Power Corporation vs. Great-West Lifeco: Which Dividend Stock Would I Own?

Power Corporation gives you exposure to Great-West and more. I’d take Great-West directly when I want to know what’s funding my next dividend.

Key Points
  • Both shares offered yields near 3% at their recent close.
  • Power’s published asset value gives buyers a way to judge the price of the holding company.
  • I’d own Great-West for straightforward income and consider Power if the discount widens.

Buying two stocks can feel like diversification right up until you discover one of them already owns a big piece of the other. That’s a little like ordering two desserts and getting two spoons for the same slice. The second purchase can still make sense; I’d just want to know what else comes with it.

woman stares at chocolate layer cake

Source: Getty Images

Look through the company you own

An operating business makes money from selling its products and services. A holding company owns stakes in other businesses. It can receive dividends from them and use that cash to pay shareholders, make investments or buy back its own stock.

A holding company can trade below the value it assigns to its investments, after deducting liabilities. A discount can be interesting if the underlying assets grow or if the company uses cheap shares to buy back stock. It can also stick around for years while shareholders wait for the market to change its mind.

For me, I’d also look for a history of what management does with money when the shares are cheap. Buying back shares below a reasonable estimate of asset value can help the remaining shareholders own more of the assets per share. It takes both a sensible purchase price and cash the holding company can afford to use.

For my Canadian dividend stocks, I’d decide whether I want the operating business and its earnings or a manager making decisions across several holdings. Those are different reasons to buy, even when the cheques look nearly identical.

The insurer and the owner

Great-West Lifeco (TSX: GWO) earns from insurance, retirement and wealth businesses. That gives shareholders exposure to the money people save for retirement and the coverage they buy along the way. Its latest results showed base earnings of $1.48 per share, an adjusted measure that I’d compare with its quarterly payment.

The current $0.67 dividend takes about 45% of those quarterly base earnings. That leaves room for other needs, including capital to support insurance policies. A single quarter can’t tell me how much cushion will be there after claims and if financial markets go against it.

Power Corporation of Canada (TSX: POW) gives me exposure to Great-West alongside interests in wealth management and other assets. It reported $112.94 per share in adjusted net asset value at the end of its second quarter. Against the recent share price of $91.36, that’s a gap of about 19%, using the earlier asset estimate as a reference.

Considerations

Power’s $0.67 quarterly dividend works out to $2.67 annualized, or about 2.9%. Great-West’s annualized $2.68 works out to about 3% at its November 6 price of $90.17. I wouldn’t make a choice over a few dollars of annual income on a $10,000 position.

I’d own Great-West if I want the earnings of the insurer and a clearer view of the dividend’s coverage. Power would interest me more if the discount widened and I was happy owning the other assets for years. I’d check its next asset value update before treating an old estimate as money I can buy for less today.

With the direct insurer, I’d spend more time watching the capital it has available after meeting its obligations. A good year for investment markets can make the results look easy. I’d want the dividend to have room in a year when markets offer less help.

If I held both inside a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), I’d count the overlap when sizing each position. Higher claims or weaker markets can affect Great-West’s earnings and the value of Power’s investment at the same time.

Bottom line

All taken together, I’d buy Great-West for a straightforward retirement income position. Power would move up my list if I could get its other holdings at a price that gives me a reason to own them for their own sake.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

man calculates finances
Dividend Stocks

What $50,000 Across 3 Dividend Stocks Could Add to Your Retirement Budget

A utility, a pipeline and a railway show how $50,000 could start paying part of the retirement budget.

Read more »

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

Down Day, Wish List Ready: 3 Canadian Stocks to Keep Handy If You Have Cash to Invest

Market swings can catch you off guard, but be ready to take advantage of buying opportunities in a down day.

Read more »

Canadian Red maple leaves seamless wallpaper pattern
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Use a $20,000 TFSA to Start an Income Plan, Not Replace a Salary

A $20,000 TFSA can start paying part of a bill. Reinvesting those first dividends can give it a bigger job…

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Strategy: How to Earn $500 a Month in Tax-Free Dividend Income

Canadians can earn $500 in tax-free dividend income or another desired amount every month using a simple TFSA strategy.

Read more »

doctor uses telehealth
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Investors: This Monthly Dividend Stock Yields 7.6%

This REIT offers investors a monthly yield investors and a regular and frequent passive income stream to supplement their regular…

Read more »

shopper chooses vegetables at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

Loblaw vs. Empire: Which Grocery Stock Would I Choose for Long-Term Growth?

Both grocers benefit from repeat shoppers. I’d give Loblaw the edge for the ways it can earn more from those…

Read more »

ETF is short for exchange traded fund, a popular investment choice for Canadians
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX ETFs to Buy and Hold in a TFSA Forever

Looking for top TSX ETFs for your TFSA? Explore how VFV and VDY combine U.S. stock exposure and Canadian dividends…

Read more »

Retirees sip their morning coffee outside.
Dividend Stocks

2 Canadian Stocks to Buy and Hold for 20 More Years

CP Rail (TSX:CP) and another outstanding Canadian stock that's more than worth holding for many decades.

Read more »