Better Materials Stock: Nutrien vs Mattr?

Nutrien stock still looks like a strong, long-term buy, but so does Mattr. So, which comes out on top?

| More on:
A worker wears a hard hat outside a mining operation.

Source: Getty Images

Investing in the materials sector offers a diverse range of opportunities, especially when considering companies listed on the TSX. Nutrien (TSX:NTR), a giant in agricultural inputs, often comes to mind. However, another notable player in the materials sector is Mattr (TSX:MATR), formerly known as Shawcor. Comparing these two materials stocks provides insight into different facets of the materials industry and can guide investors in making informed decisions. So, let’s get into it.

Into earnings

Nutrien stands as a significant force in the agricultural sector. It produces and distributes potash, nitrogen, and phosphate products, which are essential for fertilizers. These nutrients play a crucial role in global food production, supporting crop yields and quality.

In its fourth-quarter report for 2024, Nutrien reported net earnings of $118 million, equating to $0.23 per share. This figure shows a decline from the previous year’s $176 million, or $0.35 per share. The materials stock’s revenue also experienced a downturn, reflecting challenges in the market. Despite these hurdles, Nutrien achieved record potash sales volumes, indicating strong demand for this key product.

Mattr operates in the materials technology space, serving critical infrastructure markets globally. The materials stock specializes in providing services to the pipeline sector of the oil and gas industry. It is recognized as one of the largest pipe-coating providers worldwide. In 2017, Mattr reported revenues of $1.56 billion, showcasing its substantial presence in the industry. The materials stock underwent a rebranding in 2023, transitioning from Shawcor to Mattr to better reflect its focus on materials technology.

Considerations

When evaluating these two materials stocks, it’s essential to consider market capitalization. Nutrien boasts a significant market cap of $36.81 billion at writing, reflecting its extensive operations and influence in the agricultural sector. Mattr, while smaller, maintains a market capitalization of $677 million at writing, positioning it as a noteworthy contender in the materials sector.

Both materials stocks have faced their share of challenges. Nutrien’s recent earnings report indicates a decrease in net earnings and revenue, suggesting market headwinds. However, the company’s record potash sales volumes highlight a resilient demand for its products. Mattr, having undergone a rebranding, signifies a strategic shift to align more closely with its core competencies in materials technology. This move may open new avenues for growth and innovation.

Investors looking into the materials sector should consider these materials stocks’ distinct positions. Nutrien offers exposure to agricultural inputs, a sector tied closely to global food production and population growth. Mattr provides services essential to the oil and gas industry’s infrastructure — a critical component of global energy supply.

Bottom line

In conclusion, both Nutrien and Mattr present unique opportunities within the materials sector. Nutrien’s role in agricultural inputs and its recent performance metrics offer insight into its market position. Mattr’s specialization in pipeline services and its strategic rebranding reflects its commitment to adapting and thriving in its niche. Investors should assess these companies based on their individual investment goals and risk tolerance, considering the broader economic factors influencing the materials sector.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Nutrien. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

Nuclear power station cooling tower
Metals and Mining Stocks

How to Invest in Uranium as a Canadian in 2026

This ETF provides exposure to spot uranium prices and uranium miners.

Read more »

ETF is short for exchange traded fund, a popular investment choice for Canadians
Metals and Mining Stocks

Why Silver ETFs Can Be Better Investments than Silver Bars

Read this before you buy a silver bar at your local precious metal dealer.

Read more »

A worker wears a hard hat outside a mining operation.
Stocks for Beginners

Mining Momentum: 2 TSX Stocks That Could Surprise Investors This January

Mining stocks could kick off 2026 with another surprise run as rate-cut hopes meet tight commodity supply.

Read more »

iceberg hides hidden danger below surface
Stocks for Beginners

Why January Loves Risk: 2 Small-Cap TSX Stocks to Watch in Early 2026

FRU and LIF can make a TFSA feel like “cash season” in early 2026, but their dividends are cycle-driven, and…

Read more »

todder holds a gold bar
Metals and Mining Stocks

With Copper and Gold Surging, the Canadian Mining Stocks You Need to Know About

As the commodity rally in metals continues, some Canadian mining stocks are emerging as winners over others. Here are two…

Read more »

monthly calendar with clock
Dividend Stocks

Buy 2,000 Shares of This Top Dividend Stock for $121.67/Month in Passive Income

Want your TFSA to feel like it’s paying you a monthly “paycheque”? This TSX dividend stock might deliver.

Read more »

Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.
Metals and Mining Stocks

Energy and Mining Stocks Are Outshining Tech in 2025

Energy and mining stocks have outperformed tech this year. Here’s why and where to invest for 2026.

Read more »

Stacked gold bars
Metals and Mining Stocks

It’s Not Too Late to Join the Rush in Canadian Gold Stocks. Really

Opportunity is knocking for prospective investors in Canadian gold stocks. Here’s why you need to invest now.

Read more »