Stock Day Trading Is Back! Is It Right for you?

Day trading may be popular, but buy-and-hold is easier and likely to be more lucrative. Why not pick the easier path to riches?

With the markets in turmoil and people confined to their homes, there’s been a surge in stock day trading. Investors across the country are betting on or against stock prices that are fluctuating by double digits every other day. If you’ve never invested in stocks before, here’s what you need to know about day trading and its alternatives. 

Day trading 101

Put simply, day trading is a strategy for investors to bet on a stock price going up or down within a single day. The stock market is open from 9:30 am to 4:00 pm eastern time, and most stocks barely move throughout that window. However, on some occasions, prices can move substantially. 

For example, Shopify stock surged 8.2% on May 6. Investors who bet on the stock in the morning potentially made hundreds of dollars. Investors who bought call options could have made thousands — not bad for a day’s work. 

Day traders lose money on some days. However, the strategy is expected to deliver riches over time as long as a trader can have more up days than down ones.

Pitfalls of day trading

Day trading hinges on probability. As long as you can have more up days than down over time, you’ll make money. However, you simply don’t know your chances of making money when you start. 

Let me put it another way. We now know that Shopify stock surged 8.2% on May 6. However, I can’t predict what the stock will do on May 21 or July 2 or December 10. I can make a bet based on a guess, but that’s just speculation.

Research suggests that 80% of day trading investors give up on the strategy within the first two years. That’s a clear indication that making money by trading daily is difficult if not impossible. 

Better alternatives

Veteran investors believe that if there’s an easier way to make money, you should probably adopt it. For instance, the long-term trend of an industry or the economy is easier to predict than the daily moves. 

It’s easier for me to say Shopify’s potential market is worth $9 trillion and the company could be worth much more in a few years. It’s also easier for me to see that people will still be paying their electric bills in 2022, so stocks like Fortis should be able to sustain their dividends.

I can’t tell you precisely how much Canadians will spend on healthcare and groceries in the future, but it seems likely it will be more not less in ten years. 

Making these calls is easier. It’s more intuitive. And it’s probably why investors can make bigger bets with more conviction. Buying and holding Shopify or Fortis for years, if not decades, should be unimaginably easier than day trading — and it’s also likely to be a lot more lucrative.  

From Warren Buffett to Gerald W. Schwartz, the buy-and-hold strategy has worked for countless billionaires for decades. There’s no reason why it can’t work for regular investors like us.

Foolish takeaway

Day trading may be popular, but buy-and-hold is easier and likely to be more lucrative. Why not pick the easier path to riches?

Fool contributor Vishesh Raisinghani has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Tom Gardner owns shares of Shopify. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Shopify and Shopify.

More on Stocks for Beginners

resting in a hammock with eyes closed
Dividend Stocks

Yes, a 3.5% Dividend Yield Is Enough to Generate Massive Passive Income

This “boring” TSX dividend stock has quietly surged, and its next earnings report could change expectations again.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

Got $14,000? Here’s How to Structure a TFSA for Lifelong Monthly Income

Turn a “small” $14,000 TFSA deposit into steady, tax-free monthly cash by picking resilient REITs, not just high yields.

Read more »

diversification is an important part of building a stable portfolio
Stocks for Beginners

Here Are My Top Canadian Stocks to Buy for 2026

Here are four Canadian stocks I plan to buy in 2026 and hold for the years ahead.

Read more »

ETFs can contain investments such as stocks
Stocks for Beginners

Start 2026 Strong: 3 Canadian ETFs for Smart Investors

These Vanguard ETFs target Canadian stocks using a variety of methods and are great for beginner investors.

Read more »

a woman sleeps with her eyes covered with a mask
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Stocks That Are the Best to Buy and Hold in a TFSA

Three “sleep well” TFSA stocks can come from boring, essential businesses: rail, insurance, and waste.

Read more »

A meter measures energy use.
Dividend Stocks

1 Unbelievable Canadian Dividend Stock to Buy and Hold for Years

Canadian Utilities is the kind of dividend stock that can keep paying and compounding quietly, even when the share price…

Read more »

Person uses a tablet in a blurred warehouse as background
Dividend Stocks

This Safe 4% Dividend Stock Could Pay up Every Month

Granite REIT looks like a “set-it-and-collect-it” monthly payer, with rising distributions backed by strong industrial demand.

Read more »

a sign flashes global stock data
Dividend Stocks

5 Top Canadian Stocks to Pick up Now in January

January can reward investors who put fresh TFSA/RRSP cash to work in stocks with clear catalysts and steady demand.

Read more »