A stock can fall after a good report and make you feel like you’ve missed a page. The business sold more, kept more cash and still left shareholders with less money by closing time. That’s the market’s way of reminding us that good results come with a price tag.

Source: Getty Images
For sale
A selloff resets the price you can pay today. It doesn’t tell you what the business will earn over the next decade. I’d look at what investors expected before the report and what the company actually delivered, then decide how much of the next several years I’m being asked to buy in advance.
For growth stocks, I like to look at free cash flow, or cash left after operating expenses and investment in equipment and other capital assets. It helps me see what the business has available to reinvest. I’d look across several quarters so a seasonal cash bump doesn’t get mistaken for the pace the business can sustain.
There’s also a timing issue. The holiday shopping period can tell investors a lot about what merchants are selling and which services they’re using. I’d look at the results alongside spending ahead of that rush, especially if it takes another quarter or two for the payoff to show.
I’d also be careful with how much room a growth stock takes up inside a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA). Gains can grow tax-free. A loss in the account doesn’t give me new contribution room to replace it, which makes position size worth deciding before I hit buy. So let’s dive in.
SHOP
Shopify (TSX: SHOP) sells tools merchants use to set up stores, take payments and handle online and in-person orders. It can earn more as sellers grow and use more services. That gives me a way to own a piece of the infrastructure behind a sale without choosing which brand of jeans will be popular next year.
Revenue rose 32% in the third quarter. Shopify reported a 22% free cash flow margin, meaning about $0.22 of every revenue dollar became free cash flow by its definition. Growth at that pace is more appealing when the business is also keeping a meaningful amount of cash.
I’d watch what new shopping tools do for merchants before assigning them much value. If they bring more sales through Shopify’s checkout or give sellers a reason to pay for more services, the investment can help earnings. If the tools cost more to run and shoppers barely use them, the bill still shows up.
The test
The stock fell 8% on November 3, the day it reported. At that price, I’d put the shares next to a conservative estimate of annual cash flow per share in Canadian dollars. For illustration, at 40 times that cash flow, the stock would need about $5.26 per share to support the current share price. At 30 times, it would need about $7.02.
I’d buy a small position if the price and my estimate leave room for slower growth. Then, I’d hold if the business keeps delivering and the position hasn’t grown too big. I’d wait if my estimate only works when merchants spend more, margins rise and investors keep paying a high multiple all at once. That means I can change my mind in either direction. If the share price falls because the business starts keeping less cash per sale, a lower price alone won’t make me buy. If the economics get better, the same price may offer a different deal.
That’s my way of keeping a stock I like from becoming a stock I need to be right about. There’ll be other chances to buy during a stock market correction, and Shopify will have more quarters to show what it can earn from the changes it’s making.
Bottom line
I’d hold Shopify at a size I’m comfortable owning through a rough year. A better price or several quarters of stronger cash generation would make it easier for me to add without asking an excellent business to deliver a perfect decade.