Your GIC Is Maturing as Rates Rise: I Wouldn’t Automatically Lock It Up Again

A maturing GIC may offer an attractive guaranteed rate, but long-term investors could sacrifice considerably more growth by renewing automatically.

Key Points
  • Higher GIC rates make guaranteed returns attractive again, particularly for money needed within several years.
  • Long-term investors should compare that certainty with the greater growth potential of stocks.
  • BMO’s dividend yield is below leading GIC rates, but earnings growth and capital gains can add another source of return.

A maturing guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) comes with a powerful temptation: do absolutely nothing.

The bank already has your money. The renewal offer lands in your inbox and rates look respectable again. A few clicks later, your cash disappears behind another five-year lock without ever having to make an actual investing decision.

That convenience has become more tempting as bond yields have pushed higher. The Bank of Canada has kept its policy rate at 2.25%, yet longer-term market rates have risen. Some five-year GIC offers are now around 4.25%.

For money you absolutely can’t afford to lose, that’s a pretty attractive deal. For money you won’t need for another decade, I wouldn’t automatically take it.

customer uses bank ATM

Source: Getty Images

Safe isn’t enough

A GIC gives you something stocks can’t: certainty. Hold a non-redeemable GIC until maturity and you know what your principal and interest should look like at the end. That makes GICs useful for a home down payment, upcoming retirement spending or any goal where a stock market selloff could ruin your timing.

The problem begins when investors confuse “safe” with “best.” Lock $10,000 into a five-year GIC at 4.25%, and it could grow to roughly $12,315 if interest compounds annually. Nothing wrong with that. Yet inflation will nibble away at some of the purchasing power, and your upside stops at the agreed rate.

That opportunity cost becomes much more important when you’re investing inside a TFSA. Interest, dividends and capital gains can all grow tax-free in the account, provided you stay within your available contribution room. So if the GIC is maturing inside a TFSA and the money won’t be needed for years, I’d at least ask whether part of it deserves a longer runway.

Buy the bank

Bank of Montreal (TSX: BMO) offers an amusing alternative. Your bank may be perfectly happy to sell you another GIC. You could instead consider owning a small piece of the bank collecting all those deposits.

BMO operates Canadian and U.S. personal and commercial banking businesses alongside wealth management and capital markets. Its Bank of the West acquisition gave it a much larger U.S. footprint, although making that expansion more profitable remains one of management’s biggest jobs.

Recent results suggest the machinery is moving in the right direction. BMO’s third-quarter adjusted earnings per share climbed 22% year over year to $3.96. Its Common Equity Tier 1 ratio, which measures the capital cushion available to absorb losses, remained a healthy 13%.

The bank also pays a quarterly dividend of $1.71 per share, or $6.84 annually. At a recent price around $235, that works out to a yield near 2.9%. Yes, that’s lower than a good GIC rate, but isn’t necessarily a problem. Unlike GIC interest, a dividend can increase. The company can also grow earnings, repurchase shares and become more valuable over time. That combination is why strong Canadian dividend stocks make more sense for money with a long enough horizon.

What a decade can do

BMO traded around $85.83 in early October 2016. At roughly $235 today, its share price has increased at an annualized rate of about 10.6%, even before including dividends. If that historical rate continues, and there’s absolutely no guarantee it will, the difference becomes substantial.

STARTING AMOUNTASSUMED ANNUAL GROWTHAFTER 5 YEARSAFTER 10 YEARS
$10,00010.6%$16,563$27,434

That isn’t a forecast, but BMO has already enjoyed a powerful run, including a gain of more than 30% this year, so expecting another identical decade would be asking quite a lot. That brings us to the catch.

BMO trades around 14.5 times forward earnings, so investors aren’t exactly finding it in the bargain bin. Its U.S. business still needs to deliver stronger returns, while a Canadian slowdown could increase credit losses.

Bottom line

A roughly 4.25% guaranteed return deserves consideration, especially when protecting principal matters more than maximizing growth.

Yet a five-year renewal is still a five-year decision. If your goal sits much further into the future, locking every dollar away could mean protecting yourself from volatility while also protecting yourself from considerably more upside.

BMO won’t provide a guarantee. Over a decade, however, growing earnings, dividends and share value give it something a GIC never will. That’s room for the return to get bigger.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

A TFSA Loss Doesn’t Create New Room: Here’s the Rebuilding Plan I’d Use

A falling investment won’t create TFSA contribution room. I’d rebuild using the room I actually have and a portfolio that…

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Colliers Stock: The Engineering Business Behind the Real Estate Name

Colliers still earns from real estate, but engineering now gives investors a second business to follow.

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Telus vs. Fortis: Which Stock Would I Choose for a More Dependable Payout?

Telus pays more today after its reset. I’d choose Fortis for the payout I’d rather count on over several years.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Use a $5,000 Starting TFSA to Build My First Dividend Income

A $5,000 TFSA won’t replace a paycheque. It can start buying small pieces of the income you want later.

Read more »

Rocket lift off through the clouds
Tech Stocks

MDA Space Stock: Big Opportunities, but What Should Investors Pay?

MDA’s backlog gives investors work to follow. The share price asks how much of that work will turn into profit…

Read more »

c
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian National vs. Waste Connections: Which Stock Would I Hold for Steadier Growth?

Waste Connections has the steadier demand story for me. Canadian National offers a lower price relative to earnings and a…

Read more »

how to save money
Energy Stocks

Want $12,000 a Year in Dividends? Here’s the Capital the Goal Requires

A $12,000 dividend target can look more manageable once you see the required balance and how much monthly deposits can…

Read more »

Offshore wind turbine farm at sunset
Energy Stocks

Northland Power Stock: Would I Buy the Dividend or Wait for Better Cash Flow?

Northland pays monthly after cutting its dividend. I’d wait for more cash after project spending before giving it a job…

Read more »