The Retirement Gap CPP and OAS Won’t Fill on Their Own

Retirement plans can fall apart fast if you budget for maximum CPP but end up receiving the average cheque.

Key Points
  • Most Canadians won’t get maximum CPP, so the retirement income gap can be over $28,000 yearly.
  • Estimate your real CPP/OAS, then build layers: cash for now, bonds for stability, stocks for growth.
  • Tourmaline can support the growth layer with a covered base dividend, but gas prices make it unpredictable.

Retirement can look perfectly affordable when the plan quietly assumes you will receive the biggest government pension available. Then the first deposit arrives, and the budget discovers it has been dating the marketing brochure rather than reality.

In 2026, the maximum Canada Pension Plan (CPP) retirement pension starting at 65 is $1,507.65 per month. Yet the average new age-65 recipient receives $877.01. Add the current maximum Old Age Security (OAS) payment of $751.97 for someone aged 65 to 74, and those two starting points produce very different retirements.

Senior uses a laptop computer

Source: Getty Images

The gap

Suppose a retiree needs $4,000 per month before tax. Someone receiving the maximum CPP and OAS would collect $2,259.62, leaving a monthly shortfall of $1,740.38, or $20,884.56 annually. Using a 4% initial withdrawal as an illustration, filling that gap could require a portfolio of approximately $522,000.

Replace the maximum CPP with the recent average, and government income falls to $1,628.98 per month. The shortfall grows to $2,371.02 monthly, or $28,452.24 annually. Supporting that withdrawal at 4% would require approximately $711,000. Ouch.

That is why the maximum CPP figure is a dangerous planning shortcut. Your benefit depends on contribution history, career earnings, and when payments begin. OAS can also differ because of residency history, start age, and income. The sensible move is to check personal estimates before building the retirement budget, not after ordering the celebratory patio furniture.

Income has a job

CPP and OAS are valuable because they provide indexed lifetime income, but they should form the floor rather than the entire house. I would first use them to cover essential expenses, including housing, groceries, utilities, and insurance. A workplace pension, Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) withdrawals, and investment income can then fund the remaining essentials and discretionary spending.

The portfolio shouldn’t be one enormous pile of dividend stocks. Near-term withdrawals can sit in cash or a short guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) ladder; fixed income can reduce volatility, and diversified equities can provide the long-term growth needed to fight inflation. Choosing among Canadian retirement accounts also matters because TFSA withdrawals are tax-free, while RRIF withdrawals increase taxable income.

The growth layer

Tourmaline Oil (TSX: TOU) could occupy a small portion of that equity layer. Canada’s largest natural gas producer pays a $0.50 quarterly base dividend, equal to $2 annually. At recent levels, that produces a yield of approximately 3.3%.

COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
TOU$60.09166$2.00$332.00Quarterly$9,974.94

A $10,000 investment would purchase 166 whole shares and generate $332 in annual base dividends. That averages $27.67 per month, although the regular payments arrive quarterly. Tourmaline stock has also paid special dividends, but I would treat those as bonuses for reinvestment or travel rather than money required to keep the lights on.

A balanced payment

Tourmaline stock generated $192.1 million of free cash flow during the second quarter of 2026. Net debt ended the period at $1.5 billion, below management’s long-term target and equal to approximately 0.4 times forecast 2026 cash flow. That financial flexibility helps protect the base dividend when natural gas prices become uncooperative.

Valuation is also reasonable rather than spectacular. One analyst’s fair-value estimate places Tourmaline stock at $65, roughly 8% above the recent price. The company’s diversified marketing and hedging can improve realized pricing, while export-linked contracts provide exposure to stronger international gas markets.

The risk is straightforward. Tourmaline stock remains a commodity producer, so cash flow and special dividends can shrink when gas prices weaken. That makes it a potential component of a diversified Canadian dividend portfolio, not a bond replacement or a solo retirement plan.

Bottom line

CPP and OAS create an invaluable income floor, but even the maximum payments can leave a five-figure annual shortfall. Start with personal benefit estimates, calculate the actual gap, and build several income layers around it. Tourmaline stock’s well-supported base dividend can help, while any special payment remains exactly what its name suggests: special, welcome, and absolutely not guaranteed.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Tourmaline Oil. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Group of people in a line at an ATM waiting to make a cash withdrawal
Dividend Stocks

The TFSA Withdrawal Rule Every Canadian Should Know

The account is a much better place to invest long term than to make frequent trades and withdrawals.

Read more »

man shops at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

The Best Canadian Stocks for Conservative Investors Right Now

These two Canadian stocks combine durable businesses, growing earnings, and shareholder returns.

Read more »

Three children jump on an outdoor trampoline
Dividend Stocks

2 Solid Dividend Stocks Down 20 Percent to Buy Before They Bounce Back

These Canadian companies have been increasing their dividends year after year, while their stocks have pulled back from recent highs.

Read more »

happy woman throws cash
Dividend Stocks

The Ideal TFSA Stock: A 5.9% Yield-Paying Constant Cash

Enbridge’s predictable cash flows, substantial growth pipeline, and long history of dividend increases underpin its long-term investment appeal for TFSA…

Read more »

woman gazes forward out window to future
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Income in Retirement: What Could Go Wrong?

Dividend investing is a proven way to create income in retirement but you must know the risks you need to…

Read more »

The TFSA is a powerful savings vehicle for Canadians who are saving for retirement.
Dividend Stocks

A 5% Monthly Payer I’d Buy for My TFSA: About $100 a Month on $24,000

Canada’s largest residential landlord offers a high yield, reliable monthly income, and a tax-sheltered foundation for TFSA investors.

Read more »

Two seniors walk in the forest
Dividend Stocks

Can Dividends Replace a Paycheque in Retirement?

Can dividends in retirement replace your paycheque? Explore how Scotiabank, RioCan REIT, and Fortis can help build a steady retirement…

Read more »

Sliced pumpkin pie
Dividend Stocks

The Fees That Quietly Eat Into a Small Investment

Many funds charge outrageous fees, but broad market index funds like the iShares S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index ETF (TSX:XIC) usually…

Read more »