Stock Market Crash: Could a 2000-Style Drop Be in the Cards?

Stocks may look expensive after 2020’s tech-driven rally, but are stocks really in a bubble like they were before the 2020 stock market crash?

Financial technology concept.

Image source: Getty Images

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: the stock market is expensive going into 2021. Potentially so expensive such that prospective returns moving forward are low and the risk of a 2000-style tech-lead stock market crash is high. While the TSX Index and S&P 500 may be “expensive” based on traditional valuation metrics, with tech leading the way in the latter index, I’d say it’s quite the stretch to say that we’re due for a repeat of the events that unfolded after the tech frenzy of the late 1990s.

Tech stocks haven’t been this hot in quite a while

Are stocks really partying like it’s the late 1990s? With the exception of Bitcoin, a handful of overbought recent Initial Public Offerings (IPOs), EV makers that I shall not name, and a few other isolated pockets of severe overvaluation, I’d say no, it’s not partying like the late 1990s — not even close.

Back when the dot-com bubble inflated, tech may have led the upward charge, but valuations across the board were so stretched beyond belief. The NASDAQ went parabolic for a while, surging more than 100% from trough-to-peak in around a year.

While the NASDAQ is up almost double from those ominous March depths, it’s up just a modest 30% from pre-pandemic highs, and it’s up mainly because of a few dominant tech behemoths, which are profoundly profitable, have been beneficiaries of this horrific pandemic.

A 2000-style market crash is unlikely, but what about those bubbles?

Unlike in 1999, when many euphoric investors were betting on stories (like with those white-hot shares of Shopify), today’s dominant tech leaders are generating so much cash that it’s ridiculous. Their valuations are backed by earnings, and heck, the FAANG stocks may actually still be undervalued here, given their dominance increased substantially in 2020.

I can’t say the same about white-hot software-as-a-service (SaaS) stocks (think Shopify), many of which have been bid-up by investors exhibiting the fear of missing out mentality. Sure, stocks may not be as expensive as they seem, given the pandemic-plagued environment and the U.S. Fed’s backing. But that doesn’t grant a free pass to pay whatever price Mr. Market is asking for at any given instance.

While a name like Shopify deserves a premium valuation, just how much of a premium remains the million-dollar question. Shopify stock will probably never trade at a multiple that’s anything short of absurdly expensive.

That said, one has to draw the side somewhere. If you’re in the belief that paying for many years’ worth of (potentially unsustainable) growth right off the bat is a risky proposition, then it may be time to take profits in 2020 winners such as Shopify before the appetite for speculation has a chance to nosedive.

The 56 times sales multiple on shares of Shopify is excessive, to say the least. For those who’ve already doubled or tripled their money on the name, it’s only prudent to think about playing with the house’s money now that the stakes have been raised that much higher in this new year.

Should investors expect a tech-led market crash?

Margin debt is uncomfortably high, Bitcoin and other such speculative momentum plays are not looking back, IPOs are way oversubscribed and overbought, and the “new normal” may also be describing lofty valuations in some tech plays out there.

That said, I have no idea if or when Mr. Market will correct any isolated pockets of overvaluation. But when he does, the “sexiest” plays could be at risk of crumbling like a paper bag, doling out amplified losses to those who went all-in on the “hottest” investment themes of this past year.

Stay cautious, my friends.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Shopify.

More on Tech Stocks

consider the options
Tech Stocks

Top 2 Beaten-Down Stocks I’ve Not Given Up on

The massive correction in the prices of these TSX stocks presents a solid buying opportunity at current levels.

Read more »

Various Canadian dollars in gray pants pocket
Tech Stocks

2 Cheap Stocks (Below $50) to Buy and Hold Till 2032

The inexpensive valuations and rapid growth will help these Canadian companies outperform the TSX by a wide margin.

Read more »

Couple relaxing on a beach in front of a sunset
Dividend Stocks

Canadians: 3 Easy Stocks to Invest in for Retirement

It’s never too early to begin retirement planning. Adding the right mix of stocks to an RRSP can grow your…

Read more »

Tech Stocks

3 Growth Stocks to Buy Before it’s Too Late

These growth stocks were once greats, and now they're gross to even consider. But honestly, I'm asking you to consider…

Read more »

Family relationship with bond and care
Tech Stocks

Retire Young: 2 Cheap Growth Stocks to Buy Now and Hold Forever

There are huge sales on growth stocks in the tech sector. Here are two top picks to put on your…

Read more »

A worker uses the cloud for paperless work. tech
Tech Stocks

3 Tricks to Finding Undervalued Canadian Stocks

There are plenty of cheap Canadian stocks, but not all are undervalued. Yet this one certainly ticks all the boxes.

Read more »

Tech Stocks

Lightspeed Stock: Could a Holiday Rush Save the Tech Stock?

Lightspeed (TSX:LSPD)(NYSE:LSPD) stock continues to have near-term issues, but in the long term, this could be a stock everyone wants…

Read more »

question marks written reminders tickets
Tech Stocks

Is Evertz Technologies (TSX:ET) Stock a Buy After Q1 Earnings?

Evertz Technologies (TSX:ET) stock appears undervalued and offers a high dividend yield and growth potential. Watch identified challenges.

Read more »