Bank Stocks or a Dividend ETF? Where I’d Put $25,000 for Retirement Income

Two bank stocks can pay a decent retirement cheque. I’d give the next $25,000 to a dividend ETF if I already own plenty of Canadian banks.

Key Points
  • The illustration compares two big banks with a monthly dividend ETF.
  • The fund gives you exposure to more industries and still holds Canadian financials.
  • I’d check what I already own before adding another layer of the same banks.

A Canadian investor can end up with bank shares the way a kitchen ends up with mugs. One or two seemed reasonable. Then another arrived in an index fund, and suddenly there’s an entire shelf of them. I’d check the shelf before using $25,000 to buy more retirement income.

open bank vault

Source: Getty Images

How much you want

Owning bank shares directly lets me choose which banks I own and how much of each. I can compare loan losses, dividends and what I’m paying for earnings. If I pick two banks, both can still feel the same Canadian slowdown.

An exchange-traded fund (ETF), can hold several dozen stocks in a single purchase. The management fee and other fund expenses reduce the return. I’d check the holdings and sector weights to see what I’m paying to own, since a Canadian dividend fund can still have a lot in financials and energy.

I’d compare a full year of payments before putting a fixed transfer into my budget. A fund that pays one larger or smaller distribution can still deliver a similar annual amount. The recent payment is a starting point for the comparison, and I’d leave a little room until I’ve seen the cash land.

I’d also check how it pays. A bank usually pays quarterly. An ETF may distribute monthly, and the amount can change. In a taxable account, a fund’s distribution can include different kinds of income. I’d decide whether the mix and frequency suit my retirement plan before comparing what lands in cash.

Banks and beyond

Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX: TD) pays $1.12 a share quarterly. Its Canadian and U.S. banking businesses give it several sources of earnings. I’d watch the loan book and the progress of the U.S. business before relying on the dividend to grow at any particular pace.

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX: CM) pays $1.07 a share quarterly. I’d compare its loan losses and earnings with TD’s. At recent prices the yields were close to 2.5% and 2.6%, respectively. Owning both spreads company risk while leaving plenty of exposure to banking.

The iShares S&P/TSX Composite High Dividend Index ETF (TSX: XEI) holds companies across several industries and pays monthly. It holds financials as well, so I’d count them when adding up my exposure. A broader fund can be a better fit if I have too much riding on any one bank.

Considerations

Here’s the direct-stock option on two $12,500 budgets, followed by the fund on a separate $25,000 budget at recent prices.

COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
TD$175.8771$4.48$318.08Quarterly$12,486.77
CM$164.2476$4.28$325.28Quarterly$12,482.24
TOTAL—147—$643.36Quarterly$24,969.01
COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
XEI$40.24621$1.32$819.72Monthly$24,989.04

I’d choose the ETF if this were most of my Canadian income allocation. The fund’s latest payment works out to roughly $820 a year in the example, versus $643 from the two stocks. I’d still check the sector mix and understand that a higher distribution can change as the holdings and payments change. I’d also think about how I’d use new contributions.

If my direct bank holdings grew faster than everything else, I could add to another industry without selling a share. In a fund, the index handles the rebalancing, and I’m paying for that simplicity along with the wider spread of holdings.

I’d use direct shares if the rest of my portfolio already provided broad exposure and I wanted to own a particular bank. Either way, I’d look at how ETFs work and check the overlap with my Canadian dividend stocks before making the purchase.

Bottom line

I’d put the $25,000 in XEI for a first income allocation or to reduce reliance on individual banks. I can still buy a bank separately when I have a reason to own more of it.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

Trans Alaska Pipeline with Autumn Colors
Energy Stocks

How Much Would You Need in Pembina to Average $300 a Month?

Pembina pays quarterly. Averaging $300 a month at its latest rate would take about $85,000 at writing.

Read more »

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

What $12,000 in Canadian Utilities Could Add to Your Annual Income

At its recent price, Canadian Utilities could turn a $12,000 budget into about $418 a year in dividends.

Read more »

woman checks off all the boxes
Stocks for Beginners

TFSA Withdrawal Rules Every Canadian Investor Should Know

Looking to make a withdrawal from your TFSA? Here are some guidelines to keep in mind before you do.

Read more »

Super sized rock trucks take a load of platinum rich rock into the crusher.
Stocks for Beginners

Finning Stock: Can Canada’s Construction Plans Turn Into Shareholder Returns?

Finning can sell equipment before a project opens and service it long after. I’d watch the second sale as closely…

Read more »

man shops at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

Dollarama vs. Loblaw: Which Stock Has the Better Case When Households Cut Back?

Dollarama is drawing more visits from value shoppers. I’d choose Loblaw if I had to buy one at today's prices.

Read more »

senior man smiles next to a light-filled window
Dividend Stocks

A Tailor-Made TFSA Stock With a 4.6% Yield and Monthly Payouts

Sienna Senior Living can help turn part of a TFSA into monthly spending money, and fuller residences give its dividend…

Read more »

arrows hit bullseye on target
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Build a $100-a-Month TFSA Income Plan Before Aiming for $1,000

A $100 monthly target gives you a reason to start. It also lets you see what building a $1,000-a-month portfolio…

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Energy Stocks

Your RRIF Needs Cash, Not Just a Big Balance: Here’s the Dividend Plan I’d Use

A big RRIF balance doesn’t tell you how much cash you’ll have when the minimum withdrawal comes due. I’d build…

Read more »