Higher Oil Prices Could Delay Rate Cuts: Here’s Where I’d Put $10,000

Suncor can turn today’s expensive oil into dividends and a smaller share count.

Key Points
  • Higher energy prices can complicate the case for rate cuts.
  • Suncor increased planned repurchases to $500 million per month.
  • Buybacks create more value when management can retire shares at lower prices.

Expensive oil has an irritating ability to reach into two pockets at once. First comes the petrol station, then comes the possibility that higher energy inflation keeps borrowing costs elevated for longer.

The Bank of Canada held its policy rate at 2.25% in September, while elevated energy prices remain one of the risks to the inflation outlook. That doesn’t mean higher oil guarantees another rate hike. Yet it does mean I wouldn’t build an investment plan that requires cheaper money next month. I’d rather own something currently generating cash.

trading chart of brent crude oil prices

Source: Getty Images

Get paid by the problem

Energy producers can benefit when realized oil prices rise. Yet a higher barrel price doesn’t travel directly to shareholders. Royalties rise, operating costs continue, taxes get paid and companies still need to invest in their assets.

What remains can fund dividends, debt reduction or share repurchases. That’s why I’d rather focus on per-share cash generation than celebrate another oil headline. For a $10,000 long-term allocation, Suncor Energy (TSX: SU) still deserves consideration among Canadian dividend stocks.

Two sides of oil

The key here is that Suncor is integrated. It produces oil and refines it, and sells fuel through businesses including Petro-Canada. That gives the company exposure to crude prices and refining margins rather than relying on just one link in the chain.

Second-quarter adjusted funds from operations reached $5.3 billion. Management then increased planned share repurchases to $500 million per month beginning in August. That’s where strong oil prices can create something more permanent.

Repurchasing shares reduces the number of claims on future earnings, provided management doesn’t wildly overpay. At different prices, that same $500 million buys very different amounts of Suncor. A cheaper stock lets the same cash retire more shares, so buybacks become considerably less exciting when everyone is excited.

What $10,000 buys

Suncor pays $0.60 quarterly, or $2.40 annually. At $98.09, $10,000 would buy 101 whole shares.

COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
SU$98.09101$2.40$242.40Quarterly$9,907.09

The yield is only around 2.4%, so this isn’t primarily an income trade. I’d be buying Suncor for cash flow, buybacks and the possibility that fewer shares translate into greater earnings per share over time. A $10,000 purchase inside a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) requires enough contribution room beyond the 2026 annual $7,000 limit.

Bottom line

Lower crude prices, weaker refining margins or operational outages can reduce cash flow just as quickly as they improved it. That makes position sizing important after a large commodity rally. I’d buy in stages rather than treat US$100 oil as evidence the stock can’t get cheaper.

Higher oil prices might complicate the path to lower interest rates. Suncor gives investors a way to own the cash-generation side of that problem instead of simply paying more at the pump.

If management keeps using excess cash to retire shares at sensible prices, today’s expensive oil could improve tomorrow’s per-share results. That’s what would keep me invested long after the next Bank of Canada decision.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Energy Stocks

Hourglass and stock price chart
Energy Stocks

Enbridge Q3: Profit Nearly Doubles, and I Don’t Think the Dividend Stock is Done Yet

Enbridge starts investors off with a near 5.9% dividend that can continue to grow with a steady growth profile.

Read more »

Woman checking her computer and holding coffee cup
Energy Stocks

Hydro One Stock: A Growing Grid Doesn’t Mean You Should Pay Any Price

Hydro One’s grid investment supports growth, but my preferred entry offers a better starting yield than today’s price.

Read more »

Canadian energy stocks are rising with oil prices
Energy Stocks

Suncor vs. Canadian Natural: Which Dividend Would I Rely On When Oil Falls?

Canadian Natural is my income preference through weaker oil prices, while Suncor offers refining exposure and a newly increased dividend.

Read more »

dividend stocks are a good way to earn passive income
Energy Stocks

Income Investors! Enbridge’s Q3 Results and 5.8% Yield Make a Compelling Case

Enbridge is operating close to capacity as the energy sector benefits from strong demand. The stock is a good buy…

Read more »

Hourglass projecting a dollar sign as shadow
Energy Stocks

Canadian Natural Resources Is Down 10% in 5 Days: Too Late to Buy the Dividend?

Learn how the US mid-term elections affected Canadian Natural Resources and quickly led to a 10% drop in stock value.

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Energy Stocks

A Top-Notch 6.5% Dividend Stock to Fuel Your Retirement Income Every Month

Peyto Exploration stock just instituted an 8% increase in its monthly dividend, as cash flows remain strong and its debt…

Read more »

A meter measures energy use.
Energy Stocks

Rates Are Rising Again: Is Emera Still a Sensible Retirement Stock?

Emera still offers retirement income, but borrowing costs and per-share earnings decide how comfortably that payment can grow.

Read more »

how to save money
Energy Stocks

How Much Would You Need to Invest in Enbridge to Average $200 a Month?

Enbridge’s current dividend needs roughly $42,600 in shares to average $200 monthly, with payments arriving every quarter.

Read more »