Canada Revenue Agency: 1 Reason Why the CRA Could Take Your TFSA to Court

Frequent trading in your TFSA is prohibited. If you have high dividend payers Peyto stock and Whitecap stock, you don’t need to break the TFSA rule and risk facing the CRA in court.

| More on:
You Should Know This

Image source: Getty Images

The TFSA is an outstanding vehicle to grow your savings or build a retirement fund. All earnings from the account are tax-free, which is advantageous as you get older and closer to the sunset years.

However, the last thing you would want is to face the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) in a legal tussle. The agency can take your TFSA to court with one grievous error. Conducting a business of trading stocks is a no-no. The CRA can slap you with a significant TFSA tax penalty.

Trading stocks

For purposes of illustration, let us use Peyto (TSX:PEY) and Whitecap (TSX:WCP) as examples. Both energy stocks are dividend titans. The former pays an 8.3% dividend, while the latter yields 8.16%. The common denominator is the affordable price, which is $2.78 and $4.10, respectively.

Peyto is a $458.35 million energy firm that is in the business of exploring, developing, and producing oil and natural gas and natural gas liquids in Deep Basin, Alberta.

The stock is underperforming, and so far this year, it is down 58.67%. If you’re a spendthrift investor, you will find the price dirt cheap. You’ll purchase the stock in exchange for the high dividend payout.

Currently, the company is struggling, although it’s a well-managed and a low-cost producer. The stock hasn’t bounced back, because NGL prices remain depressed. Analysts are finding it difficult to make forecasts given the unpredictable crude oil prices.

Anyhow, once the situation improves, this energy stocks could be an excellent long-term investment prospect. In the meantime, Peyto is playing it safe by significantly reducing production. It can produce tonnes of gas but wouldn’t sell them at sea-bed prices. Next year might be a different but better story for the stock.

Whitecap is similarly situated. This $1.68 billion oil and gas company has been around for many years now. TFSA investors have made a killing from the high dividend of this energy stock. However, the price remains stagnant for most of the year.

As of the nine months ended September 30, 2019, the company is showing $712 negative retained earnings, which is an 8.37% plunge versus the same period in 2018. Anyhow, Whitecap is riding the storm, as the revenue drop is outpacing the expense.

During the same period, the company was able to accumulate $3.5 million in cash after consolidating its working capital assets in British Columbia, northwest Alberta, southwest Saskatchewan, and west central Saskatchewan. Consolidation is a means to raise operating efficiency.

CRA court cases

The erratic price movements of Peyto and Whitecap are tempting for speculative investors. There is a tendency to buy and sell the stocks for higher gains but shorter holding periods.

Generally, the TFSA is a passive trading account. The CRA can catch you using your account for business activities through the frequency of transactions or trading. Alarm bells will ring when there is an unusually high turnover rate.

As a TFSA investor, you have to play it by the book and not abuse its use. The court will rule your supposedly tax-free gains from frequent trading as business income. Therefore, all your earnings become taxable.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

thinking
Dividend Stocks

Should You Buy BCE Stock for its 8.6% Dividend Yield?

Down over 20% from all-time highs, BCE stock offers you a tasty dividend yield in 2024. But is the TSX…

Read more »

grow dividends
Dividend Stocks

How Long Would It Take to Turn $20,000 Into $100,000 With TSX Dividend Stocks?

Here's how high-quality TSX dividend stocks and the power of compound interest can help grow your investments by 400% or…

Read more »

Paper airplanes flying on blue sky with form of growing graph
Dividend Stocks

2 Soaring Stocks I’d Buy Now With No Hesitation

These two stocks may be the most expensive on the market, but they're high for a reason! And I'm still…

Read more »

Hour glass and calendar concept for time slipping away for important appointment date, schedule and deadline
Dividend Stocks

Invest $374.50 Each Month to Create Passive Income of $288 in 2024

Investing a specific amount each month to create passive income this year is possible with monthly dividend payers.

Read more »

Happy retirement
Dividend Stocks

2 Stocks to Help Turn $100,000 Into $1 Million

If you want to reach $1 million, $100,000 can certainly get you there. Even if you invest in some low…

Read more »

warning or alert
Dividend Stocks

Income Alert: These Stocks Just Raised Their Dividends

There's no shortage of companies that raised their dividends recently. Here's a trio of options to consider buying now.

Read more »

Business success with growing, rising charts and businessman in background
Dividend Stocks

Don’t Look Now, But These 3 TSX Stocks Look Poised for a Nice Rally 

Three TSX stocks are in a downtrend amid headwinds. 2024 may be rocky for them, but they are poised for…

Read more »

protect, safe, trust
Dividend Stocks

3 Safe Dividend Stocks to Beat Inflation

These three dividend stocks are excellent buys to beat inflation, given their solid underlying businesses and high yields.

Read more »