (TSX:BYD.UN) and goeasy Ltd. (TSX:GSY).

| More on:

TSX investors keep making a big mistake. This mistake has caused them to underperform global markets while preventing them from accessing the fastest-growing sectors of the economy. In total, billions of dollars have been left on the table. Many investors have self-corrected, but the vast majority have not. Odds are that you are making this mistake.

If you want to make sure your portfolio can grow as quickly as possible, pay close attention.

You’re automatically big

Take a look at your investments. You’ll probably find a major theme: you’re heavily invested in gigantic companies. Whether you’re invested in mutual funds or individual stocks, your portfolio is likely heavily biased towards larger firms. And for good reason. Consider the S&P/TSX Composite Index. It represents roughly 70% of the value on the Toronto Stock Exchange yet only 250 companies are included. The vast majority of the index is comprised of multi-billion-dollar companies.

But what happened to the remaining 30% of value on the TSX? Why aren’t those companies included in the index? The biggest reason is size. There’s a reason why major market indexes like the S&P 500 Index only include big firms: liquidity. If a company is only worth $100 million, it’s possible that less than $1 million worth of shares trade on a daily basis. If a fund has $1 billion in assets under management (a relatively small sum), it would be very difficult to buy and sell stock in that company without dramatically influencing the price.

While you can make a market index that follows anything, we compare performance with the big indexes because that’s what most funds are competing against. That means smaller companies often fall off the face of the earth. They’re not included in market indexes, major mutual funds, or analyst research reports. Small-cap stocks are the market’s orphans, but they shouldn’t be. Over time, small-cap stocks consistently outperform large-cap stocks. But if you’re like most investors, you’re hardly invested in these undervalued, high-growth firms.

How to go small

You’ve likely heard of Royal Bank and Suncor Energy, but what about Boyd Group Income Fund (TSX:BYD.UN) or goeasy (TSX:GSY)?

Countless mutual funds owns shares in RBC and Suncor. Both companies have scores of analysts that follow their every move. Is that because these stocks represent attractive investments? No. The attention these companies get is simply due to their size. Suncor is worth $63 billion, while RBC is valued at a whopping $149 billion.

What about Boyd Group and goeasy? Boyd Group is worth less than $4 billion, while goeasy hasn’t even surpassed a $1 billion market cap. In terms of size, these stocks are puny. Yet it’s their small size that allows them to grow significantly faster than their larger peers. After all, it’s easier to double in size as a $1 billion company than as a $100 billion company.

Over the last decade, shares of Goeasy are up more than 400%. Boyd Group stock, meanwhile, is up nearly 4,000%! It’s rare to find these returns with large-cap stocks. If you’re invested in large index funds or mutual funds, you’re probably missing out. As with large-cap stocks, small-cap stocks are never a sure thing. But over the long term, exposure to small companies has proven a winning formula. Don’t miss out.

Fool contributor Ryan Vanzo has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Energy Stocks

A worker gives a business presentation.
Energy Stocks

Rates Are Stuck: 1 Canadian Dividend Stock I’d Buy Today

Side hustles are booming, but a steady dividend stock like Emera could be the quieter “second income” that doesn’t need…

Read more »

Natural gas
Energy Stocks

A Canadian Energy Stock Ready to Bring the Heat in 2026

Peyto Exploration and Development is a natural gas producer delivering shareholder value in an increasingly bullish energy environment

Read more »

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Energy Stocks

Where Will Canadian Natural Resources Be in 5 Years?

Energy stocks can humble investors fast, but CNQ’s long-life oil sands cash flow makes it one of the steadier ways…

Read more »

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Energy Stocks

Energy Sector Strength: A Canadian Producer That Can Thrive in Any Market

Whitecap is built to survive oil-price swings by keeping costs low and focusing on durable free cash flow.

Read more »

Board Game, Chess, Chess Board, Chess Piece, Hand
Energy Stocks

Is Algonquin Power Stock a Trap?

Algonquin can look cheap and high-yield, but the real test is whether cash flow and balance-sheet repairs are truly sustainable.

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Energy Stocks

This Canadian Energy Stock Offers Serious Value (and Yield) This January

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) stock looks way too cheap for energy-focused value investors.

Read more »

stock chart
Energy Stocks

A Canadian Stock Poised for a Massive Comeback in 2026

After several years of downturns and attempts at a slow recovery, Suncor Energy (TSX:SU) is finally near its all-time highs…

Read more »

golden sunset in crude oil refinery with pipeline system
Energy Stocks

Outlook for Imperial Oil Stock in 2026

Imperial Oil stock has returned more than 300% to shareholders in the past decade. Here's why it can gain 35%…

Read more »