4.66% Yield? Here’s a Dividend Trap to Avoid in March

I’m surprised this bank is still around, much less paying a 4.66% dividend yield.

Key Points
  • Laurentian Bank’s 4.66% dividend yield looks attractive, but investors should look beyond that number.
  • Weak fundamentals, including a price-to-book ratio of 0.67 and return on equity of just 2.84%, point to deeper structural issues.
  • Investors seeking Canadian bank dividends may be better off using a ETF rather than betting on a smaller struggling bank.

Canada’s banking sector is a very popular hunting ground for dividend investors. The Big Six banks have long histories of paying and growing dividends, strong balance sheets, and dominant positions in a protected oligopoly. But that does not mean every Canadian bank is a great investment.

Once you move outside the Big Six and start looking at smaller names, the picture changes quickly. In theory, these should be scrappy challengers trying to disrupt the incumbents. In reality, Canada’s tightly controlled banking market often leaves it stuck in permanent second place.

A good example is Laurentian Bank (TSX: LB). If you screened Canadian banks by dividend yield, this one might catch your eye. Based on its most recent quarterly payout, the stock currently offers a forward dividend yield of about 4.66%.

But that headline number hides some serious financial problems, and once you dig into the fundamentals, the story only gets worse. Here’s why I would avoid Laurentian Bank as a dividend trap.

Yellow caution tape attached to traffic cone

Source: Getty Images

Why Laurentian Bank has poor fundamentals

Banks are not evaluated quite the same way as most companies. A normal business sells products or services. Banks make money primarily by taking deposits, lending that money out at higher interest rates, and capturing the spread between those two rates. They also earn income from fees, trading, and other financial services.

Because of this structure, traditional valuation metrics do not always tell the full story. Two metrics I pay close attention to when evaluating banks are price-to-book value and return on equity.

Book value matters for banks because their assets are largely financial instruments such as loans and securities. In other sectors, book value is less meaningful, but for banks, it still provides insight into how the market values their balance sheet.

Healthy banks typically trade somewhere between one and two times book value. Below one times book can sometimes signal a bargain, but it can also signal deep problems.

Laurentian Bank currently trades at about 0.67 times book value. At first glance, that may look cheap. You are buying the bank for less than the value of its assets.

But banks do not trade below book value without a reason. Investors are effectively saying the assets on that balance sheet are not generating attractive returns.

That brings us to the next metric. Return on assets for banks is usually very low. That is not unusual because banks operate with enormous balance sheets and heavy leverage.

Return on equity is the real test of efficiency. A strong bank should produce a return on equity above 10%. Many of the large Canadian banks operate comfortably in the low to mid-teens.

Laurentian Bank’s return on equity is just 2.84%. That is extremely weak for a financial institution and helps explain why the stock trades at such a steep discount to book value.

The future for Laurentian Bank

I am bearish on Laurentian Bank. The company has spent years exploring strategic alternatives, including attempts to find a buyer. Those efforts have repeatedly fallen apart after potential acquirers took a closer look at the business.

That does not inspire confidence. Yes, the stock has rallied recently. Over the past 12 months, Laurentian shares have climbed about 52.6%. But a short-term rally does not fix long-term structural problems.

The balance sheet also raises concerns. As of the most recent quarter, the bank held about $9.2 billion in cash against roughly $17.77 billion in debt. Over the trailing 12 months, operating cash flow was negative $847.5 million.

For me, this is not a stock worth owning just for the dividend. If you want exposure to Canadian bank dividends, a better approach may be to use an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that holds all six major banks.

Some ETFs even enhance the yield by writing covered calls or applying modest leverage of around 1.25 times. That way, you still benefit from the sector’s income potential without betting on one struggling player.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Strategy: How to Earn $500 a Month in Tax-Free Dividend Income

Canadians can earn $500 in tax-free dividend income or another desired amount every month using a simple TFSA strategy.

Read more »

doctor uses telehealth
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Investors: This Monthly Dividend Stock Yields 7.6%

This REIT offers investors a monthly yield investors and a regular and frequent passive income stream to supplement their regular…

Read more »

shopper chooses vegetables at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

Loblaw vs. Empire: Which Grocery Stock Would I Choose for Long-Term Growth?

Both grocers benefit from repeat shoppers. I’d give Loblaw the edge for the ways it can earn more from those…

Read more »

ETF is short for exchange traded fund, a popular investment choice for Canadians
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX ETFs to Buy and Hold in a TFSA Forever

Looking for top TSX ETFs for your TFSA? Explore how VFV and VDY combine U.S. stock exposure and Canadian dividends…

Read more »

Retirees sip their morning coffee outside.
Dividend Stocks

2 Canadian Stocks to Buy and Hold for 20 More Years

CP Rail (TSX:CP) and another outstanding Canadian stock that's more than worth holding for many decades.

Read more »

woman relaxes with phone
Dividend Stocks

Is TELUS Stock a Buy for Its 6% Dividend Yield?

TELUS's attractive 6% dividend yield and ongoing business transformation could offer patient investors an opportunity to benefit from income and…

Read more »

middle-aged couple work together on laptop
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Income Outside a TFSA? The OAS Math I’d Check Before Buying More

A $1,000 dividend can add $1,380 to the income used to calculate your Old Age Security recovery tax.

Read more »

Colored pins on calendar showing a month
Dividend Stocks

Monthly Dividend Stocks: 3 TSX Picks That Pay Every 30 Days

These monthly dividend stocks stand out for their strong distribution history and ability to sustain payouts in the years ahead.

Read more »