Which Stock Is the Better Buy: Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX) or Wheaton Precious Metals (TSX:WPM)?

Both Barrick Gold Corp. (TSX:ABX)(NYSE:GOLD) and Wheaton Precious Metals Corporation (TSX:WPM)(NYSE:WPM) have had a great start to the year, but which is the better buy?

| More on:

It’s no secret that Wheaton Precious Metals (TSX:WPM)(NYSE:WPM) has been hitting some crazy numbers recently.

The stock has gone from about $20 per share to over $31 per share at the time of writing in under four months.

But is this stock still at the top? Another titan of the gold industry is Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX)(NYSE:GOLD), which could be a fairly sturdy option as well.

So, which should you be investing in?

Wheaton

Wheaton’s business model is what makes investors pretty excited about this company. Rather than owning and operating mines, the company invests in mining projects. For example, if a mining company wants to open a mine but needs start-up costs, Wheaton swoops in with the funds.

What does Wheaton get in exchange? It gets the precious metals the company mines at below wholesale prices. It’s a pretty sweet deal for both the company and its investors.

The latest increases in this company’s stock pretty much add up to some more streaming deals Wheaton has made. Most recently, the company paid $307 million for a streaming agreement with Hudbay Minerals, which saw shares jump about 5%.

But if we add up all the deals the company has made in the last while, shares have jumped 55% from $20.56 to $31.89 at the time of writing.

Can the stock keep up these numbers? That depends pretty much entirely on the value of gold, silver, and copper and as long as these deals keep up. Should a recession occur, those prices could go down and take the share price along with it.

Barrick

What Barrick has going for it is pretty major: it’s the largest gold producer in the world. The great news for this industry titan is that gold has been on a bit of a rally. The great news for investors is that Barrick has also been merging and acquiring company after company amid this news.

The biggest merger, of course, was with Randgold Resources, and, according to fellow Fool writer Andrew Walker, it was, “a deal that created a mining company with five of the top 10 mines on the planet.”

Next in its sights is a deal with Newmont Mining, and if it happens there is really no stopping Barrick from taking over the gold industry.

Where Wheaton has been on a pretty steady upward trend, Barrick has had a few more ups and downs. But the stock is still doing well, starting off the year at around $16 to now reach almost $19. And that could just be the beginning.

If gold prices continue to rally, this stock could be in the territory of doubling in the next while, potentially reaching $30 by the end of 2020.

Barrick or Wheaton?

Gold may be rallying, but with a recession on the line, I just don’t trust that the commodity will continue on its tear. Wheaton has just a too good of a business model to ignore. Where Barrick will definitely continue on an upward trend over the long term, I would wait to invest until the next downturn.

In the meantime, Wheaton’s diversified mining projects mean the company could potentially just continue its meteoric rise and reach $40 per share by the end of 2020. It may not be as drastic an increase as Barrick, but it’s definitely a bit more sturdy.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Wheaton Precious Metals is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.
Stocks for Beginners

Miners Sold Off: 3 TSX Materials Stocks Worth a Second Look

Materials stocks have sold off together, but these three miners have company-specific progress that could surprise investors in 2026.

Read more »

a person watches stock market trades
Stocks for Beginners

Why Smart Canadian Investors Are Watching These 3 Stocks Right Now

These three TSX names are on investors’ watchlists because each has a real catalyst, real growth, and just enough proof…

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Dividend Stocks

The TSX Just Sent a Signal: Here Are 3 Stocks to Buy Now

The TSX is perking up again, and these three stocks look positioned for upside with real assets, earnings momentum, and…

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Metals and Mining Stocks

2 Canadian Mining Stocks Worth Considering Right Now

Agnico Eagle is benefitting from strong gold prices, and Teck Resources has strong upside as copper prices momentum continues.

Read more »

Warning sign with the text "Trade war" in front of container ship
Stocks for Beginners

2 Canadian Stocks That Could Surprise Investors During Trade Turbulence

These five “boring” TSX stocks focus on essentials and recurring demand, which can make them useful holds in 2026.

Read more »

middle-aged couple work together on laptop
Tech Stocks

What the Average Canadian TFSA Looks Like at 50 – and 3 Stocks That Could Help You Catch Up

Turning 50? Discover how the TFSA can enhance your retirement planning and help secure your financial future.

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Metals and Mining Stocks

Gold, Staples, or Cash: Where Should You Put Your Money When Markets Get Rocky?

Long-term success comes from staying diversified and investing through market weakness.

Read more »

customer fills up car with gasoline
Dividend Stocks

Oil Shock, Rate Decision Ahead: 3 TSX Stocks Built for Both

These stocks can hold up better when oil shocks and rate fears make markets choppy.

Read more »