Keeping $10,000 in Cash for 10 Years Could Cost More Than a Market Dip

Cash may feel safe in a downturn, but over a decade, it can quietly lose buying power versus investing.

| More on:
Key Points
  • Cash avoids scary market drops, but inflation can quietly shrink what your money buys over time.
  • If you won’t need the money for 10 years, investing can beat cash even after an early market dip.
  • BCE could be a small, higher-risk long-term pick, but debt, spending, and a dividend cut add uncertainty.

A market decline announces itself loudly. Your account turns red, the headlines become dramatic, and suddenly everyone has an opinion about your retirement.

Cash is considerably quieter. The balance stays reassuringly familiar while groceries, insurance, and practically everything involving a contractor become more expensive.

That difference makes cash feel safer than it sometimes is. For money you won’t need for a decade, avoiding every market dip can create another problem: missing years of potential growth while purchasing power slips away.

Beware of bad investing advice.

Source: Getty Images

Safety has more than one meaning

Suppose $10,000 sits in an account earning no interest for 10 years. At an illustrative 2% annual inflation rate, it would finish with purchasing power equivalent to approximately $8,203 today.

Interest helps. If cash earned an average 3% annually, with interest reinvested, it would grow to approximately $13,439 before tax. That’s meaningfully better than leaving it idle, although the return available on savings accounts can change.

Now compare those outcomes with an illustrative investment earning 7% annually.

SCENARIOVALUE AFTER 10 YEARS
Cash earning no interest$10,000
Cash earning 3% annually$13,439
Investment earning 7% annually$19,672
Immediate 20% investment decline, then 7% annually for 10 years$15,737

These are nominal values before fees and taxes, with no additional contributions. The last scenario deliberately assumes an immediate loss followed by a full decade of growth. It isn’t a forecast or evidence that stocks always recover.

It does show why avoiding an initial decline isn’t automatically the same as achieving the best long-term outcome.

One stock I’d consider selectively

For a small portion of genuinely long-term money, BCE (TSX: BCE) offers a contrarian option from the analyst research I follow.

BCE owns wireless, internet, fibre, and media businesses. Its networks provide services customers use repeatedly, while its Ziply Fiber acquisition adds a U.S. expansion opportunity. Furthermore, the recent announcement of a 1.2-gigawatt (GW) artificial intelligence (AI) expansion adds more long-term value.

I’d consider a small position alongside other Canadian stocks, provided the investor can tolerate a turnaround that takes years.

The business still has work to do

BCE’s second-quarter adjusted earnings per share (EPS) increased 3.2% to $0.65. However, free cash flow fell 9.5% to $1.04 billion as capital spending increased.

Fibre network efficiencies remain an advantage, but Ziply’s construction spending and BCE’s debt burden limit financial flexibility. Competitive pressure could keep customer revenue weak while those bills continue arriving.

BCE’s 2025 dividend cut is another reason not to confuse a familiar company with a guaranteed investment. Its shares could fall further, and the hypothetical 7% return above is not a BCE forecast.

Give cash a deadline

Emergency savings, a near-term home purchase, and upcoming retirement withdrawals belong in accessible, lower-risk holdings. That money has a job, and protecting it matters more than maximizing its return. The question is whether the entire $10,000 genuinely needs that protection for 10 years.

After separating short-term needs, I’d invest the long-term portion across diversified holdings, with BCE only a modest component. A written purchase schedule can help hesitant investors get started. Proper portfolio diversification matters more than making one perfectly timed trade.

Foolish bottom line

Cash protects against market volatility, but it doesn’t automatically protect purchasing power or long-term goals.

Keep the money you need soon secure. Give the money you won’t need for years an investment plan that reflects its longer timeline. A market dip can hurt, but spending a decade waiting for investing to feel comfortable can carry a substantial cost of its own.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Banks Just Pledged $325 Billion: Here’s the 1 Bank I’d Buy

Global investors are lining up to fund Canada’s next buildout, and BMO could profit by financing and advising the boom.

Read more »

space ship model takes off
Tech Stocks

Canada’s Aerospace Boom is Taking Off: Here’s the TSX Stock to Buy Now

Canada’s aerospace boom is being fuelled by a new wave of defence spending, and Bombardier could be a direct TSX…

Read more »

some REITs give investors exposure to commercial real estate
Stocks for Beginners

Here are 3 Canadian Blue Chip Stocks I Plan to Hold for Years – Here’s My Take

Learn about blue chip companies and their trustworthiness in the market. Discover stable investments that withstand crises.

Read more »

data center server racks glow with light
Stocks for Beginners

The AI Data Centre Backlash Has Started: I’d Watch These 2 Canadian Stocks

AI data centres promise growth, but local pushback is forcing investors to separate real earnings from risky, unapproved projects.

Read more »

investor schemes to buy stocks before market notices them
Energy Stocks

GIC or Dividend Stock? Here’s Where I’d Put $10,000 for the Next 5 Years

I'd invest in this hydro producer and wait for the share price to recover if the timing goes wrong.

Read more »

man with shovel stands by a hole
Dividend Stocks

TD Just Put $150 Billion Behind Canada’s Next Investment Boom. Should You Buy the Stock?

Instead of betting on which mega-project wins, consider a picks-and-shovels play on the bank that earns interest and fees on…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Stocks for Beginners

Canada Just Unleashed Nearly $500 Billion in New Investment: Here’s What I’d Buy Now

Nearly $500 billion of “commitments” sounds like a windfall, but the real opportunity is in who finances the projects if…

Read more »

man looks surprised at investment growth
Stocks for Beginners

The OAS Clawback Can Start Before You Feel Rich: I’d Make This Move Earlier

OAS clawbacks can hit “comfortable” retirees, so shifting income into a TFSA and managing RRSP/RRIF withdrawals early matters.

Read more »