TD or BMO? Here’s the Dividend Stock I’d Rather Buy

Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO) stock has run up a lot. Could an out-of-favour non-bank financial be better?

Key Points
  • Large Canadian banks are starting to get pricey.
  • Non-bank financials in many cases offer better growth prospects.
  • In this article I explore a TSX non-bank financial stock I'd buy before TD and BMO.

Are you considering investing in Canadian bank stocks like TD Bank (TSX: TD) or Bank of Montreal?

If so, you’re making a natural choice. Canada’s banks are some of the best businesses in the country, being defined by strong risk management and considerable protection from outside competition. They’ve performed well over the long term.

Indeed, the TSX banks are so strong that they make up a disproportionate share of the TSX’s market cap. Two of the three biggest Canadian companies (66%) are banks!

Personally, I like TSX banks enough that I currently hold TD Bank as my first or second-largest position (it was by far my largest position as recently as two months ago, but I sold about 35% of my shares in July). Despite that, I wouldn’t actively be looking to add to my TD position right now – nor would I be interested in buying BMO shares. No, there’s another TSX financial – a non-bank financial – that I’d much rather buy in August. In the ensuing paragraphs, I will explore that stock in detail and explain why I’m considering adding to my position in it.

open bank vault

Source: Getty Images

Brookfield Asset Management

Brookfield Asset Management (TSX: BAM) is a Canadian asset management company. Like TD and Bank of Montreal, it is a financial services company. However, unlike those companies, BAM is not a diversified bank, but rather a pure play asset manager. Its sole business activity is running investment funds for institutional clients like pension funds and governments. Its parent company, Brookfield Corporation, is a diversified financial that is similar to the big Canadian banks in some ways, though even it isn’t involved in banking as such.

Brookfield is Canada’s premier non-bank financial, and Brookfield Asset Management is its investment management subsidiary. Due to a recent spinoff, the pure play asset manager can be bought as a standalone security. In a Canadian financial sector dominated by conventional banks, that fact makes BAM distinctive.

Brookfield Asset Management’s competitive advantage

BAM has a massive competitive advantage in the form of a great reputation. The company is well known and respected by many of the smartest people on Wall Street. Past shareholders and partners have included people like Lou Simpson, Bill Ackman, Mohnish Pabrai, and Howard Marks. Asset management is all about relationships, and this laundry list of well-connected shareholders and partners gives BAM an edge in finding new clients.

Growth and profitability

Brookfield’s competitive strengths have contributed to stellar financial results from the company. In the trailing 12-month period, BAM’s revenue increased 31.9%, its earnings increased 14%, and it had net and FCF margins of 47% and 49%, respectively. So, the company’s expertise in running alternative asset funds is leading to concrete financial performance.

Valuation

Despite its strong performance, BAM is not an especially pricey stock. Going by reported earnings, BAM trades at about a 30 times P/E ratio. That might appear high, but note the high growth, and also the fact that this is an asset management business, which may be evaluated better by distributable earnings (DE) rather than reported earnings. If we use DE instead of reported earnings, then BAM’s P/E ratio shrinks to 21.8 – not dirt cheap, but not extraordinarily high by the standards of the financial services sector in 2026.

The bottom line

The bottom line on TSX financials today is that the most obvious ones – big banks like TD and BMO – are starting to look pricey relative to their potential future earnings. They’re still worth holding, but non-bank financials like BAM offer an exciting alternative. I’d rather invest fresh funds into the latter rather than the former.

Fool contributor Andrew Button has positions in TD Bank, Brookfield Asset Management, and Brookfield Corporation. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Brookfield Corporation. The Motley Fool recommends Brookfield Asset Management. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Structure My $14,000 TFSA for Constant Income

If you have $14,000 saved in your TFSA, here is one easy investment strategy to earn $50 of tax-free monthly…

Read more »

woman looks at iPhone
Dividend Stocks

I’m Not Selling Telus After the 55% Dividend Cut: Here’s Why

Contrary to what the market seems to be saying, Telus Corporation (TSX: T) still has a lot going for it.…

Read more »

monthly calendar with clock
Dividend Stocks

A No-Nonsense 3.7% Dividend Stock That Can Pay Retirees Monthly

This no-nonsense dividend stock has returned more than $3.4 billion to shareholders through dividends since 2013.

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

3 Questions to Ask Before Buying a Dividend Stock

Buying a dividend stock? Here are three questions to help you look beyond the yield, with examples from Enbridge, Fortis…

Read more »

Woman in private jet airplane
Dividend Stocks

Make $100 a Month Tax-Free: How Much to Invest in Diversified Royalty and Where

The TFSA is the ultimate investment account to place your money and earn tax-free income.

Read more »

man in bowtie poses with abacus
Dividend Stocks

Passive Income From Dividends: What Canadians Can Realistically Expect

Here's the actual dividend math the passive income gurus won't show you.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

RRSP, TFSA or Both? A Quick Guide by Income Level

Your RRSP and TFSA are complementing accounts that you can use to shield your income from taxes.

Read more »

Real estate investment concept with person pointing on growth graph and coin stacking to get profit from property
Dividend Stocks

Buying Your First Home? The $8,000 FHSA Deduction Most Renters Miss

An eligible renter's $8,000 FHSA contribution can save $2,400 at a 30% tax rate, with the purchase date guiding investments.

Read more »