Canadian Natural Resources vs. Enbridge: Which Dividend Stocks Looks Better Today?

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) and another dividend star that’s worth consideration here.

Key Points
  • Canadian energy still looks undervalued as a hedge if oil spikes and inflation re-accelerates, especially with ongoing Strait of Hormuz risks supporting higher crude prices.
  • CNQ offers more direct upside to higher oil with a ~3.77% yield and ~11.8x P/E, while Enbridge is the steadier “toll-booth” play with a ~5.0% yield and more predictable cash flows.

The Canadian energy patch continues to look like one of the more undervalued places in the Canadian stock market these days, even following the big gains posted earlier in the year. Indeed, the Iran war and blockage in the Strait of Hormuz could remain a problem for a while longer. And as discussions go nowhere, perhaps anticipating higher oil prices could be the way to go.

With higher energy prices, though, come higher costs for transport and just about everything further down the stream. As inflation flourishes again, I think a natural hedge is to consider the Canadian energy plays, given the generous dividends they pay out, which could help consumers stay afloat if inflation collides with weaker employment numbers.

oil pump jack under night sky

Source: Getty Images

Canadian Natural Resources

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX: CNQ) shares might be one of the best mega-cap Canadian energy plays to pick up if you’re worried about a return of US$100 oil, the possibility of US$150, or maybe even a shocking surprise of US$170 oil or higher.

The longer that the Strait of Hormuz stays blocked, the more disruptive the impact as energy stores get exhausted. I have no idea when the blockage will pave the way for higher prices again. But if peace talks go nowhere, a return of +US$100 oil seems like the path of least resistance.

In any case, CNQ stock is dirt-cheap at 11.8 times trailing price-to-earnings (P/E) after fluctuating since peaking in the spring. With a nice 3.77% dividend yield that’s well-covered and poised for growth, perhaps CNQ is the obvious mega-cap bargain to consider, especially if you think oil will move higher rather than lower from here.

Enbridge

Enbridge (TSX: ENB) is a stellar midstream energy play that won’t be as choppy as oil makes its next move. As a standout pipeline play that will be busy transporting essential energy amid what could be a spike in demand for oil and gas, investors stand to benefit from a “toll booth” effect, so to speak, with less to worry about regarding the state of the Strait of Hormuz or how much higher or lower oil prices could move.

As it stands today, the yield sits at 5.0%, making it one of the most generous, well-covered payouts in the mega-cap Canadian market. You could go chasing for higher yields, but the added risks, I think, are not worth it. Might as well stick with a proven dividend-growth star in Enbridge, especially as it is experiencing strength right across the board.

Enbridge stock might be one of the market’s newest momentum heroes, but I see no reason to sell at 26.7 times trailing P/E. In my view, that’s a very fair price to pay for a firm with one of the widest physical economic moats out there.

The company is flush with cash flows, and much of it will be coming back to investors in the form of a dividend hike. What’s most interesting is how the AI-driven tailwind will affect the firm in the next 10-15 years.

Bottom line

It’s hard to pick between CNQ and ENB. I think they go well together. If I were forced to pick one, though, maybe ENB takes the cake for the higher yield and lower beta. Though CNQ does score higher for value and upside if another leg higher for oil happens.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Canadian Natural Resources and Enbridge. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Energy Stocks

Child measures his height on wall. He is growing taller.
Energy Stocks

Down 16% and Paying 5.8%: The Case for Buying Enbridge Now

Understand how Enbridge is positioning itself in the energy sector during uncertain times with significant capital investments.

Read more »

Data Center Engineer Using Laptop Computer crypto mining
Energy Stocks

I’m Watching Hammond Power’s Backlog, Now Nearly Double Last Year’s

Hammond Power's revenue backlog is up 96.9% YoY on AI data centre demand. Here's what to watch ahead of Q3…

Read more »

golden sunset in crude oil refinery with pipeline system
Energy Stocks

Enbridge’s $41 Billion Backlog Is Why I’m Not Selling

Here’s why Enbridge’s massive growth backlog and reliable dividend make it one of the best Canadian stocks to buy and…

Read more »

a man relaxes with his feet on a pile of books
Energy Stocks

Why I’d Rather Own Enbridge and Its $41 Billion Backlog Than Chase a Higher Yield

Discover the importance of Enbridge against the backdrop of Canada’s energy investments and its potential amidst rising infrastructure demand.

Read more »

Hourglass and stock price chart
Energy Stocks

The Set-It-and-Forget-It Dividend Stock for Your Portfolio

Enbridge (TSX:ENB) is a standout dividend pick to own for the long haul as its growth streak keeps going strong.

Read more »

Nuclear power station cooling tower
Energy Stocks

Cameco: Should You Buy on Canada’s Uranium Push? Here’s My Verdict

Here’s why Cameco’s uranium business and stake in Westinghouse make it one of the top Canadian stocks to consider buying…

Read more »

Senior uses a laptop computer
Energy Stocks

A 5.8% Dividend Stock That’ll Pay You Through Your Retirement Years

Its high yield, a longstanding record of dividend increases, and ability to keep growing its dividends make it a compelling…

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Energy Stocks

I Keep Coming Back to Canadian Natural After 26 Straight Years of Dividend Increases

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) stock is a dividend growth icon as it looks to break out while giving more back…

Read more »