Dividend Stocks: Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) vs. Suncor Energy (TSX:SU)

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ)(NYSE:CNQ) looks like a dividend stock bargain, but is it superior to Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX:SU)(NYSE:SU)?

| More on:
Growth from coins

Image source: Getty Images

The market crash has provided countless buying opportunities. This is the best time in years to be putting money to work, especially if you’re buying dividend stocks.

Two large-cap Canadian stocks have seen their valuations crushed in recent months. Value investors are flocking to two energy producers: Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX:SU)(NYSE:SU) and Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ)(NYSE:CNQ).

Suncor stock now sports an incredible 8.3% dividend yield. Canadian Natural has an even higher yield at 8.6%.

Which income stock is a better buy at current prices?

Dividend stocks on steroids

For years, Canadian Natural and Suncor were solid dividend stocks. While they almost always yielded at least 3%, when the stocks dipped, the payouts could move as high as 5%. The current 8% dividend yields are a rare event, marking the highest payouts in history for both stocks.

Unfortunately, the juicy dividends aren’t a result of strength. In recent weeks, Suncor and Canadian Natural shares have fallen by more than 50%. The culprit is falling oil prices.

At the start of the year, oil prices were above US$60 per barrel. Today, they’re closer to US$20 per barrel. As oil producers, Suncor and Canadian Natural are on the front lines of the pain. Their fossil fuel production is now worth significantly less. In fact, it’s likely that both businesses are racking up major losses on a daily basis.

Suncor and Canadian Natural have breakeven levels well above US$30 per barrel, which means oil prices need to rebound by more than 50% simply so these companies can stop burning cash.

It’s not hard to see why CNQ and SU shares have fallen so much in recent weeks. These slow and steady dividend stocks have become major money-losers. But with the dividend yields now above 8%, is now the time to buy?

Time to buy?

It’s important to know that neither Canadian Natural nor Suncor have ever paid out a dividend that yields more than 8%. Those prospective yields are based on previous dividend amounts. For the yields to stand, both companies must reaffirm their historical dividend rates.

I suspect at least one of these stocks will cut its dividend for the upcoming quarter, and the other stock won’t be far behind. Perhaps these companies can limp along for a quarter or two, pretending that their dividends are stable, but with losses piling up, the payouts will eventually reach the chopping block. That’s bad news for dividend investors.

Many value investors will point to other assets that these companies own, including refinery facilities and pipelines. Owning midstream assets is a fantastic way to offset volatility, as margins often run counter-cyclical to oil prices. When commodity prices fall, for example, refinery margins usually rise.

While Canadian Natural and Suncor have diversified business lines to shoulder some of the pain, there’s no arguing that both firms need significantly higher oil prices to remain economically viable.

Who knows what the long-term future is? Perhaps oil prices rebound by the summer, making SU and CNQ stock a clear buy. The dividends, however, likely won’t last until then.

When companies burn cash, they look to fortify the balance sheet any way possible. Suspending stock buybacks is an easy way to do that. Dividend cuts are another no-brainer.

There are some terrific buying opportunities for dividend investors following the market crash, but these stocks don’t fit the bill.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Ryan Vanzo has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Energy Stocks

protect, safe, trust
Energy Stocks

Millennials: 2 Green Energy Dividend Stocks to Buy Now

Millennials, you're in an enviable position to make a killing through clean energy companies, but also from collecting passive income…

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Energy Stocks

Buy These 2 Energy Stocks Together for Bigger Monthly Dividends in 2023

Two energy stocks, a large-cap and small-cap, make the perfect combination for investors looking for monthly passive income in 2023.

Read more »

Man data analyze
Energy Stocks

Should You Still Invest in Canadian Energy Stocks This Year?

Canadian energy stocks are closer to their 52-week highs even when oil prices dipped below US$80. Should you invest in…

Read more »

oil tank at night
Energy Stocks

The Oil Boom Isn’t Over: These 2 Energy Stocks Could Rebound Sharply in 2023

Energy stocks like MEG Energy (TSX:MEG) could rebound surge higher in 2023.

Read more »

oil and natural gas
Energy Stocks

Better Buy: Suncor Energy Stock or Canadian Natural Resources

Suncor and Canadian Natural Resources are generating strong profits. Is one undervalued?

Read more »

oil and gas pipeline
Energy Stocks

Better Deal: Enbridge Stock or Pembina Pipeline?

Enbridge and Pembina Pipeline are two top Canadian energy infrastructure stocks. Which is a better deal for income and growth…

Read more »

Engineers walk through a facility.
Energy Stocks

3 Undervalued TSX Stocks Worth a Buy Right Now

Many TSX stocks are undervalued as earnings and cash flows soar along with oil and gas prices. Here are a…

Read more »

energy industry
Energy Stocks

Suncor Energy Stock: Should You Buy the Dip?

Suncor Energy Inc (TSX:SU) stock has taken a significant dip. Is it buyable?

Read more »