Individual Energy Stocks vs ETFs: Which Is Better for Investors?

ETFs are an easy, capital efficient way of gaining sector exposure, but sometimes picking individual stocks may be a better option.

The TSX energy sector is cyclical, with bouts of underperformance and outperformance versus the S&P/TSX Composite Index. Factors like political roadblocks, commodity prices, and supply chain disruption make it rather volatile.

Today, with inflation at all-time highs and the threat of multiple rate hikes on the horizon, these energy stocks are again poised to outperform in 2022, after posting amazing returns in 2021.

Investors seeking to gain exposure can either choose to buy individual energy stocks, or buy a sector exchange-traded fund (ETF) that holds them all. Let’s look at the pros and cons of each approach.

ETF chart stocks

Image source: Getty Images

The ETF method

There is an easy way to own the TSX energy sector with one ticker — iShares S&P/TSX Capped Energy Index ETF (TSX:XEG). XEG holds 22 energy stocks in a “basket” of sorts. When you purchase a share of the ETF, you are getting a slice of this basket, with proportionate exposure to all of its underlying stocks.

XEG is advantageous in that it is completely hands off – asides from buying shares of the ETF, you don’t have to worry about rebalancing. The dividend payments are easily tracked too, with the 22 dividends averaged out to pay an annual yield of 1.79% currently.

XEG currently trades at around $13 a share, making it a very capital efficient method for investors with smaller accounts to gain exposure to energy stocks, some of which trade in the $50+ share price range. If you don’t have too much money to allocate to multiple individual energy stocks, XEG is the way to go.

The stock method

There is a big downside to XEG – the management expense ratio (MER). This is the cost charged by the fund provider to you on a annual basis for managing the ETF. The current MER is 0.61%, which means that for a $10,000 account, you are being charged $61 dollars annually to hold XEG.

That might not sound like a lot, but it does add up over time. For larger accounts, the opportunity cost of the MER can compound significant to result in missed gains. Compare this to buying and holding each of the 22 energy stocks individually. If you are using a$ 0-commission brokerage like Wealthsimple Trade, your fees would be 0%.

If you wanted to create a portfolio of the six largest energy stocks (Enbridge, TC Energy, Pembina Pipeline, Suncor Energy, Imperial Oil, and Canadian Natural Resources) by market cap, you should purchase enough shares of each, so the total dollar amount in each stock represents roughly 16.66% of your allocation, as seen in this image:

The Foolish takeaway

A word of caution: the backtest results provide below are hypothetical in nature, do not reflect actual investment results, and are not guarantees of future results. Hypothetical returns do not reflect trading costs, transaction fees, or actual taxes due on investment returns.

That being said, from 2003 to present, with all dividends reinvested and quarterly rebalancing, the equal weight six-fund portfolio of the largest Canadian energy stocks beat XEG significantly in terms of risk and return.

This can be attributed to the high MER of XEG, the much greater dividend yield and growth of the six large-cap stocks, and the under-performance of small-cap energy stocks in XEG.

Choosing between the two boils down to two questions:

  1. Do you have the time and discipline to manage a portfolio of six stocks, reinvesting the dividends and rebalancing every quarter without tinkering or deviating from your strategy?
  2. Do you think the large-cap Canadian energy stocks will continue to outperform and increase their dividends? Historically, investors have been compensated with greater returns for the risk of small caps, although the TSX energy sector hasn’t reliably produced that small-cap risk premium.

If your answer to both of those questions is no, paying 0.61% to buy an ETF and have someone manage it for you might make more sense.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends CDN NATURAL RES, Enbridge, and PEMBINA PIPELINE CORPORATION.

More on Energy Stocks

Two seniors walk in the forest
Energy Stocks

A 3.9% Dividend Stock That Will Pay You Through Your Retirement Years

Retirees might buy this dividend stock gradually on market pullbacks, as a part of a diversified retirement portfolio.

Read more »

how to save money
Energy Stocks

Want $12,000 a Year in Dividends? Here’s the Capital the Goal Requires

A $12,000 dividend target can look more manageable once you see the required balance and how much monthly deposits can…

Read more »

Offshore wind turbine farm at sunset
Energy Stocks

Northland Power Stock: Would I Buy the Dividend or Wait for Better Cash Flow?

Northland pays monthly after cutting its dividend. I’d wait for more cash after project spending before giving it a job…

Read more »

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Energy Stocks

I Found the Ideal Retirement TFSA Stock Paying 6.4%

Looking for an ideal retirement TFSA stock? Freehold Royalties stock pays a 6.4% monthly dividend backed by a low payout…

Read more »

boy in bowtie and glasses gives positive thumbs up
Energy Stocks

Enbridge: My Verdict Is Buy – Here’s the Dividend $6,000 Would Collect

Unpack the financial dynamics at Enbridge, including its stock performance and pressures from rising debt and investment needs.

Read more »

Trans Alaska Pipeline with Autumn Colors
Energy Stocks

How Much Would You Need in Pembina to Average $300 a Month?

Pembina pays quarterly. Averaging $300 a month at its latest rate would take about $85,000 at writing.

Read more »

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

What $12,000 in Canadian Utilities Could Add to Your Annual Income

At its recent price, Canadian Utilities could turn a $12,000 budget into about $418 a year in dividends.

Read more »

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Energy Stocks

My Top Canadian Dividend Stock to Own Going Into 2027

An energy major that is poised to have a sizeable footprint after a multi-billion-dollar deal is the top Canadian dividend…

Read more »