Why Magna Stock Fell 8% Last Week

Magna stock (TSX:MG) dropped 8% last week as the company reported earnings that fell below full-year estimates for the stock.

Shares of Magna International (TSX: MG) fell 8% last week as the car manufacturer reported its most recent earnings report. Yet despite increasing its dividend, the company still saw a drop in share price.

So, what happened? Let’s take a look and see if this gives investors in Magna stock an opportunity to buy, or beware.

What happened

First, the good news. The auto parts maker reported that the company would pay a quarterly dividend of US$0.475 per share, an increase from US$0.46 per share before earnings. This brings the total dividend up to US$1.90 per share on an annual basis.

The news also came as Magna reported that net income surged from US$95 million last year to US$271 million as of the most recent quarter. Furthermore, sales totalled US$10.5 billion, an increase from US$9.6 billion last year.

Yet during the third quarter, Magna stock gave guidance as to what investors could expect during the quarter. However, there was a negative impact after strikes brought down the company’s earnings. This coupled with the unfavourable impact of “commercial items,” higher launch costs, and acquisitions all caused the company to take a hit on earnings.

In fact, the company walked away with US$1.2 billion in net income, falling pretty far short of its estimates between US$1.55 and US$1.65 billion.

Investors not confident

Investors therefore might believe that the company continues to struggle when it comes to following through on its own guidance. And this became an important sticking point when looking at earnings last week.

Magna management reported that it now has guidance for 2024 and 2026. Its sales should increase, as well as net income. However, it’s unclear how much investors can really trust the company if they have missed earnings estimates in the past?

So despite having a high dividend yield, investors may also wonder: can the company afford to keep it up? After all, with costs climbing and the company touting higher costs as an issue, it’s unclear why the company would choose now to increase that dividend by a fair amount.

Bottom line

Magna apparently still has work to do when it comes to getting its costs under control. While the company continues to see sales increase around the world, it blamed a laundry list of issues for the higher costs.

What’s more, these issues don’t look like they’re suddenly going to disappear. Higher costs are here to stay; acquisition and divestiture costs are also an issue. What’s more, it remains unclear about how the company will lower these costs in the future, despite seeing cost-cutting measures already in place over the last year or so.

So sure, Magna stock offers a dividend yield now at 3.16%. It also trades at 15 times earnings, which certainly suggests it offers some value. However, there seems to also be issues with follow through. And frankly, that’s not something you want from a company you plan to invest in over the long term.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Magna International. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Real estate investment concept
Dividend Stocks

Timbercreek Financial’s Double-Digit Yield: Is the Monthly Dividend Safe?

Timbercreek Financial's 16% dividend yield may be at risk. Understand the implications for dividend investors in this article.

Read more »

young people dance to exercise
Dividend Stocks

1 Magnificent Dividend Stock Down 33% to Buy and Hold for Decades

Groupe Dynamite stock is down over 33% from its high. See why a growth story with 69% gross margins and…

Read more »

some investments are riskier than others
Dividend Stocks

5 Top Canadian Stocks to Buy and Hold With $1,000

Get tips on buying and holding stocks with strategic insights to maximize your investment returns and manage risks.

Read more »

a person prepares to fight by taping their knuckles
Dividend Stocks

2 Defensive Canadian Stocks to Own Into Year-End

With solid fundamentals, predictable cash flows, consistent dividend payouts, and clear growth prospects, these two defensive stocks are excellent buys…

Read more »

hiker with backpack in the mountains
Dividend Stocks

2 TSX Dividend Stocks for TFSA Passive Income

The payouts of these Canadian dividend stocks are supported by strong fundamentals, stable earnings, and consistent free cash flow.

Read more »

Real estate investment concept with person pointing on growth graph and coin stacking to get profit from property
Dividend Stocks

Down 17% but Still a Perfect Buy for Long-Term Passive Income

CAPREIT stock has fallen 17% in a year, but its attractive monthly distributions and focus on improving profitability could make…

Read more »

fast shopping cart in grocery store
Dividend Stocks

What Would It Take for North West Company Stock to Pay You $1,800 a Year?

North West’s dividend can turn a portfolio into a grocery budget, though the price of getting there deserves its own…

Read more »

ETFs can contain investments such as stocks
Dividend Stocks

Dividend ETFs Are Great for Retirement Income: Are They Enough?

Here's why retirement investors will likely need to sell some shares to augment their dividend payouts.

Read more »