Enbridge Is Solid, But the Bank of Scotia Has More Upside: Here’s Why I’d Buy It First

With improving fundamentals, an encouraging growth outlook, and a reasonable valuation, Scotiabank offers a more compelling investment opportunity than Enbridge.

Key Points
  • Enbridge offers stable earnings and a strong dividend yield but faces near-term pressures from interest rate concerns and regulatory challenges.
  • In contrast, Scotiabank presents a compelling investment, with diversified revenue streams, a strategic growth strategy, share buybacks, and a strong dividend track record, potentially delivering sustainable long-term growth.

Enbridge (TSX: ENB) operates a diversified energy infrastructure business with more than 200 assets. About 98% of its earnings come from regulated operations and long-term take-or-pay contracts, and about 80% benefit from inflation-indexed mechanisms. This resilient business model reduces its exposure to commodity price volatility and broader macroeconomic uncertainties, supporting stable earnings and predictable cash flows.

Backed by these solid fundamentals, Enbridge has delivered a total shareholder return of over 850% over the past two decades, or an annualized return of about 11.9%. The company also boasts an impressive dividend track record, having paid dividends since 1953 and increased its annual payout for 31 consecutive years. It currently offers an attractive forward dividend yield of 5.7%.

Despite these strengths, Enbridge has faced selling pressure recently, with its share price declining 15.6% from its May highs. Concerns over potentially higher interest rates, which could increase financing costs for its capital-intensive operations, along with persistent regulatory and legal uncertainties surrounding its Line 5 pipeline, appear to have dampened investor sentiment. Although Enbridge’s resilient business model and attractive dividend yield support its long-term investment appeal, these near-term uncertainties could continue to weigh on its stock performance.

Against this backdrop, I believe Bank of Nova Scotia (TSX: BNS) offers a more compelling buying opportunity, supported by improving operating and financial performance, a strengthening balance sheet, and an increasingly favourable business outlook.

Piggy bank on a flying rocket

Source: Getty Images

BNS’s business outlook and growth prospects

Scotiabank provides a broad range of financial services across multiple geographic markets, generating revenue from diversified business segments. This diversified operating model supports relatively stable earnings and cash flows across economic cycles. Over the past two decades, Scotiabank has delivered a total shareholder return of approximately 585%, representing an annualized return of 10.1%. The bank also boasts an impressive dividend track record, having paid dividends since 1833 and increased its payout at an annualized rate of 4.5% over the last decade. It currently offers an attractive forward dividend yield of 3.5%.

Meanwhile, elevated oil prices could sustain inflationary pressures, prompting central banks to remain cautious about easing monetary policy. A prolonged period of relatively higher interest rates could support Scotiabank’s net interest margins, although elevated borrowing costs could also weigh on loan demand. Additionally, the bank is optimizing its business portfolio by expanding its more profitable North American operations while reducing exposure to less profitable Latin American markets. This strategic realignment could enhance operational efficiency, improve profitability, and strengthen earnings quality over time.

Furthermore, Scotiabank expanded its share repurchase authorization from 15 million to 40 million shares and had already repurchased about 13 million shares as of August 31. The expanded program could reduce its outstanding share count by about 3.3% from its March starting level, potentially supporting earnings-per-share growth and enhancing shareholder value.

Given its diversified revenue streams, strategic growth initiatives, improving operational performance, and commitment to shareholder returns, I believe Scotiabank is well positioned to deliver sustainable long-term growth and is an attractive investment at current levels.

Investors’ takeaway

Supported by its strong financial performance and improving investor sentiment, Scotiabank has delivered an impressive year-to-date total shareholder return of 35.6%. Despite this rally, the stock still trades at a reasonable forward price-to-earnings mutliple of 14.1, suggesting its valuation may not fully reflect its growth prospects. Given its improving fundamentals, encouraging growth outlook, and reasonable valuation, I believe Scotiabank is well-positioned to maintain its upward momentum in the coming quarters, making it a more compelling investment opportunity than Enbridge, which continues to face near-term headwinds.

Fool contributor Rajiv Nanjapla has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Enbridge. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

young people stare at smartphones
Dividend Stocks

2 TSX Stocks Under $100 Worth a Look

Quebecor (TSX:QBR.B) and another sub-$100 stock that looks seriously undervalued with a strong, growing dividend.

Read more »

senior man smiles next to a light-filled window
Dividend Stocks

A Tailor-Made TFSA Stock With a 4.6% Yield and Monthly Payouts

Sienna Senior Living can help turn part of a TFSA into monthly spending money, and fuller residences give its dividend…

Read more »

man shops at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

Dollarama vs. Loblaw: Which Stock Has the Better Case When Households Cut Back?

Dollarama is drawing more visits from value shoppers. I’d choose Loblaw if I had to buy one at today's prices.

Read more »

Concept of rent, search, purchase real estate, REIT
Dividend Stocks

A Perfect TFSA Stock: 5.3% Payout Each Month

BSR REIT pays a monthly distribution yielding about 5.3%. See why this Texas apartment landlord could anchor your TFSA income…

Read more »

arrows hit bullseye on target
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Build a $100-a-Month TFSA Income Plan Before Aiming for $1,000

A $100 monthly target gives you a reason to start. It also lets you see what building a $1,000-a-month portfolio…

Read more »

man in business suit pulls a piece out of wobbly wooden tower
Dividend Stocks

Overlooked Canadian Stocks Worth a Closer Look

Explore overlooked Canadian stocks North West Company and West Fraser, with essential retail demand and potential housing recovery upside.

Read more »

Happy golf player walks the course
Dividend Stocks

I’d Split $30,000 Across 3 TSX Stocks for $941 a Year in Passive Income: Here Are the Picks

Three businesses could turn a $30,000 budget into about $941 a year. I’d spread the money across companies that earn…

Read more »

infrastructure like highways enables economic growth
Dividend Stocks

The 1 Stock I’d Hold in a TFSA for the Long Term

This utility stock is an excellent TFSA long-term holding, especially if purchased on meaningful market corrections.

Read more »