CP Stock or CNR Stock: Which Railway Looks Better Before Earnings?

CNR (TSX:CNR)(NYSE:CNI) stock and CP (TSX:CP)(NYSE:CP) stock both have earnings due, so what should investors know before diving in?

The Canadian railway duopoly continues to truck along in a heated battle for the top position. Whereas one remains in a financially lucrative position, the other has a lot to offer long-term investors. So, ahead of earnings, which should investors focus their attention: Canadian National Railway (TSX: CNR)(NYSE: CNI) or Canadian Pacific Railway (TSX: CP)(NYSE: CP)?

CNR stock

CNR stock was part of a hugely dramatic exchange last year. The railway looked like it would come out on top in the bid for Kansas City Southern but instead lost the bid. This came after the Surface Transportation Board in the United States chose CP stock over the company and was followed by major investors wanting an executive shake up.

But now, things have cooled down somewhat, and CNR stock looks like it’s in a solid position. This could lead the way for investment in other areas. Furthermore, the company sailed past earnings estimates last quarter and could do so again.

However, analysts do want investors to note that CNR stock may see railroad traffic down due to winter weather. Volumes suggest a somewhat weak demand environment, with weak grain volumes and operational challenges. Never mind supply-chain issues. This could see earnings per share come down, with lower profitability in the first quarter.

Shares of CNR stock are up 4.73% year to date and 17% in the last year.

CP stock

CP stock is in a similar position, but with one big difference. The company has billions in debt to manage over the coming years after becoming the winner of the bid for KCS. In the short term, this could hurt investors. The company already made a major cut to its dividend to help pay down this increase in debt. And that won’t be helped by the weak demand environment discussed above.

That being said, CP stock was in a strong position going into the move and remains so. The company took years to do away with inefficiencies and narrow its focus. Now, it will become the only railway to run through every country in North America.

So, despite some short-term issues, analysts are quite positive about the future benefits and growth of CP stock. And investors could start feeling the growth as early as next year should the deal be fully realized.

Shares are up about 9% both year to date and in the last year.

Bottom line

Both CNR stock and CP stock are in strong positions heading into the next quarter. However, they may indeed suffer from operational issues, supply-chain demands, and weaker grain production. Spring may shoot transportation back up going into summer, especially if the war in Ukraine continues to impact demand for items like oil and potash.

However, when it comes down to one or the other, analysts seem more convinced about the long-term growth of CP stock. It trades closer to value territory as well compared to CNR stock and offers the potential for enormous revenue growth from its merger.

But that’s not to say you should count out CNR stock just yet. This company continues to make waves and find lucrative revenue streams and is merely part of the duopoly that likely won’t move aside, even with the KCS merger.

In the short term, CNR stock may be a strong option, especially with a dividend of 1.82%. In the long term, however, CP stock may be your best bet for higher returns.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe owns Canadian Pacific Railway Limited. The Motley Fool recommends Canadian National Railway.

More on Stocks for Beginners

Happy golf player walks the course
Stocks for Beginners

The TFSA Investment Strategy I’d Use to Build a Retirement Paycheque

This TFSA investment strategy combines global growth, bonds, and dividend income to help build a reliable retirement paycheque.

Read more »

A Canada Pension Plan Statement of Contributions with a 100 dollar banknote and dollar coins.
Dividend Stocks

OAS Clawback Worries? I’d Check Where My Dividend Stocks Are Held

The account holding a dividend stock can change its effect on OAS, even when the cash payment is identical.

Read more »

A person's hand cupped open with a hologram of an AI chatbot above saying Hi, can I help you
Tech Stocks

CGI vs. OpenText: Which Canadian Tech Stock Offers the Better Long-Term Case?

CGI gets my long-term preference, while OpenText offers a recovery case that still needs stronger sales.

Read more »

coins jump into piggy bank
Energy Stocks

Fortis vs. Emera: Which Utility Gives Dividend Investors the Better Deal?

Fortis gets my long-term dividend-growth preference, while Emera offers more current income from the same budget.

Read more »

man in bowtie poses with abacus
Dividend Stocks

To Collect $150 a Month From Granite REIT, Here’s the Investment You’d Need

Granite’s current monthly distribution requires 508 units, or about $43,119, to reach a $150 monthly income target.

Read more »

man shops in a drugstore
Dividend Stocks

How Much to Invest in RioCan for $300 a Month in Dividends

How much should you invest in RioCan for $300 a month in dividends? Explore its retail business, monthly payout and…

Read more »

Quality Control Inspectors at Waste Management Facility
Stocks for Beginners

Would I Buy Waste Connections for a 10-Year TFSA? Here’s My Case

Waste Connections earns my interest for a 10-year TFSA, with recurring demand and cash generation balanced against a demanding valuation.

Read more »

Hourglass and stock price chart
Energy Stocks

Enbridge Q3: Profit Nearly Doubles, and I Don’t Think the Dividend Stock is Done Yet

Enbridge starts investors off with a near 5.9% dividend that can continue to grow with a steady growth profile.

Read more »